The Procrastinators Book Club discussion

note: This topic has been closed to new comments.
50 views
★Buddy/Group Read Retirement★ > The Gentleman's Guide to Vice and Virtue (November 2018) Buddy Read Discussion

Comments Showing 1-24 of 24 (24 new)    post a comment »
dateUp arrow    newest »

message 1: by Althea ☾ (last edited Oct 20, 2018 08:57AM) (new)

Althea ☾ (themoonwholistens) | 1115 comments Welcome to the Buddy Read for The Gentleman's Guide to Vice and Virtue The Gentleman's Guide to Vice and Virtue (Montague Siblings, #1) by Mackenzi Lee ! This thread will officially be open to discussions in November. Please keep in mind that spoilers are allowed in this thread but only up to the group's current reading place. Participants can always have the scheduling adjusted. Do not spoil the book if you've read further than the group. The Buddy Read Discussion schedule is as follows:

[WEEK OF 11/1]
✧ 11/1 Part One: Chapter 1
✧ 11/2 Part One: Chapter 2
✧ 11/3 Part One: Chapter 3

[WEEK OF 11/4]
✧ 11/4 Part One: Chapter 4
✧ 11/5 Part One: Chapter 5
✧ 11/6 Part One: Chapter 6
✧ 11/7 Part One: Chapter 7
✧ 11/8 Part Two: Chapter 8
✧ 11/9 Part Two: Chapter 9
✧ 11/10 Part Two: Chapter 10

[WEEK OF 11/11]
✧ 11/11 Part Two: Chapter 11
✧ 11/12 Part Two: Chapter 12
✧ 11/13 Part Two: Chapter 13
✧ 11/14 Part Two: Chapter 14
✧ 11/15 Part Three: Chapter 15
✧ 11/16 Part Three: Chapter 16
✧ 11/17 Part Three: Chapter 17

[WEEK OF 11/18]
✧ 11/18 Part Three: Chapter 18
✧ 11/19 Part Three: Chapter 19
✧ 11/20 Part Three: Chapter 20
✧ 11/21 Part Four: Chapter 21
✧ 11/22 Part Four: Chapter 22
✧ 11/23 Part Four: Chapter 23
✧ 11/24 Part Four: Chapter 24

[WEEK OF 11/25]
✧ 11/25 Part Five: Chapter 25
✧ 11/26 Part Five: Chapter 26
✧ 11/27 Part Five: Chapter 27
✧ 11/28 Part Five: Chapter 28
✧ 11/29 Part Five: Chapter 29
✧ 11/30 Part Five: Chapter 30


PARTICIPANTS:
Dellaknowsdobby
Audrey
neeks


Dellaknowsdobby | -12 comments Thanks so much for making this, Althea! I'm looking forward to reading with y'all! :)


message 3: by Althea ☾ (new)

Althea ☾ (themoonwholistens) | 1115 comments no prob ;) happy reading!


message 4: by ikram (new)

ikram (basingse) | 25 comments thank you for making this!


message 5: by kimberlina (new)

kimberlina (capricorns) oof i’ve been wanting to read this for the longest time, can’t wait to start it!


message 6: by Anna (last edited Oct 29, 2018 06:30AM) (new)

Anna Thank you for making this! I think I'll be taking part in this...I've been meaning to read the book for a while now, so this would give me a good opportunity to read it and talk about it with people. :)


message 7: by ikram (new)

ikram (basingse) | 25 comments hello guys! happy reading!! i'll start reading this one later this evening


Dellaknowsdobby | -12 comments I've gotten a little ahead of schedule...I just finished chapter 4 :) I can't wait to discuss it with y'all! Have y'all started? I'm really enjoying it! :)
-Della


message 9: by ikram (new)

ikram (basingse) | 25 comments I'm currently on Chapter 8! What do you think about the book so far?


message 10: by Dellaknowsdobby (new)

Dellaknowsdobby | -12 comments I've gotten more than a little ahead of schedule...Just finished chapter 14. :) What do y'all think of Monty?


message 11: by ikram (new)

ikram (basingse) | 25 comments I think Monty is reckless and rebellious--the product of people (especially his father) seeing him as the next heir of his father. So far, I think he's sick of the expectation people give to him; Monty has to be the a gentle, soft-spoken aristocrat, and he thinks everyone forgets about who he is at the moment; a teenager. Monty just wants to live like a normal teenager should be, but of course he can't have that, can he? That's why he rebels.

