Fantasy Book Club discussion

102 views
Challenge: Complete those Series > tnkw01's series challenge

Comments Showing 51-100 of 142 (142 new)    post a comment »

message 51: by Tnkw01 (new)

Tnkw01 | 2293 comments Mod
I am absolutely loving this trilogy. One of the best I have ever read. Mara has become my favorite female fantasy character.


message 52: by Helen, I·ᴍ ɪɴ ᴛʜᴇ ʟɪʙʀᴀʀʏ (new)

Helen | 3616 comments Mod
That's great, I read it when I was still a young impressionable girl and idolized Mara. I also really felt for that guy who ended up with the death sentence from the grove???? That stayed with me.


message 53: by Tnkw01 (new)

Tnkw01 | 2293 comments Mod
Finished Mistress of the Empire. The whole series is a 5 star. One of the best I have ever had the pleasure to experience.


message 54: by Bill (new)

Bill | 337 comments Tnkw01 wrote: "Finished Mistress of the Empire. The whole series is a 5 star. One of the best I have ever had the pleasure to experience."

Good to hear. I plan to read it later this year.


message 55: by Tnkw01 (new)

Tnkw01 | 2293 comments Mod
Finished The Blue Sword. Started off slow but it picked up and turned out to be a great story. Will read The Hero and the Crown after I read Throne of Jade.


message 56: by Virginie, Meow. (new)

Virginie | 898 comments Mod
Ooooh. Let us know what you think of Throne of Jade! I really liked Temeraire.


message 57: by Tnkw01 (new)

Tnkw01 | 2293 comments Mod
You know I will. I'm looking forward to reading it.


message 58: by Tnkw01 (last edited Mar 23, 2018 11:10AM) (new)

Tnkw01 | 2293 comments Mod
I've finished The Hero and the Crown. Here's my review . Now on to Shadows Linger.


message 59: by Tnkw01 (new)

Tnkw01 | 2293 comments Mod
Finished Shadows Linger, here's my review . Now on to The White Rose.


message 60: by Virginie, Meow. (new)

Virginie | 898 comments Mod
Tnkw01 wrote: "Finished Shadows Linger, here's my review . Now on to The White Rose."

Oh, maybe I should give this series another chance. I liked the first book but found it tedious sometimes. Does Shadows Linger has a better flow?


message 61: by Tnkw01 (new)

Tnkw01 | 2293 comments Mod
I can only give my opinion but I liked all three books in the trilogy. I'm about to finish the last one. As far as flow, they all flow very similarly. I can see why you feel the way you do. The chapters are very short and at times I would think "why not combine some of these chapters together for better flow." Overall though, I still found them very entertaining and fun.


message 62: by Helen, I·ᴍ ɪɴ ᴛʜᴇ ʟɪʙʀᴀʀʏ (new)

Helen | 3616 comments Mod
I think I'm the only person who didn't like the Temeraire series. Don't tell anyone!


message 63: by Tnkw01 (new)

Tnkw01 | 2293 comments Mod
Helen wrote: "I think I'm the only person who didn't like the Temeraire series. Don't tell anyone!"

Yes Ma'am!


message 64: by Tnkw01 (new)

Tnkw01 | 2293 comments Mod
Read The White Rose last month and forgot to mark it off. Loved the story and the Black Company


message 65: by Tnkw01 (new)

Tnkw01 | 2293 comments Mod
Started The Liar's Key today.


message 66: by Bill (new)

Bill | 337 comments Tnkw01 wrote: "Read The White Rose last month and forgot to mark it off. Loved the story and the Black Company"

Any plans to continue the series? I finished all 9 earlier this month and it kept up the same quality throughout.


message 67: by Virginie, Meow. (new)

Virginie | 898 comments Mod
Tnkw01 wrote: "Started The Liar's Key today."

Yeah! I hope you'll like it.

I'd advise you to finish the Broken Empire trilogy before reading The Wheel of Osheim. I'm currently buddy-reading it (the Wheel) and there's plenty of hidden Easter Eggs you won't get if you haven't read Emperor of Thorns.


message 68: by Tnkw01 (new)

Tnkw01 | 2293 comments Mod
@ Bill - yes I plan on finishing the rest next year when all I'm going to do is the series challenge. I have so many open I believe it will be time close as many as possible. I may title it "The Never-ending Challenge".

