November 2016 Moms Book Club discussion
Before We Were Yours
>
Question for those finished #SPOILER
date
newest »
newest »
message 1:
by
Andrea
(new)
Feb 07, 2018 09:33AM
Ok did anyone else suspect that Judy was one of the twins? I'm not sure if I missed a birthday or missed a big clue...I had to literally hold up my eyelids some nights so I could have missed something, but for me personally, it was a HUGE shock!
reply
|
flag
Mod
I guessed it when they brought the papers from the envelope to May and she shut down. I had a suspicion earlier on, but I can't recall. I think I was guessing that Judy was the girl baby and Trent SR. was the boy baby. But I went around and around with Judy might be Fern, or even Lark too.
I thought Trent was the twin too until May commented that he was Stevie. And I was thinking Avery can't be attraced to Trent jr because they are related! But I had an inkling there was some connection with Judy..
Mod
Michele, I had some kind of suspicion that they would end up being related, so every time they hinted at a romantic connection, I was like NO NO NO that's probably your cousin!! Thankfully, they aren't!!
Mod
I though Judy was Ferm for a while. But then when it turned out Fern and May were adopted together I went to Lark. But then when Avery looked at the documents in the envelope I figured the twins had survived.
No joke, I was going to be pissed if Trent and Judy had been the twins because that meant Trent III and Avery couldn't be together. But I thought Judy was Camellia for a while. I did not even pick up on the boy birth information - that just confused me more but looking back it was obvious now.
I also thought Judy could be Camelia, she had some of the troublemaker qualities and Fern and Lark were pretty quiet girls. I was not overly surprised it was the baby twin though.