Yet, at the same time, he also fears of being disowned by his own parents. In which I found pretty irony to what Monty portrays himself in front of anyone.


message 12: by ikram (new)

ikram (basingse) | 25 comments I also kinda feel like.. Felicity will intervene in Percy/Monty's relationship. What do you think? There's no way she travels with them and not even think there's something happening between those two.


message 13: by Anna (new)

Anna I'm only chapter 4....so far I like it. I wish I was farther along with it but whenever I try to read it before I fall asleep...I fall asleep while reading it.


message 14: by ikram (new)

ikram (basingse) | 25 comments The problem was the same with me when I first picked the book. The plot is too slow and boring for my liking, it's almost like a bedtime story... it's such a shame because the characters are amazing.


message 15: by Dellaknowsdobby (new)

Dellaknowsdobby | -12 comments neeks wrote: "I also kinda feel like.. Felicity will intervene in Percy/Monty's relationship. What do you think? There's no way she travels with them and not even think there's something happening between those ..."

Yeah! I would have to agree. It'll be interesting to see what happens!


message 16: by Dellaknowsdobby (new)

Dellaknowsdobby | -12 comments neeks wrote: "The problem was the same with me when I first picked the book. The plot is too slow and boring for my liking, it's almost like a bedtime story... it's such a shame because the characters are amazing."

In the beginning, it was a bit slow; however, I didn't find it boring. Now that it's picking up pace, I'm really enjoying the plot.

The characters are amazing! Of course, I love Monty and his recklessness and mild arrogance; he's SO flawed which makes me love him even more! Percy is an absolute sweetheart - he must be protected at all costs ;-) But, Felicity is my current favorite! She's such a strong, smart, and feisty character!!


message 17: by ikram (new)

ikram (basingse) | 25 comments I also feel bad about Felicity. Just because she's woman, she doesn't have the same privilege as Percy and Monty. She's strong and smart and feisty, I agree. It's such a shame that everyone doesn't look at her the same way as Monty and Percy.


message 18: by ikram (new)

ikram (basingse) | 25 comments Hello! How's everyone been doing? I'm sorry I'm a bit slow on this since I'm currently a little busy with my job.

How do you think it'd end?


message 19: by Dellaknowsdobby (new)

Dellaknowsdobby | -12 comments Hey, y'all! So, I've only got 4 more chapters to go...Where are y'all at? I wanna make sure I don't spoil anything!
-Della :}


message 20: by ikram (new)

ikram (basingse) | 25 comments I'm already at chapter 27!!!


message 21: by ikram (new)

ikram (basingse) | 25 comments I finished the book! How do you guys feel about it?


message 22: by Anna (new)

Anna neeks wrote: "I finished the book! How do you guys feel about it?"

I finished it a few days ago. I thought that it wasn't worth the hype, to be honest. It wasn't bad, but it wasn't great, either.


message 23: by ikram (new)

ikram (basingse) | 25 comments Anna wrote: "neeks wrote: "I finished the book! How do you guys feel about it?"

I finished it a few days ago. I thought that it wasn't worth the hype, to be honest. It wasn't bad, but it wasn't great, either."


I agree, I have mixed feeling about the book. I love the historical setting and slow burn relationship, but the plot it's a bit slow in the beginning but it's rushed on the few last chapters


message 24: by Anna (new)

Anna neeks wrote: "Anna wrote: "neeks wrote: "I finished the book! How do you guys feel about it?"

I finished it a few days ago. I thought that it wasn't worth the hype, to be honest. It wasn't bad, but it wasn't gr..."


I also think that she threw too many things into the plot.


back to top
This topic has been frozen by the moderator. No new comments can be posted.