The Sword and Laser discussion
note: This topic has been closed to new comments.
What Else Are You Reading?
>
What Else Are You Reading - January 2018
date
newest »

message 151:
by
Phil
(new)
Jan 25, 2018 10:59PM

reply
|
flag

The last JKR's non-Harry Potter book I read was Casual Vacancy and I hated it so hopefully this one is better. Really liked the TV series though.

The last JKR's non-Harry Potter book I read was Casual Vacancy and I hated it so hopefully this one is better."
The Casual Vacancy is the only Rowling book I've not really enjoyed. It's a very different kind of book for her. There's no single hero/protagonist and no real mission or goal to be achieved. It's a nicely observed slice-of-life kind of thing, but ultimately didn't really entertain, perhaps because most of the events are pretty grim.
On the other hand, I love love love the Cormoran Strike books! They exist in the small intersection on the Venn diagram of stuff that I read and stuff my wife reads and if it wasn't for Kindle we'd be fighting over who's turn it was to get the book!





Reading Half a King.
Less grim dark than your usual Joe Abercrombie.
So far I'm enjoying it. Joe has a 100% record with me. :-)
Less grim dark than your usual Joe Abercrombie.
So far I'm enjoying it. Joe has a 100% record with me. :-)

The Long Earth
And non-genre Atonement.
Plus catching up on 2000AD

I got the third just to finish it out. This one continues the musings of the second book, on the man/machine interface, and what exactly makes a human being. There's even more pointless violence, this time with otherwise sympathetic characters doing unsympathetic things. For the decent space opera I would give this book three stars, but only for that. There are some interesting moments involving engineering as space battle tactic, and some orbital mechanic considerations that ring interesting, but they don't make up for the dull plot and characterization.
Overall it feels like a "side" project that a publisher indulges to let the author stretch his wings from the moneymaking series, like Butcher's non-Dresden books. In this case the main series is the many Polity books, which are all at least entertaining, most good potboiler page turners, and occasionally excellent. "The Owner" series feels like it is some half-baked ideas with ultraviolence thrown in because plot. Well, if it helps Asher in turning out good Polity books then I'm all for it. But had I realized what I was getting into I probably would have given this trilogy a miss.

Delighted to read this. I read some of Asher's Polity books a few years back . . . and then stopped, with some regret. Asher can write one hell of a good story - but then he always seems to spoil it with too much (or too excessive) violence.

I also dipped my toe into the Star Wars novel world and read Thrawn by Timothy Zahn (thank you again for people's suggestions on another thread!). I really enjoyed it and found it interesting to read a story from the Empire's perspective. Those pesky rebels! This year I plan to read the new canon stuff in story chronological order starting with Catalyst: A Rogue One Novel and watching the Rebels seasons where they fit in between stories.

Catching up on my reviews for the last 2 weeks:
The Infernal Battalion - ★★★★★ - I think this is one of the best fantasy series of the last few years. (My Review)
Three Parts Dead - ★★★½☆ - Interesting start to the series, which is a good thing since I bought 5 books when they were on sale last year. (My Review)
Points of Impact - Another decent entry in this series, but not as much happened as I might have liked. ★★★☆☆ (or maybe ★★★½☆ ) - (My Review)
The Infernal Battalion - ★★★★★ - I think this is one of the best fantasy series of the last few years. (My Review)
Three Parts Dead - ★★★½☆ - Interesting start to the series, which is a good thing since I bought 5 books when they were on sale last year. (My Review)
Points of Impact - Another decent entry in this series, but not as much happened as I might have liked. ★★★☆☆ (or maybe ★★★½☆ ) - (My Review)

Rick wrote: "Rob - I like the entire Craft Sequence from Max. However, you have an interesting choice. You can read them in publication order (which I did and which works well) OR you can read them in internal ..."
Interesting. I always read everything in publication order. Or at least on my first read.
Interesting. I always read everything in publication order. Or at least on my first read.

Just keep in mind that the title numbering is actually the internal chronological sequence of events. The reason it works to read in publication order, though, is that the books aren't a linear arc with the same characters throughout but jump around and show us different bits of the world in different locations and with mostly different characters.