@ Virginie - Emperor of Thorns just happens to be one of my challenge books for next month.


message 69: by Virginie, Meow. (new)

Virginie | 898 comments Mod
Do you know how many open series you have, roughly?


message 70: by Tnkw01 (last edited Apr 23, 2018 06:11AM) (new)

Tnkw01 | 2293 comments Mod
Virginie wrote: "Do you know how many open series you have, roughly?"

38, that's only counting the ones I have already started. There are some that I haven't started yet. Haven't counted those yet.


message 71: by Bill (new)

Bill | 337 comments That’s pretty good I’m at 81. I have no willpower at all.


message 72: by Virginie, Meow. (new)

Virginie | 898 comments Mod
Tnkw01 wrote: "Virginie wrote: "Do you know how many open series you have, roughly?"

38, that's only counting the ones I have already started. There are some that I haven't started yet. Haven't counted those yet."


Oh, that's not so bad. I gave up counting series I want to start after 50... Don't do it, it's scary :p

@Bill: 81! Wow! Do you manage to remember it all or are you forgetting details about previous books sometimes?
My brain wouldn't be able to handle so many series :o


message 73: by Tnkw01 (new)

Tnkw01 | 2293 comments Mod
Virginie wrote: "Tnkw01 wrote: "Virginie wrote: "Do you know how many open series you have, roughly?"

38, that's only counting the ones I have already started. There are some that I haven't started yet. Haven't co..."


I had to be very selective and I threw several series out as a DNF or it would have been more.


message 74: by Bill (new)

Bill | 337 comments I have been getting a little better with the dnfing series but could probably trim some more off my list.


message 75: by Tnkw01 (new)

Tnkw01 | 2293 comments Mod
I've not been doing very well at keeping up with my challenges with taking care of family and all. So, I have to say I've finished a couple more for this challenge with Prince of Fools and The Liar's Key.


message 76: by Virginie, Meow. (new)

Virginie | 898 comments Mod
Tnkw01 wrote: "I've not been doing very well at keeping up with my challenges with taking care of family and all. So, I have to say I've finished a couple more for this challenge with [book:Prince of Fools|186937..."

Well, you're still slaying this challenge! Family always comes first :)


message 77: by Tnkw01 (new)

Tnkw01 | 2293 comments Mod
Finished The Wheel of Osheim. Really great read. Now on to Sailing to Sarantium.


message 78: by Virginie, Meow. (new)

Virginie | 898 comments Mod
Oh, what did you think of the ending?


message 79: by Tnkw01 (last edited May 18, 2018 04:37AM) (new)

Tnkw01 | 2293 comments Mod
I liked the ending much more in the Red Queen War series than I did the Broken Empire series. I must say though, and this is only my opinion but, when you mix Sci-Fi with Fantasy it takes some of the "magic" out of it. I still enjoy reading Sci-Fi/Fantasy but I enjoy other forms of Fantasy better.


message 80: by Virginie, Meow. (new)

Virginie | 898 comments Mod
Heh... I didn't really like the ending. Felt rushed and anti-climatic.
I liked the Science Fantasy part until everything started to be openly explained (mid book, I think).
Much of the fun I had with this trilogy and Broken Empire was to try to figure how the 'magic' worked, and built an mental map of the 'hidden players' goals, alliances, etc.


message 81: by Tnkw01 (new)

Tnkw01 | 2293 comments Mod
Virginie wrote: "Heh... I didn't really like the ending. Felt rushed and anti-climatic.
I liked the Science Fantasy part until everything started to be openly explained (mid book, I think).
Much of the fun I had wi..."


