Truly Madly Guilty Truly Madly Guilty question


88 views
Probably a terrorist !!!!! (P.433)
Haffoudhi Mehdi Haffoudhi Mehdi Nov 12, 2017 11:51AM
Me and my friend have had a big discussion about a line on page 433 (It was the big Arab guy or whatever nationality he was. Probably a terrorist) and we would like to hear from other fans of Liane's work what their opinion is !!!



If you're talking about Vid, I think he was Greek. I don't know why you would think he was a terrorist unless you're just racist & think any mid-eastern type person is a terrorist. I think it was suggested he had criminal ties, though.

75781159
Dottie It was Harry's opinion of Vid not this OP ...more
Jul 28, 2019 09:37AM · flag

No Cindy ! I'm not talking about Vid. The line on Page 433 was just like that about (Harry's neighbor) . I'm not saying that anyone is a terrorist and the book was simply amazing.


Was Harry not talking about Vid? I thought it just demonstrated how little he (i.e. Harry) cared for actually getting to know anybody. Describing Vid as "Arab", when he clearly wasn't, and then the immediate roll in to "probably a terrorist".


So I picked up this book while on a retreat...bit of light reading. It started to sound Monty Pythonesque with 'on the day of the BBQ' for the umpteenth time. Absolutely the last time I will persevere with a novel in case something astounding might happen, which didn't! No wonder this book was abandoned at the hotel.

18216218
Jim Swike I was disappointed as well.
Sep 03, 2018 09:29AM · flag

I think the line was just there to show the sort of person Harry was (Harry made the comment about Vid). I think it was supposed to show that he was a stereotypical crotchety racist old person who just made judgments about the neighbors without even knowing them (since Vid obviously wasn't a terrorist).


back to top