Support for Indie Authors discussion
Writing Process & Programs
>
mutual beta reader?
date
newest »

message 1:
by
Tomas, Wandering dreamer
(new)
Oct 01, 2018 11:04PM

reply
|
flag

Jay wrote: "Beta readers, ideally, aren't writers. And you don't want them to be, so you can get the average reader's reaction to the prose, rather than, "This is how I would have done it," of someone who writes fiction.
What you're really looking for isn't beta readers. You're trying to form a small critique group. "
The stuff quoted above is fine, but the rest of your post was off topic. You're making a lot of presumptions about the poster and lecturing him needlessly on his writing.
What you're really looking for isn't beta readers. You're trying to form a small critique group. "
The stuff quoted above is fine, but the rest of your post was off topic. You're making a lot of presumptions about the poster and lecturing him needlessly on his writing.
Jay wrote: "You're making a lot of presumptions about the poster and lecturing him needlessly on his writing.
Presumption? No. It was a careful analysis..."
The poster wasn't asking for an analysis. He's looking for beta readers. If you want to read his book and then contact him with your analysis, fine. Doing it here is off topic.
Presumption? No. It was a careful analysis..."
The poster wasn't asking for an analysis. He's looking for beta readers. If you want to read his book and then contact him with your analysis, fine. Doing it here is off topic.