The Seasonal Reading Challenge discussion
OLD TASK HELP THREADS
>
50.1 - Schatzie's Task: Outside the box
date
newest »
newest »
message 51:
by
Terri FL
(new)
Oct 24, 2017 09:46AM
Thank you! That's what I figured, but, better safe than sorry!
reply
|
flag
Hi, sorry, another question. For option 3, as long as there is one inanimate object that won't fit in a box, does it matter if there is another inanimate object that would fit in a box? Like for instance, if you have a house (the object to fit the task), but, there is a small flower-pot on the porch that would fit in the box.
Mod
or is the door enough on this cover to..."I guess I forgot about the nine living part. Lol. Thanks!
Suzanne wrote: "Could you verify the fantasy genre for Sourcery please? I don't really expect it to drop off, but. Well."Hi Suzanne, I agree...it is better to safe than sorry. The genre has been noted for your book. Enjoy.
Terri FL wrote: "Hi, sorry, another question. For option 3, as long as there is one inanimate object that won't fit in a box, does it matter if there is another inanimate object that would fit in a box? Like for in..."Hi Terry, just one object that meets the requirement is needed even if there are others that don't.
Yes! I finally have a place to put The Best American Science and Nature Writing 2017! Also, please verify Science genre because there's only 6 "shelves" so far. Thank! :)
Melissa wrote: "Yes! I finally have a place to put The Best American Science and Nature Writing 2017! Also, please verify Science genre because there's only 6 "shelves" so far. Thank! :)"Hi Melissa, The science genre has been noted for your book. Enjoy.
Melissa wrote: "Oh, also, could I get The Bloodprint verified for Fantasy please? Thanks!(Love this task)"
Hi again, I've noted the genre of Fantasy for this. It looks like something I'd read. Let me know how you like it. I may have to add it to my own list.
Does the building at the top of the hill on
work for Option 3?And please verify The First Book of Swords for Fantasy. (I don't think it's going to drop off, but just in case...)
Thanks
Julia wrote: "Does the building at the top of the hill on work for Option 3?And please verify The First Book of Swords for Fantasy. (I don't think it'..."
Hi Julia, the house works for opt. 3, and the fantasy genre has been noted. Enjoy.
Wanted to check on the lamppost on this cover for option 3:
I don't think it would fit in a box, but it depends on the size of the box. Will it work?
Alycia wrote: "Wanted to check on the lamppost on this cover for option 3:I don't think it would fit in a box, but it depends on the size of the box. Will it work?"
Hi Alycia, I will accept the lamp post. Enjoy.
Cindie wrote: "Does this work for option 4, Science?Sapiens: A Brief History of Humankind?"
Hi Cindie, I don't see 'Science' as a mpg for that book. I'll check again tomorrow to see if it pops up.
Christine wrote: "Could you please verify To Say Nothing of the Dog for MPG Fantasy? Thanks!"Hi Christine, the fantasy genre has been noted. Enjoy your book.
My three books:Option 1 - Liver Let Die (no B, O, X in title)
Option 2 - Celestial Chess (MPG = Fantasy)
Option 3 - The Last Time I Saw Paris (Eiffel Tower)
I am pretty sure that my first and third books work for their options, but could you please verify the second book for Fantasy? Currently there are only 3 users.
Hi Bea, the genre for your opt. 2 book has been noted. Your opt. 1 and 3 choices work as well. Happy reading.
Would the statue's head on the cover of this book be acceptable for the inanimate object for Option 2?
by Elizabeth Peters
Donna wrote: "Hi Bea, the genre for your opt. 2 book has been noted. Your opt. 1 and 3 choices work as well. Happy reading."Thanks, Donna.
Wanda wrote: "Would the statue's head on the cover of this book be acceptable for the inanimate object for Option 2? by Elizabeth Peters"Hi Wanda, I'll accept your statue. At first I thought it was just a picture, but in the jacket blip it specifically said it was a bust of Nefertiti so it is a go. Enjoy.
For Option 3, would the mountains on this cover work? Or possibly the bridge in the distance?
Thanks!
Christine wrote: "For Option 3, would the mountains on this cover work? Or possibly the bridge in the distance?Thanks!"
Hi Christine, either of those work.
For option 3, would the stone wall on this cover work?
Candy wrote: "For option 3, would the stone wall on this cover work?"Hi Candy, the stone wall works. Enjoy.
Is the mountain in the background of
good for something not fitting in a box?
Shanna_redwind wrote: "Is the mountain in the background of good for something not fitting in a box?"Hi Shanna, your mountains work. Enjoy.
Would this book work for option three as it shows sky? I initially thought sky wouldn’t count, but then I saw ocean is listed as an example object so I figured perhaps sky would be okay too? There’s also a parasol and table in the foreground, though I guess if you had a box large enough they would fit in!
Bryony wrote: "Would this book work for option three as it shows sky? I initially thought sky wouldn’t count, but then I saw ocean is listed as an example object so I figured perhaps sky would be okay too? Ther..."
Hi Bryony, I don't think sky will work. It isn't really an object. You can't touch it, handle it, feel it. You can't take a piece of it. I'll double check with the mods and let you know if my ruling changes. Sorry Bryony.
No problem, thanks for letting me know. It was actually an interesting question as I ended up debating with myself what defines an object if the sea is an object but the sky isn’t (which is what I thought)....can you tell I like science books too? Anyway, I’m sure I can find another book that works for this task. :-)
Valerie wrote: "Could you please verify The Little Stranger for Fantasy > Paranormal for Option 2? Thank you!"Hi Valerie, I noted the fantasy genre. Enjoy
Can I get the oil tower verified for option 3? 
Could I check that the plane on this cover counts as an object that won’t fit in a box?
Thank you!
Rebecca wrote: "Can I get the oil tower verified for option 3? "Hi Rebecca, the oil tower works. Enjoy.
Bryony wrote: "Could I check that the plane on this cover counts as an object that won’t fit in a box?Thank you!"
Hi Bryony, there is definitely enough of the plane on the cover to tell what it is, so it works. Enjoy.
Does this statue work for option 3? Thanks!
Can I please have The King of Attolia verified for Fantasy and The Key Muscles of Yoga: Scientific Keys, Volume I verified for Science? Thank you!
Can I please have Driving Mr. Albert: A Trip Across America with Einstein's Brain verified for science?
Lorraine wrote: "Does this statue work for option 3? Thanks!"Yes, Lorraine. The statue will work. Enjoy.
Sally wrote: "Can I please have The King of Attolia verified for Fantasy and The Key Muscles of Yoga: Scientific Keys, Volume I verified for Science? Thank you!"
Hi Sally, both genres have been noted. Enjoy. I may have to check out that yoga one myself.
Brooke wrote: "Can I please have Driving Mr. Albert: A Trip Across America with Einstein's Brain verified for science?"Hi Brooke, the genre has been noted.
Donna wrote: "Cindie wrote: "Does this work for option 2?All You Desire? Is it ok that it is YA?"
YA is fine."
great! Thanks!
The Seasonal Reading Challenge
Books mentioned in this topic
All You Desire (other topics)All You Desire (other topics)
All You Desire (other topics)
The Key Muscles of Yoga: Scientific Keys, Volume I (other topics)
The King of Attolia (other topics)
More...
Authors mentioned in this topic
Elizabeth Peters (other topics)Elizabeth Peters (other topics)