Travel Light by Naomi Mitchison. Historical Fantasy. This is really a novella. It's billed as a Children's Fantasy, which I guess I can see (it was written in the '50s), but I really didn't end up liking it--I thought the latter half of the story went in a weird direction, and the finale was a bit "huh." I had picked this up a couple years ago in a Small Beer Press Humble Bundle.
That's Not My Monster by Fiona Watt. Fantasy. A children's board book, each page shows a monster (but not YOURS) who has some body party that's too fluffy or scaly or something. The final page finally has your monster. Riveting. LOL. My son doesn't care, but he's too young for this book (6 weeks old), oh well.
The Wind in the Willows by Kenneth Grahame. Fantasy (possibly Post-Apocalyptic?) This started off a bit slow, but I always found the Mr. Toad chapters hilarious (and read them out loud to my wife). I can see why people call it "cozy," though I'm not sure quite sure I would (since I'm not a Brit in love with the countryside), but some chapters were quite affecting (like the one with Otter's missing kid).

Since I'd already read Frankenstein, I wanted to read a sci-fi book next to get a jump on the reading challenge. So I picked Ahsoka.
Misti wrote: " I wanted to read a sci-fi book next to get a jump on the reading challenge. So I picked Ahsoka. ."
I really enjoyed that. Did you watch the Clone Wars show?
I really enjoyed that. Did you watch the Clone Wars show?

I really enjoyed that. Did you watch the Clone Wars show?"
Yes, I'm a big fan of the show; Rebels, too. :)

Thanks, Stephen! I'm actually following the timeline in the link you posted in the Star Wars thread, so will definitely read A New Dawn before watching the series. My order right now is: Catalyst, Lords of the Sith, Tarkin, A New Dawn. The new Solo movie coming out in May is supposed to be between A New Dawn and Rebels Season 1; so I might aim to read the above before May, watch the Solo movie and then hit Rebels.
Misti wrote: "Rob wrote: "Misti wrote: " I wanted to read a sci-fi book next to get a jump on the reading challenge. So I picked Ahsoka. ."
I really enjoyed that. Did you watch the Clone Wars show?"
Yes, I'm a..."
Cool. That'll probably be important to enjoying the book I suspect. I'm hoping they do a live action Ahsoka movie at some point..
I really enjoyed that. Did you watch the Clone Wars show?"
Yes, I'm a..."
Cool. That'll probably be important to enjoying the book I suspect. I'm hoping they do a live action Ahsoka movie at some point..

In non-SF/F books, also ploughing (or plowing, if you prefer) through Dan Brown's Origin while my wife does the same. It's very much what you'd expect. He's got a formula that works for him and he's not about to change it!

Starting The City and the City by China Mieville. Interesting that it is my fourth detective novel this month.
Started reading A Wrinkle in Time.
This feels like something I should have read when I was in Primary School :-?
I'm only early on in the book, but this is skewing way younger than YA. More like 8 to 12 yo.
I will stick with it.
This feels like something I should have read when I was in Primary School :-?
I'm only early on in the book, but this is skewing way younger than YA. More like 8 to 12 yo.
I will stick with it.


That's very much the reaction I'm currently having to A Wizard of Earthsea
John (Taloni) wrote: "It's a "kid's story" the way Narnia is for kids. That is, with a lot of material only older people will fully understand."
As long as it doesn't get into the religious crap that Narnia did, I'll stick with it ;-)
As long as it doesn't get into the religious crap that Narnia did, I'll stick with it ;-)

This feels like something I should have read when I was in Primary School :-?
I'm only early on in the book, but this is skewing way younger than..."
The discussion I've read on it has highlighted the 'before YA was YA' argument - it's Middle Grade fiction but published before the distinction. I'm actually keen to give it a co-read with my 9 year old daughter, who is the target audience.

