Ultimate Popsugar Reading Challenge discussion

4153 views
2018 Challenge Prompts - Regular > 6. A novel based on a real person

Comments Showing 51-100 of 359 (359 new)    post a comment »

message 51: by Abigail (new)

Abigail Smith | 66 comments Burial Rites would work for this. It's a heavy read - the historical figure is the last person to have been executed in Iceland - but the writing is really lovely.


message 52: by Bronwyn (new)

Bronwyn (singingbron) | 17 comments The Museum of Modern Love by Heather Rose was excellent. It's centred around Marina Abramovic and her performance of The Artist is Present at the Museum of Modern Art in New York, but it's primarily about a cast of fictional characters who all sit with Marina over the months that the show ran for. It was an unusual novel but I loved it. It won this year's Stella Prize too.

And I'll second the recommendation for Burial Rites by Hannah Kent! Some really amazing fiction out there from Australian women writers at the moment. :)


message 53: by Nancy (new)

Nancy (fancynancyt) | 65 comments The Other Alcott by Elise Hooper is based on May Alcott, Louisa's sister who she based the character of Amy on (and May hated how she was portrayed).

Girl Waits With Gun, recommended upthread, was excellent. I'll be reading the third book in the series for this prompt.


message 54: by Cristin (new)

Cristin | 25 comments Any thoughts on if the Little House (Laura Ingalls Wilder) books would count?


message 55: by poshpenny (new)

poshpenny | 1916 comments Cristin wrote: "Any thoughts on if the Little House (Laura Ingalls Wilder) books would count?"

Fiction based on herself and her family... sounds good to me!


message 56: by Shannon (new)

Shannon (sjwthompson) | 36 comments H.B. Moore writes historical fiction and religious fiction. I picked up The Killing Curse a while back when it was free and it references several real people, The author says you don't need to read the series in order either, which I like. I've read a few of her books and really enjoyed them.


message 57: by Stephanie (new)

Stephanie | 26 comments Wenjack by Joseph Boyden. It's technically a novella, but it fits the prompt beautifully and is both a historical work and one tied to current discussion around the treatment of indigenous peoples.


message 58: by Jo (last edited Nov 08, 2017 12:56PM) (new)

Jo (allweatherreader) | 50 comments Maplecroft is great, if quite kooky (very Lovecraftian). The Invention of Wings is good, too.

A Brief History of Seven Killings would count too, I think.


message 59: by Deepika (new)

Deepika | 7 comments The other Alcott.


message 60: by Stina (new)

Stina (stinalyn) | 464 comments Eujean2 wrote: "What a great chance to finally ready Maplecroft, a recommendation from a panel at Emerald City Comic Con 2017.

As Patrick Rothfus puts it in his 5 star review: "The primary charact..."


It's not for everybody, but I loved that book!


message 61: by Christina (new)

Christina (cvilla44) Anabell wrote: "Stalking Jack the Ripper just to go outside the biography genre."

I thoroughly enjoyed that book and couldn't put it down!


message 62: by Jessica (new)

Jessica Jerris | 42 comments Cate wrote: "The Paris Wife would fit the bill for this one too."

OH YES!!!!!!!!!!! I have been wanting to read this!! I am going with this one! :)


message 63: by Nicole (new)

Nicole (nicolecoster) | 6 comments If anyone is interested in a different viewpoint on the Salem Witch Trials, I, Tituba, Black Witch of Salem by Maryse Conde was a good read.

I think I'm going to finally tackle one of Margaret George's books for this prompt! I'm leaning towards Mary, Called Magdalene but I've heard her book on Henry VIII is also very good.


message 64: by Tara (new)

Tara Bates | 1008 comments Room isn't based on a real person, there are certainly similar stories and it was apparently inspired by a True case Donohue heard, but I don't think that it really counts for this prompt.


message 65: by Elena (new)

Elena Maddox (lanie7311) | 10 comments See What I Have Done by Sarah Schmidt. A novel about Lizzie Borden.


message 66: by Tara (new)

Tara Bates | 1008 comments After I made my comment I thought about it and I think you can do what you want, who am I to judge? It was inspired by a thing she heard even if the story is fictional. But yeah Schindler's List should work right? I don't actually know much about it.


message 67: by AF (new)

AF (slothlikeaf) | 398 comments Tara wrote: "Room isn't based on a real person, there are certainly similar stories and it was apparently inspired by a True case Donohue heard, but I don't think that it really counts for this prompt."

Bummer! I'm thinking about reading The Hours by Michael Cunningham instead.


message 68: by AF (new)

AF (slothlikeaf) | 398 comments Tara wrote: "After I made my comment I thought about it and I think you can do what you want, who am I to judge? It was inspired by a thing she heard even if the story is fictional. But yeah Schindler's List sh..."