You really do have to read Broken Empire first and it helps to immediately go into the Red Queens War. I have to admit I did forget some stuff from Prince of Thorns and the later books.


message 82: by Tnkw01 (new)

Tnkw01 | 2293 comments Mod
I finished Sailing to Sarantium. I am going to wait until I finish Lord of Emperors before I write a review on Sailing to Saratium.


message 83: by Virginie, Meow. (new)

Virginie | 898 comments Mod
You're doing great at this challenge :)


message 84: by Bill (new)

Bill | 337 comments Great job! Think Sarantine is my next Kay series. Been too long since I read anything by him.


message 85: by Tnkw01 (new)

Tnkw01 | 2293 comments Mod
Bill wrote: "Great job! Think Sarantine is my next Kay series. Been too long since I read anything by him."

He and Janny Wurts have some of the most beautiful prose in fantasy.


message 86: by Joseph (new)

Joseph | 1651 comments Bill wrote: "Great job! Think Sarantine is my next Kay series. Been too long since I read anything by him."

Sarantine Mosaic also has one of the best chariot races I've ever read.


message 87: by Tnkw01 (new)

Tnkw01 | 2293 comments Mod
Joseph wrote: "Bill wrote: "Great job! Think Sarantine is my next Kay series. Been too long since I read anything by him."

Sarantine Mosaic also has one of the best chariot races I've ever read."


Yes it does.


message 88: by Kevin (new)

Kevin | 121 comments Tnkw01 wrote: "Bill wrote: "Great job! Think Sarantine is my next Kay series. Been too long since I read anything by him."

He and Janny Wurts have some of the most beautiful prose in fantasy."


Guess I need to read some Wurts because I love his stuff.


message 89: by Tnkw01 (new)

Tnkw01 | 2293 comments Mod
Though Kay's style is a little more straightforward than Wurts'. Ms. Wurts' writing needs to be savored.


message 90: by Tnkw01 (new)

Tnkw01 | 2293 comments Mod
I'm making an adjustment to my series list for this year. Since the third book in the Licanius Trilogy doesn't come out till next year I going to replace it with the Healer Series by Maria V. Snyder starting with Touch of Power. I'll do Licanius next year.


message 91: by Virginie, Meow. (last edited Jul 02, 2018 06:01AM) (new)

Virginie | 898 comments Mod
Oh, I too am waiting for the release of The Light of All That Falls to re-read the first and continue the series!

You're slaying your challenge! :D


message 92: by Tnkw01 (new)


message 93: by Virginie, Meow. (new)

Virginie | 898 comments Mod
Yay! Great reads, all of them :D


message 94: by Tnkw01 (new)

Tnkw01 | 2293 comments Mod
Virginie wrote: "Yay! Great reads, all of them :D"

I'm really enjoying them!


message 95: by Tnkw01 (new)

Tnkw01 | 2293 comments Mod
Finished the First Law Trilogy. It was a great read but I was highly disappointed in the ending and the direction the characters were taken. I'm reading Best Served Cold next but I'm not too sure I'll continue on in this world. This book will probably determine that.


message 96: by Virginie, Meow. (new)

Virginie | 898 comments Mod
I haven't read Best Served Cold yet. The ending of the trilogy was, in my opinion, very cynical.

I heard there's a second trilogy coming soon, after the 3 standalones + short stories collection :)


message 97: by Tnkw01 (new)

Tnkw01 | 2293 comments Mod
Virginie wrote: "I haven't read Best Served Cold yet. The ending of the trilogy was, in my opinion, very cynical.

I heard there's a second trilogy coming soon, after the 3 standalones + short stories collection :)"


So far Best Served Cold is very good. But the First Law Trilogy started out very good also. So I'm staying very wary on this one. I love the premise of this one though. Revenge where there is justice is right down my ally.


message 98: by Bill (new)

Bill | 337 comments I liked the standalones more than the trilogy. The ending of the trilogy was so brutal.


message 99: by Kevin (new)

Kevin | 121 comments Bill wrote: "I liked the standalones more than the trilogy. The ending of the trilogy was so brutal."

I thought the stand alones were much better myself, could just be an author improving as he continues to write...


message 100: by Tnkw01 (new)

Tnkw01 | 2293 comments Mod
Ok, I'm about 25% through Best Served Cold and I'm really liking it. I hope I don't have a let down.


back to top