Goodreads Librarians Group discussion

This topic is about
Mr. Softee
Questions (not edit requests)
>
Confusing ACE situation
date
newest »


As for the edition originally marked kindle with an ISBN13, changing it to ebook was absolutely right, so no changes needed there.
The rest of the editions look OK to me.
I'm not sure I follow the second half of your post, though. I suggest you look over the changes I made and see if there are any more that need to be done.
Books mentioned in this topic
Mr. Softee (other topics)Mr. Swirlee (other topics)
When Mr. Swirlee editions were added, one was listed as a "Kindle edition" but used an ISBN13. (The ISBN10, ISBN13, and ASIN are all printed inside the book.) I saw this edition first, and so switched the format to ebook and updated the rest of the information.
But then I found the other Mr. Swirlee edition, which had no format listed, listed the page count from the new Mr. Swirlee Kindle edition, but included a Mr. Softee publication date. It lists no ASIN or ISBN, but its data was pulled from Onix Smashwords.
So, I don't know if the Kindle-labeled edition with the ISBN should remain a Kindle edition, and be updated to be the ACE for the re-used ASIN, while the other edition becomes the ISBN-labeled ebook, or if the edition with the ISBN should be listed as the ebook edition and the no-format, no identifying number edition should become the Kindle ACE for the re-used ASIN.
Sorry it's confusing!