I changed my mind again. Schindler's List might go in microhistory, if it fits there. The Hours sounds good to me right now.


message 69: by Tara (new)

Tara Bates | 1008 comments Haha I wondered if I was going crazy!! The Hours would work lol


message 70: by Trina (new)

Trina Gloury (mactrin) | 76 comments I'm going to go with The Paris Wife by Paula McLain. The synopsis intrigued me without telling me too much. I admire the work of Hemingway and I adore a love story. Sounds like this novel will have some rich themes in which I can sink my teeth into.


message 71: by Sara (new)

Sara (saradxxiii) | 10 comments Does anyone have recommendations on where to start with Philippa Gregory? I’ve yet to read one of her books.


message 72: by Lindi (new)

Lindi (lindimarie) Sara wrote: "Does anyone have recommendations on where to start with Philippa Gregory? I’ve yet to read one of her books."

It was suggested to me to read them in chronological order, not by publication. Here is a good list to help you out :)
The first one is The Lady of the Rivers.


message 73: by Alisia (new)

Alisia (4thhouseontheleft) | 58 comments Lee Smith Guests on Earth is a great book. Zelda Fitzgerald is not the main character, but has a large presence in the novel.


message 74: by Cindy H. (new)

Cindy H. | 30 comments I’m thinking about Mademoiselle Chanel but have read and loved The Aviator's Wifeand Fever


message 75: by Brandyn (new)

Brandyn (brandy_k) | 82 comments Since the prompt is "based on" a real person I think there's a lot of leeway if you want it. Technically The Fault in Our Stars would count because Hazel was based on a girl John Green met at a Harry Potter Conference.

So I would definitely count Room as based on a real person. It wasn't her exact story, but it was based on Elizabeth Fritzl.

The Invention of Wings would also count as the Grimke's were real women.

Other options I can think of

The Girls
The Royal We
The Cartel
Wolf Hall (my plan)


message 76: by Debbie (new)

Debbie (debzanne) | 165 comments A few other ideas I haven't seen upthread yet:

Vanessa and Her Sister, about Vanessa Bell and Virginia Woolf and a host of other writers in their circle.

Alex and Eliza, about Alexander Hamilton and Eliza Schuyler

My Theodosia, about Aaron Burr's daughter

X, co-written by Malcolm X's daughter and Kekla Magoon (who is also an amazing writer you should look up) - the book is about Malcolm X's childhood, written for a middle-grade audience, but not "dumbed down" at all

The Aviator's Wife, about Charles Lindbergh's home life

I own a few books above, or ones mentioned elsewhere (like Audacity), so I'll probably try to read from my shelves for this one


message 78: by Jennifer (new)

Jennifer T. (jent998) | 231 comments I have found three books so far for this list:
In Cold Blood by Truman Capote, Burial Rites by Hannah Kent (the main character was based on a real person) and 11/22/63 by Stephen King. It's a fictional take on preventing the Kennedy assassination and Lee Harvey Oswald is a character. Plus all 3 have been on my TBR list forever.


Jeeps (immovabletype) (immovabletype) If I'm not mistaken, The Pillars of the Earth includes some historical figures, yes?


message 80: by Bridget (new)

Bridget | 26 comments Washington and Caesar

This is what I picked for this category. It looks SO good.


message 81: by Anna (last edited Nov 20, 2017 03:28AM) (new)

Anna (annaholla) Jeeps wrote: "If I'm not mistaken, The Pillars of the Earth includes some historical figures, yes?"

The historical figures loom large, but they're not the focus of the main action -- and the town of Kingsbridge and the main characters are all fictional.

You could argue that the cathedral is based on real places (Wells and Salisbury, I believe), and it's certainly at the heart of the book.


Jeeps (immovabletype) (immovabletype) Anna wrote: "Jeeps wrote: "If I'm not mistaken, The Pillars of the Earth includes some historical figures, yes?"

The historical figures certainly loom large, but they're not the focus of the main a..."


I think I'll call that good enough for me, since I'm trying to only read books I currently own as much as possible. Especially if you count setting as a character.


message 83: by Emmy (new)

Emmy Johnson | 3 comments I am reading Katherine Of Aragon; The True Queen by Alison Weir
Which is part of a series of historical novels, based on each of the wives of Henry VIII.

I could also suggest Wolf Hall by Hilary Mantel

Sovereign by C J Samson which is a Tudor crime thriller but features several historical figures and happens during real historical events and contains a lot of the history of York at the time too. Plus is is a brilliant novel.


message 84: by Megan (new)

Megan | 361 comments Emmy wrote: "I am reading Katherine Of Aragon; The True Queen by Alison Weir
Which is part of a series of historical novels, based on each of the wives of Henry VIII.

I could also suggest Wolf Hall by Hilary M..."



Ooh. I loved Katherine of Aragon! It was so good!


message 85: by Jacqueline (new)

Jacqueline | 407 comments I picked up the
Birdman's Wife by Melissa Ashley
today. The cover is exquisite and I just had to have it. When I got it home I realised it is the novelisation of the life of a real woman so it will be my book for this prompt.


message 86: by Rebecca (new)

Rebecca Kiefer | 118 comments I highly recommend The Moor's Account! It is the Cabeza de Vaca expedition from the perspective of their African slave. The voice is so well done - one of my favorite books of the year.


message 87: by Heather (new)

Heather vonReichbauer | 11 comments Isadora by Amelia Gray


message 88: by Cathy (new)

Cathy (cathy_unapologetically) I stumbled across a book I think might work for this. It’s called

The Indifferent Stars Above: The Harrowing Saga of the Donner Party

Thoughts?


message 89: by Chrissy (new)

Chrissy Busick (chrissycracksabook) Anabell wrote: "Stalking Jack the Ripper just to go outside the biography genre."

