The Evolution of Science Fiction discussion
2000-2014
>
What SF are you reading now, 2000-2014?


All Clear by Connie Willis"
How did you like these two? They make up th..."
It seems to me that I have encountered a few sci-fi books which were basically a historical narrative.
I get that sci-fi is great for examining social questions, I get that Orwell's 1984 established a preceded for timeline bending. Even so, I do wish this kind of modern 'sci-fi' would make at least an effort to veil the fact that they are writing about history.
Whoah! Slow down there! That's for next month. Maybe spend some more time with Flannery O'Connor. ;)

I know! But I gotta get out ahead of it or folks will be droppin' spoilers on me!
RJ - Slayer of Trolls wrote: "I know! But I gotta get out ahead of it or folks will be droppin' spoilers on me!"
Spoiler: Not everything that rises must converge.
Spoiler: Not everything that rises must converge.

Dan wrote: "...for no real reason..."
It was to teach you a lesson about God's grace and the Roman Catholic faith. Probably. I think that is what she said all her stories were about. But they are good anyway, even if I never understood the lessons.
It was to teach you a lesson about God's grace and the Roman Catholic faith. Probably. I think that is what she said all her stories were about. But they are good anyway, even if I never understood the lessons.


All Clear by Connie Willis
Rating: 4 stars
Review: https://www.goodreads.com/review/show...
and I started reading the "authorized" sequel to the late Michael Crichton's The Andromeda Strain

The Andromeda Evolution by Daniel H. Wilson
I've been slowly reading a pre-print of ФантАstika: Almanac of Bulgarian Speculative Fiction for the last year. I liked it. For whatever reason, I enjoyed the Fantasy stories more than the SF ones.
My review is here:
https://www.goodreads.com/review/show...
Not all countries have a home-grown SF publishing tradition. Bulgaria does now, thanks to a group of dedicated enthusiasts.
My review is here:
https://www.goodreads.com/review/show...
Not all countries have a home-grown SF publishing tradition. Bulgaria does now, thanks to a group of dedicated enthusiasts.



Wool by Hugh Howey
Rating: 3 stars
Review: https://www.goodreads.com/review/show...

https://www.goodreads.com/review/show...



The Egg and Other Stories by Andy Weir
Rating: 3 stars
Review: https://www.goodreads.com/review/show...


The Andromeda Evolution by Daniel H. Wilson
Rating: 2 stars
Review: https://www.goodreads.com/review/show...
and I started reading the third book in the Old Man's War series by the Master of Snark:

The Last Colony by John Scalzi


The Andromeda Evolution..."
'Master of snark..."love it!


A sad, familiar story! "gateway to chaos," indeed. Chaos lurks, grows, POUNCES...

Yes. I did enjoy his Old Man's War series, or the first two books anyway. But a few years ago people at GR were gushing over Scalzi like he was the SF reincarnation of Faulkner. I personally think the guy can barely write his way out of a paper bag. But then again I think the same thing of a lot of SF writers, most of whom depend much less on "snark" as something akin to character development.
The sad truth is that the SF community is not only quickly captivated by authors who crank out easy-to-read junk with very little depth other than one interesting idea that may or may not be based in "science," but even worse the community then circles the wagons anytime someone points out that their emperor is not wearing any clothes (talk about mixing some metaphors!). It took a decade or so for Scalzi's star to fall. How long will it take for Dennis Taylor? Or Martha Wells? Or Andy Weir? And why is there is a bottomless appetite for mediocrity in the SF community?

My problem is that while I've read and enjoyed Scalzi, I haven't read Faulkner :) the first Old Man's War is definitely a homage to RAH and well-made one. His latest trilogy hasn't captivated me - I won't say he is a mediocrity but his works vary (as with most authors) and I don't include him in modern top-3 SF authors
"RJ - Slayer of Trolls wrote: "How long will it take for Dennis Taylor? Or Martha Wells? Or Andy Weir? And why is there is a bottomless appetite for mediocrity in the SF community? ..."
The whole world has a bottomless appetite for mediocrity.
And most of the time, I would rather read a mediocre writer than read Faulkner. He has some gifts, but it takes more effort than it is worth, sometimes.
PS: When did Dennis Taylor become a star? I must have missed that. (I liked the one book I read by him.)
The whole world has a bottomless appetite for mediocrity.
And most of the time, I would rather read a mediocre writer than read Faulkner. He has some gifts, but it takes more effort than it is worth, sometimes.
PS: When did Dennis Taylor become a star? I must have missed that. (I liked the one book I read by him.)

