The F-word discussion
What are you currently reading?
message 251:
by
Nefeli
(new)
Aug 21, 2019 10:43AM

reply
|
flag

I've not read this one as I've seen the TV programme so many times. How does this one compare to Ms Waters's other books, Angie, if you've read them?


My first Sarah Waters book was The Paying Guests. I loved it. Was then surprised to learn that people were generally disappointed with it because it wasn’t as good as Fingersmith. So I read Fingersmith. And I loved it. But no reason to diss The Paying Guests. Affinity also was excellent. And The Night Watch. But somehow, Tipping The Velvet is just telly. ...

Ha! Well, I'm not far in, but I've also not seen the program, so I'm not terribly worried about it not stacking up. Maybe I'll see if I can lay hands on that as well. :)

Such a good book! Got me hooked on Ursula
In addition to A Little Life for this month's group read, I'm also reading Notes to Self: Essays by Emilie Pine (for school), Light in the Shadows: A Novel by Linda Lafferty & Andy Stone (for review), and The Lying Game by Ruth Stone (on audio - for fun/for exercise/for commute).
Waiting in the wings:
Lizzie Siddal: The Tragedy of a Pre-Raphaelite Supermodel by Lucinda Hawksley (for another group read)
To the Lighthouse by Virginia Woolf (for in-person book club)
Nothing: A Portrait of Insomnia by Blake Butler (for school)
I feel like I'm missing... something. But that's good enough :)
Aside from the book by Butler, all books are written by women, which makes me infinitely happy.
Waiting in the wings:
Lizzie Siddal: The Tragedy of a Pre-Raphaelite Supermodel by Lucinda Hawksley (for another group read)
To the Lighthouse by Virginia Woolf (for in-person book club)
Nothing: A Portrait of Insomnia by Blake Butler (for school)
I feel like I'm missing... something. But that's good enough :)
Aside from the book by Butler, all books are written by women, which makes me infinitely happy.

I've stayed away from this book because of the author's manipulations but do let us know how it is. It's going to be a movie now, right?
I'm nearly done with Virginia Woolf's To the Lighthouse. Will they ever get to the lighthouse? Time will tell!

What do you mean by manipulations, Kay? I enjoyed the book. Never saw those twists coming. But then I never do :-) I've heard it's going to be made into a film, yes.
Natasha, I believe Kay is referring to the author's history of exploitation and lying. Here's one article about it from The New Yorker but there are others out there as well.

Gosh. Thanks, El. I had no idea. ...

Kay wrote: "Yes, sorry if I wasn’t clear in my previous post :) I just find the whole story surrounding the book ridiculous."
I heard that somehow, even with everything, he has a second book coming out. I hope I misheard that. Sigh.
I heard that somehow, even with everything, he has a second book coming out. I hope I misheard that. Sigh.

So, I really enjoyed Tipping the Velvet. I found myself kind of wanting to shake some sense into Nan more than once (I know it is supposed to be told from her POV as an older version of herself, but she still seemed stunted even in her remembering if that makes any sense at all), but all in all, I really enjoyed the story.

I think he signed a two-book deal before all this nonsense came out?

Good to hear, Angie. I will read that at some point :-)
I'm about at the same place that I was the last time I posted with both To the Lighthouse and our group read, A Little Life, but hope to make progress on both (and maybe even finish the Woolf!).
I just started reading Sigrid Nunez's The Friend this morning in preparation for her lecture on Monday that I just got a ticket for.
On audio, I'm finishing up Jeff VanderMeer's second Southern Reach novel, Authority, and I'll go right into the third book, Acceptance, so I can finish the trilogy and move onto something else.
Whew.
I just started reading Sigrid Nunez's The Friend this morning in preparation for her lecture on Monday that I just got a ticket for.
On audio, I'm finishing up Jeff VanderMeer's second Southern Reach novel, Authority, and I'll go right into the third book, Acceptance, so I can finish the trilogy and move onto something else.
Whew.

I really loved Annihilation but the sequels didn't really do anything for me. Are you enjoying Authority?
Nefeli wrote: "I really loved Annihilation but the sequels didn't really do anything for me. Are you enjoying Authority?"
Annihilation was pretty good! But yeah, Authority fell flat for me. I'm about halfway through Acceptance now. I wish the author had decided to just leave it at Annihilation.
Annihilation was pretty good! But yeah, Authority fell flat for me. I'm about halfway through Acceptance now. I wish the author had decided to just leave it at Annihilation.





Glancing through the included women, the notes, and index based on the premise of the book, I've got questions already! About 4 chapters in already.

This is a real tear jerker. Liked the movie as well as the book.

I found this to be deeply misogynistic. I'd be interested in opinions from anyone who's read it. Here's my review (which contains spoilers):
https://www.goodreads.com/review/show...

Books mentioned in this topic
The Happiest Man on Earth (other topics)Who Owns England?: How We Lost Our Green and Pleasant Land, and How to Take It Back (other topics)
The One (other topics)
Utopia for Realists: How We Can Build the Ideal World (other topics)
Side by Side (other topics)
More...
Authors mentioned in this topic
Marie Benedict (other topics)Rachel Gold (other topics)
Naomi Alderman, The Power (other topics)
Fartumo Kusow (other topics)
Vivek Shraya (other topics)
More...