At what point did you "figure out" Blue's identity? - Caution may contain spoilers

[Emily]

I watched to movie before I read the book (I know, big mistake) so I knew who Blue was

[Victòria]

never

[[deleted user]]

It was when Mr. Wise accidently gave Simon Bram's quiz. A part of me did think it was Cal, but there was no way he could have been the boy who exchanged e-mails with Simon. He would have been too obvious of a choice, which ultimately would have made the Big Reveal a bit disappointing.

I was 99.99% certain that Bram was Blue whenever Simon described him and how they interacted with each other. I'm really happy that I was right, because I love Bram and honestly wanted him to be Blue.

[Aneesa]

He didnt really talk in the book so i was like its got to be him, i knew it had to be him in like the 9th chapter!

[Carrie]

Ajay wrote: "I kind of figured it out when Bram scored 100 in that english test."

Same. Too much detail for it to be an innocuous scene filler.

[Ivana]

That scene when simon got Bram's English paper! I felt like thw author wouldn't just put something like that there for no reason

[Kelsey]

I saw the movie before I read the book, so I already knew who Blue was, but I think the book did a very good job of making Blue's identity a surprise. I mean, there were times where the audience suspected Bram, like the English score, but the book really made the audience think "There's no way it could be Bram."

[Liilaa]

I feel really proud of myself because I realized it around the second time he was introduced.

[Taylor]

Not a single clue. I found out when the author revealed it was Bram. I didn't even pay much attention to Bram or the perfect score on the English test. I thought it was Nick or Martin or one of the assholes catfishing Simon. I was so shocked but I'm so glad blue turned out to be Bram tho :).

[Fallon]

When Blue said he had the same name as a president I thought of Bram (Abraham) straight away :)

[Melissa]

See it was so weird because the test didnt' give it away for me. I wanted it to be Bram after the cheerleader costume thing, but I didn't think it was him until Simon *finally* spoke to him about the soccer "auditions" the goober. However for a brief moment I was terrified Martin was playing some terrible joke on Simon (maybe trying to set him up with his brother??? IDEK it made sense when i was freaking out about it) and was so so relieved when that wasn't the case.

I toyed momentarily with the thought that it might be Nick. However I knew it wasn't Cal at all because (a) Blue's comment about why is white the default and (b) Cal just seemed completely clueless throughout Simon's interactions. I do appreciate he picked up on Simon being interested in him eventually though. My heart was pounding until the very end and I was so so pleased it was Bram. I legit squealed. Ugh goosebumps I tell you!

[Book Thief]

((Warning, spoilers for who Blue is))

I figured it out quite early on who Blue was as he fit all he criteria. It only made my guess stronger when Simon asked the questions Do you share a name with ano American president' or whatever it was and I was like of course: Bram - Abraham Lincoln. And other. I was quite chuffed tbh I don't usually get things like that right. 😁

[Cassandra]

The part where they were sitting at the lunch table, and Leah got upset. Then Simon noticed Bram watching Leah and made a comment about how if he liked her, he should just ask her out. Bram then blushed, and I kept thinking; He isn't blushing because he likes Leah. He's blushing because his crush is talking to him!

[Scott]

I was the same way. Even missed one of the clues in the middle of the book.Katie wrote: "I had no idea whatsoever !!!"

[Madelyn]

I accidentally spoiled myself with a buzzfeed article :,(

[Bettelort]

I kind of just followed Simon's thoughts and I didnt guess who it was. I mean, when Bram was introduced I was just like "Hmm, his name starts with B, it must be him" But I dismissed it early on...

[Lauren]

I figured it out when Simon got the wrong test and handed it to Blue. In the emails Blue said he got all quiet around cute guys so I put the pieces together there.