This looks amazing. I hadn't heard of it before. Last year I started watching the new TV series The American Ripper on the History Channel, and it has sparked an interest in Jack the Ripper for me. This may be my book for this prompt. Thanks.


message 90: by Jess (last edited Nov 26, 2017 09:43AM) (new)

Jess Penhallow | 427 comments This is an easy prompt for me because historical fiction is my favourite genre! I am going to go with the one that has been on my TBR for the longest and that is Now is the Time about the English peasant's revolt of 1380. I believe John Ball and Wat Tyler who led the revolt are the story's protagonists.

The Baroque Cycle Collection are a fantastic series of novels set across Europe in the 17th century. I don't know how well they would fit this theme though because although many real people of the time feature (e.g. Isaac Newton, Samuel Pepys, James I and II of England, William of Orange, Queen Anne of England, Leibniz, Louis XIV of France to name but a few) the three protagonists are fictional characters. Although I would definitely say they were archetypes of time era and there were definitely people like each of these characters I can't say they were based on anyone in particular.


message 91: by Lily (last edited Nov 26, 2017 11:03AM) (new)

Lily (joy1) | 61 comments @63Jo wrote: ".... The Invention of Wings is good, too. ..."

I am fascinated that Sue Monk Kidd apparently was looking for a story of two sisters when she attended the dedication of the Judy Chicago installation at the Brooklyn Museum (Google it if interested) and came upon the Grimke sisters, abolitionists born in Charleston and whose slave-supporting family was active in South Carolina politics.

I was fascinated by Kidd's creation of a parallel slave story to the story of the sisters, a story she had to largely develop on plausibility, rather than historic record. Fascinating read for both the "history" and for the writing.

(Okay! I needed a synonym for "fascinating" here! But you get the idea, no?) :-)


message 92: by Stephen (new)

Stephen | 32 comments Alice in Wonderland or Through the Looking Glass. The former (and hence the latter) began when with tales told to Alice Liddel and her sisters. There is debate about how much the fiction Alice is based on Liddel, but it's clear there's influence. For instance, Alice in Wonderland takes place on Alice Liddel's birthday.


message 93: by Tara (new)

Tara Bates | 1008 comments There's also Alice I Have Been from the pov of Alice Liddell


message 94: by Susan (new)

Susan (yetanothersusan) | 47 comments May I suggest The Tattooist of Auschwitz for this prompt? "Based on the true story" is always a good giveaway for me!


message 95: by Karen (new)

Karen | 4 comments For any Norwegians, Fvonk by Erlend Loe would work!


message 96: by Molly (new)

Molly L | 4 comments I've been thinking about Young Jane Young for this, although I wonder now if that not based enough on a real person. It's clearly inspired by the Monica Lewinsky scandal, but I don't know if I should instead be going for a novel that features a real person...


message 97: by Sarah (new)

Sarah | 263 comments Bernard Cornwell writes fiction that is frequently based on real people. I highly recommend The Last Kingdom. Uhtred is one of Cornwell's ancestors (though he is misplaced in time) but it also features King Alfred the Great, Ubbe Lothbrokson, and Ivar the Boneless, King Edward, the list goes on. Many of his other novels feature almost entire casts of real people.


message 98: by Sarah (new)

Sarah | 263 comments Sarah wrote: "Bernard Cornwell writes fiction that is frequently based on real people. I highly recommend The Last Kingdom. Uhtred is one of Cornwell's ancestors (though he is misplaced in time) but..."

Oh! He also has one coming out in 2018 (for the US, already released in the UK) called Fools and Mortals and it's based on Richard Shakespeare (brother of the more famous William Shakespeare).


message 99: by Shelly (new)

Shelly | 123 comments Sarah wrote: "Bernard Cornwell writes fiction that is frequently based on real people. I highly recommend The Last Kingdom. Uhtred is one of Cornwell's ancestors (though he is misplaced in time) but..."

Yes. Thank you, Sarah. I have this one under prompt #4 (a book tied to your ancestry) under the advanced challenge. I am looking forward to it.


message 100: by Sarah (last edited Dec 01, 2017 11:58AM) (new)

Sarah | 263 comments Shelly wrote: "Sarah wrote: "Bernard Cornwell writes fiction that is frequently based on real people. I highly recommend The Last Kingdom. Uhtred is one of Cornwell's ancestors (though he is misplace..."

Haha! Is it weird to tell you I'm jealous of your ancestry?

Edited: I just don't know much about my own ancestry- is where this comment came from, to clarify. Wish I did.


back to top