Elizabeth wrote: "The discussion I've read on it has highlighted the 'before YA was YA' argument - it's Middle Grade fiction but published before the distinction. I'm actually keen to give it a co-read with my 9 year old daughter, who is the target audience. "
That would be the best way to read it. I co-read the Harry Potter books with my god-daughter. That way we could discuss them.
She was 16 by the last book.
Middle Grade (or Primary School) is where I'd place it's target age range (about 8 to 12)
I'm not hating it. I just wish it was written for a slightly older audience.
That would be the best way to read it. I co-read the Harry Potter books with my god-daughter. That way we could discuss them.
She was 16 by the last book.
Middle Grade (or Primary School) is where I'd place it's target age range (about 8 to 12)
I'm not hating it. I just wish it was written for a slightly older audience.

Also for a bit of non-fiction read Do No Harm: Stories of Life, Death and Brain Surgery which was alternately funny and horrifying.
Now onto The Gentleman's Guide to Vice and Virtue - a bit of historical fiction with some slow-burn m/m romance thrown in.
I'm reading all sorts of things this month!

Touch - loved it! Sweeter, deeper and zippier than I anticipated. A great blend of the psychological and action.
Ninefox Gambit - so much fun! This is a space fantasy, but once you let go and let Kel, it's a delight.
The Golem and the Jinni - what a gorgeous book. Trike, you are so right, the setting was palpable.
The Tombs of Atuan - Unintentionally timely. I'm sadder now that I didn't love it, but will of course not let that deter me from finishing the series. (Re: discussion above, Wizard did feel "younger" but I was surprised by how much of it pertained to "bigger" concepts, and got quite scary for a children's book.)
Jews versus Aliens - lots of great stories, several that made me think and/or taught me new things!
and started The City & the City. In classic Mieville he's having too much fun setting up the "new" and taking his sweet @$$ time telling us about the real story. But I'm interested in that story, so we'll see how it goes.

I really enjoyed this. It had a similar feel to The Long Way to a Small, Angry Planet and examined a lot of different alien cultures. I think it would make a great club pick some day.
Starting The Hidden City.

The Core came through the library early, so I’ll be reading that along with
I also got a couple Black Panther collections, as well as I Kill Giants, plus The Art of Star Wars: The Last Jedi. Half my library holds came along at once. #GoodProblems
Allison wrote: "The Golem and the Jinni - what a gorgeous book. Trike, you are so right, the setting was palpable.."
Definitely a terrific book with an evocative and accurate setting.

I really enjoyed this. It had a similar feel to The Long Way to a Small, Angry Planet and examined a lot of different a..."
Czerneda is one of those authors who should be better known.

I read another palate-cleansing Brother Cadfael - The Sanctuary Sparrow - and started on Hild, both medieval historical fiction.
And in actual genre fic: The Girl in the Tower was as disappointing as I thought it would be when I checked in at the halfway point. The female lead forgot how to use her brain and instead was led by the nose by Boys into Obvious Traps. I won't be picking up the third novel in the trilogy. But, I started listening to Red Seas Under Red Skies, which balances out my S&L challenge reads with books I've read but don't count!

Currently reading The Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy to my 14 year old son. Only problem is he just wants me to read the book in one sitting. As god as I remembered. Guess I will have to read the whole trilogy (in five parts).


I really enjoyed that one, and it was the first Mieville I've read. He does take a long time to get to the point, and honestly I was really tired of reading the word "crosshatching" by the time I was done. But I found that the story and the setting really stuck with me. My copy had an author interview at the end in which he states that the story doesn't have any hidden meanings and readers should not attempt to metaphorically "decode" it. Wish that had been at the beginning and saved me a lot of time....

Haha! I actually just read through some reviews to see what others thought. This is one of that all of my friends seem to have liked, which I don't think has happened before. But everyone also agreed that it started slow. I'm about 25% in, so I'm gonna stick with it and wait for it to get cool. I think it's a neat concept, but (view spoiler)
This topic has been frozen by the moderator. No new comments can be posted.
Books mentioned in this topic
Authority (other topics)Acceptance (other topics)
The Hitchhiker’s Guide to the Galaxy (other topics)
Witchcraft, the Devil, and Emotions in Early Modern England (other topics)
Hild (other topics)
More...
Authors mentioned in this topic
Robert Rankin (other topics)Claudia Gray (other topics)
Claudia Gray (other topics)
Timothy Zahn (other topics)
Victor LaValle (other topics)
More...