Pride and Prejudice
discussion
Where were the servants?
date
newest »

message 1:
by
The Book Cartel
(new)
-
rated it 2 stars
Feb 03, 2017 10:08PM

reply
|
flag

I do love Pride and Prejudice, though. Austen describes her characters sparingly, focusing on the most important ones that are needed to tell the story. It's not only the servants that are hardly ever mentioned. How much do you remember hearing about Mr. Hurst, for example?

I do believe you have to look at the question both from a social-economic-historical perspective as well as from a writer's perspective. First, in that era, servants had limited roles in their masters' lives. Without diminishing the value of humans, even in Austen's time, servants were like microwaves--tools to complete certain tasks. Second, the Bennet family was not wealthy, and therefore had limited servants (just the essential ones). But also, the story has nothing to do with the servants, regardless of Elizabeth's kindness and inclination to regard all people as important. Austen could have written more about the servants, but what would that have added? In the Bennet's and Austen's world, of course there were servants, and any reader then would have known this but as a very peripheral detail. Had Austen expanded on the servants, I think it would have been mere clutter to satisfy our modern expectations for describing setting and exploring social class that was a given back then. Simply, Jane Austen didn't write the story for us; she wrote if for her contemporaries.

Servants are mentioned here and there throughout the story, not hugely, but, by reading P&P, I can feel enough presence of their servants.
Perhaps, they were not so relevant to the story. And indeed, servants did not mix with the family, that was what it was, “know your place, speak when you are spoken to” was policy.
To me, it was enough servants mentioned. In the early chapter, a good cook was mentioned, then, followed by house keeper Mrs Hill, a butler, footman, gardener etc…
all discussions on this book
|
post a new topic
Pride and Prejudice (other topics)
Books mentioned in this topic
Longbourn (other topics)Pride and Prejudice (other topics)