And most of the time, I would rather read a mediocre writer than read Faulkner. He has some gifts, but it takes more effort than it is worth, sometimes."
Amen, for the "bottomless appetite" part. That's Andy Weir, for me.
Faulkner: likely scarred for life by being forced to read his stuff in class. I think I had to write an ESSAY! Teacher [professed to] LOVE his stuff... "As I Lay Dying". Gah.
Pet whine: had I not been a clueless Freshman, I could have had LARRY McMURTRY for my English 100 class @ Rice (ca. 1963), instead of the tired old ROJ guy mentioned above. I did later learn who he was: a pal of Ken Kesey, whose "Magic Bus" and Merry Pranksters showed up in force a couple years later, parked at the women's college.... Who knows how many Rice Girls lost their virtue to whozit, the busdriver. Ah, Neal Casaday. A notorious ravager of young womanhood. And what a story they would have, in later life! Type "Merry Pranksters" into Wikipedia for the details. "Noted for the sociological significance of a lengthy road trip they took in the summer of 1964, traveling across the United States in a psychedelic painted school bus called FURTHUR organizing parties and giving out LSD...."
McMurtey went on to marry Kesey's widow much later, in Tucson, where he was living with another woman, with whom he shared an Academy award for the screenplay for that gay cowboy flick whose name escapes me. But if any readers here missed his classic LONESOME DOVE.... Well. https://www.goodreads.com/review/show... My highest possible recommendation! -- even if you have no (known) interest in Western Americana. Trust me on this. I've read it 4x over the years, and almost certainly will again!


Good on you! Hope it continues to work for you. Wonderful novel, in my view. On my 100 Best Ever list.

SF & westerns have a lot in common in terms of plots & tones. Many of the early SF stories were just westerns with a few changes & many still are. I like both genres, although I'm pickier about westerns simply because of personal knowledge of horses & such. You might well get hooked, so here are a few recommendations.
Larry McMurtry is one of the best authors of the genre since he actually grew up on a ranch & could have been a cowboy. He didn't like the idea of all that work, but he understands it & its history well. I recently read his short nonfiction book Custer which was certainly different from most other accounts.
It's hard to find any of Donald Hamilton's westerns with the exception of The Big Country, a short story that became a blockbuster movie. (The link is to a novelization of the movie.) Any you can find are well worth reading. He wasn't a cowboy, but he lived out west, did a lot of research, & hunted extensively. Many of his fictional pieces have scenes cribbed directly from his factual articles for 'Field & Stream' or other outdoor/hunting magazines. No other author I've read has come close to his knowledge of guns & hunting.
Louis L'Amour is also worth reading. He mostly wrote western romances that were so similar it's tough to keep them straight, but he also branched out occasionally. Education of a Wandering Man is autobiographical & even more interesting than his fiction books. He had quite an interesting early life & read some amazingly dry books as he lived alone in deserted places.
At some point, it's probably worthwhile to read a book by Zane Grey. I doubt you'll be able to stomach more than one, but you'll see where a lot of the cliches in the genre got started. He was very popular & might be the first author to become a millionaire from his writing. (I think I read that somewhere.)
Elmore Leonard wrote some great western stories. Three-Ten to Yuma and Other Stories, Valdez Is Coming, & Hombre were all great stories/books as well as hit movies with big name stars.

Not reading much at present, but have been playing some SF video games!
"The Outer Worlds" is great. It is very story-rich. I'm playing it mostly avoiding fights by using my conversation skills. (Which I don't have in real life!) It is a story of colonists on far-off worlds controlled mostly by one or the other of two heartless companies. Most of the colonists are basically owned by the company they work for. It is a grim life for most of them.
"Psychonauts 2" is the sequel to one of my favorite games of all time. It deals with a squad of people (including some kids) who can travel inside the minds of others to help them deal with their psychological problems. Though it deals with some dark issues, it is mostly a bright and fun game. Easily my pick for best game writing of the year.
"The Outer Worlds" is great. It is very story-rich. I'm playing it mostly avoiding fights by using my conversation skills. (Which I don't have in real life!) It is a story of colonists on far-off worlds controlled mostly by one or the other of two heartless companies. Most of the colonists are basically owned by the company they work for. It is a grim life for most of them.
"Psychonauts 2" is the sequel to one of my favorite games of all time. It deals with a squad of people (including some kids) who can travel inside the minds of others to help them deal with their psychological problems. Though it deals with some dark issues, it is mostly a bright and fun game. Easily my pick for best game writing of the year.
Jim wrote: "SF & westerns have a lot in common in terms of plots & tones. ..."
Yes, indeed. They are both often "frontier" stories. I watched Gunsmoke, Bonanza and similar things growing up, and the stories often resembled Star Trek and Twilight Zone. I haven't read many western books, though.
Yes, indeed. They are both often "frontier" stories. I watched Gunsmoke, Bonanza and similar things growing up, and the stories often resembled Star Trek and Twilight Zone. I haven't read many western books, though.

