The One (The Selection, #3) The One discussion


376 views
What would you're reaction if America didn't win?

Comments Showing 51-70 of 70 (70 new)    post a comment »
« previous 1 2 next »
dateUp arrow    newest »

message 51: by Cindy (last edited Oct 10, 2014 01:18PM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Cindy If America didn't won I would be screaming at my book and crying because Maxerica is forever!!!


Hannah Babaran As I was reading it, I didn't think much about the Selected or who would win. For me it was definitely America. The only thing that actually made me rethink this was her relationship with Aspen. Although if Maxon chose Kriss over America, I would probably be crying...a lot...


allison christine I Almost Cried when Maxon freaked out at her when he saw her and Aspen. I Would've Screamed!!!!!!!!


chinami she would have picked aspen. i am not averse to that.


message 55: by Fina (new) - rated it 5 stars

Fina i'd get totally pissed off so bad it's not even funny at all


Larose For that to happen the southern rebels wouldn't have come. I thought of it and then got sad because...

- What would happen to the destroying of the caste?
- There wouldn't be the 4th book.
-Because Aspen already had Lucy then America would be pretty lonely. :( until some cool guy came and swept her off her feet. (Which isn't possible.)
- The King would be alive. Just bleh!
- The Queen would be alive.
- Maxon would be miserable and would live the rest of his life Depressed.
- Celeste might be alive.
- The southern rebels could've attacked another time and killed possibly... America, Maxon, Celeste (again), Aspen, Lucy, And all the other cool peeps.

So I choose not to think about that! :) ANd just smile that it ended with a happy cliche!


Cassie    'The Thinker Go Go Go Go' Mis. Roben Goodfellow'\Isabelle Lightwood Larose wrote: "For that to happen the southern rebels wouldn't have come. I thought of it and then got sad because...

- What would happen to the destroying of the caste?
- There wouldn't be the 4th book.
-Becaus..."



Those are very good points! I actually hadn't thought of those, but I like them. There valid and... stuff.


Larose Cassie 'The Thinker Go Go Go Go' Mis. Roben Goodfellow'\Isabelle Lightwood wrote: "Larose wrote: "For that to happen the southern rebels wouldn't have come. I thought of it and then got sad because...

- What would happen to the destroying of the caste?
- There wouldn't be the 4t..."


thx :)


annie I probably would think "what's the fucking point then???"


message 61: by Mayu (new) - rated it 5 stars

Mayu T Annaw wrote: "I've thought about this forever. O.K. Here it goes, so America would move to Italy because she couldnt stand to be around the sadness of what couldve been with Maxon and Aspen and her father being ..."

This was very clever, and I think that's exactly what Maxon would do.

I'm really glad it didn't happen, though! :)


Taylor I would write a very angry letter to Mrs Cass! But thankfully she did win.


Larose Annaw wrote: "I've thought about this forever. O.K. Here it goes, so America would move to Italy because she couldnt stand to be around the sadness of what couldve been with Maxon and Aspen and her father being ..."

That is the worst ending ever, yet the most legit fictional ending. Spot on!


Annaw Thanks guys, sorry for the spelling and grammar I wrote it fast and a long time ago and I have been to busy to come back and edit it, I probably won't ever edit it though lol. :)


message 65: by Hannah (new)

Hannah Jones Larose wrote: "For that to happen the southern rebels wouldn't have come. I thought of it and then got sad because...

- What would happen to the destroying of the caste?
- There wouldn't be the 4th book.
-Becaus..."


why did the queen have to die? i liked her!


message 66: by Erika (last edited Dec 06, 2015 06:17PM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Erika Eroy i'll be more happier if america didn't win coz in the first place,i like kriss more than america....

America always cheats on Maxon secretly...!!!


Cecily I think I would have definitely been surprised, but I think that might have brought me to love the series even harder if there was a crazy plot twist! The only thing is, then we wouldn't have Eadlyn in the Heir.


Lorelei Jacque wrote: "I don't think she would have gone back to Aspen. She had pretty much already decided he was a brother. I think she would probably take her couple of weeks to cry and be sad and then move on. Americ..."

Yet the typical thing a YA author would write is about a mopping girl who then starts a rebellion with a broken heart.


Mirou That's a tough question. If America didn't win, I think my first reaction will be throwing the book at the wall but then, I will be like "Best twist book EVER!" and I will be definiely excited about it. I mean it would have been genius to do that. Ever since I started this series I knew that America is going to win somehow so no surprise at the end.


message 70: by Lucy (new) - added it

Lucy Sanner I would rip the book, thrown it, burn it, cut it up and then build a time machine before Keira Cass published the book and demand that she make them together. Go Maxerina!!!! I totally ship.


« previous 1 2 next »
back to top