The absolute best per me is LONESOME DOVE. Past that, it gets spotty. His ZEKE & NED is first-rate, by memory -- but the copy I checked out to re-read sits undisturbed on the shelf. Which is more a commentary on the run of good books (I hope) sitting unread on the TBR-on hand shelf. As always, some pan out, others don't....


Aha, "A Dry, Quiet War" by Tony Daniel. I wrote "It's something like a small Lonesome Dove in Space, and really, really good:"
https://www.goodreads.com/review/show...
Free copy online, too. Don't miss! Novella; so what. Easy 5 stars!

5 stars! Good stuff, right from the start. Held up well to a reread last year.
Deep enough! ⚒︎
Peter wrote: "Ed wrote: "The absolute best per me is LONESOME DOVE.
I dunno. If I want to read about sad pigeons, maybe I should start with Don't Let the Pigeon Drive the Bus!. I've heard it is a classic.
I dunno. If I want to read about sad pigeons, maybe I should start with Don't Let the Pigeon Drive the Bus!. I've heard it is a classic.

Hey, go for it!

Just read it and liked it. Any recommendations for other works from this author?

Just read it and liked it. Any recommendations for other works from this author?"
I liked his METAPLANETARY back in 2003-ish, but remember little about it. I rated it 4 stars, but other GR friends ratings are mixed at best. Here's a 4-star review online, offered without context:
https://choveshkata.net/forum/viewtop...
Plus there are a number of other 4-star reviews here --but also by reviewers I'm unfamiliar with!


The Last Colony by John Scalzi
Rating: 3 stars
Review: https://www.goodreads.com/review/show...


I think it counts as Sci Fi although it's quite literary, in the way that e.g. Margaret Atwood's books are. The plot involves a civil war in near-future USA and there's a superpower empire in the Middle East stoking the flames. So kind of a tables-turned situation. Interesting exploration of the polarisation of the "liberal" north vs the "libertarian" south against the backdrop of climate change. Touches on the dehumanising & brutalising effects of war, which has parallels with the recent short group read A Dry, Quiet War.
I just read The Anomaly by Hervé Le Tellier. I give it 3.5 stars. It is a page-turner with an interesting premise.
In France it was published with a white cover, which indicates that it should be considered a book for high-minded people who would never dare to read trashy genre books with their tacky multi-colored covers. While it deals with some SF themes, it does feel more like "thriller".
Since it was published in English in 2021 I suppose I shouldn't talk about it in this thread which is for 2000-2020. But I'm cheating. And why not! On Amazon it is listed as the 20th best-selling book in "Space Fleet Science Fiction", even though there is no space fleet in it!
In France it was published with a white cover, which indicates that it should be considered a book for high-minded people who would never dare to read trashy genre books with their tacky multi-colored covers. While it deals with some SF themes, it does feel more like "thriller".
Since it was published in English in 2021 I suppose I shouldn't talk about it in this thread which is for 2000-2020. But I'm cheating. And why not! On Amazon it is listed as the 20th best-selling book in "Space Fleet Science Fiction", even though there is no space fleet in it!


Songs of the Dying Earth: Stories in Honour of Jack Vance edited by George R.R. Martin and Gardner Dozois
Note: It's probably more fantasy than sci-fi for those purists who don't like to get their chocolate in their peanut butter.


It's "2000 & Up". We discussed changing the periods around, but decided just to go with that for a number of reasons for now. One is that it's nice to have 6 periods so we cover each one twice a year. I'm not opposed to changing them so that we have a Pre-1940 & break this period up into two: 2000-2010 or 2015 & from there up. The overall consensus was not at this time, though. Discuss in "Group Suggestions" if you disagree.
https://www.goodreads.com/topic/show/...



The Paper Menagerie and Other Stories by Ken Liu


The Paper Menagerie and Other Stories by [author:Ke..."
How do you find it so far?
Books mentioned in this topic
Judas Unchained (other topics)Pandora's Star (other topics)
Troublemakers: Stories by Harlan Ellison (other topics)
Dark Matter (other topics)
Dark Matter (other topics)
More...
Authors mentioned in this topic
Peter F. Hamilton (other topics)Blake Crouch (other topics)
Stephen King (other topics)
Blake Crouch (other topics)
Blake Crouch (other topics)
More...
Old Venus edited by George R.R. Martin and the late Gardner Dozois
Rating: 3 stars
Review: https://www.goodreads.com/review/show...