Ultimate Popsugar Reading Challenge discussion
2017 Challenge prompts
>
A book that's becoming a movie in 2017
Megan wrote: "I also had down All the Bright Places for this."That's a great book. I read it this year. I also read Ready Player One and Wonder this year. They are saying that The Silver Chair is going to be a movie next year. I will believe THAT when I see it, but I would like to read it so maybe I will read it just in case. The book becoming a movie 2016 that I read ended up not being released :) Oh well!
Megan wrote: "I also had down All the Bright Places for this."Me too. I bought it on a Kindle Daily Deal this year but it didn't fit any of my open categories so now I can finally get to it.
Mike wrote: "I cannot recommend Ready Player One enough. Too bad I've already read it twice."I borrowed a hard copy from a coworker. Wondering if I'll be able to hold out until 1/1 to read it.
Mike wrote: "Hey, that could be my "Never Fails to Make Me Smile" book! I'm smiling already!"It's a good excuse to pull out a favorite book for a re-read. Go for it! :)
I have a hard time with this sort of category every time we have it, because either I've read the book already, or I'm not interested. I'd much prefer a "book that was made into a movie in any year" category.
I'll probably choose one of these:
Red Sparrow looks promising.
The City of Shifting Waters, if I can find it at my library.
Three to Kill
Live by Night
All the Bright Places
I'll probably choose one of these:
Red Sparrow looks promising.
The City of Shifting Waters, if I can find it at my library.
Three to Kill
Live by Night
All the Bright Places
I saw a list on Goodreads that said Murder on the Orient Express is being made into a movie again in 2017. Does anyone know if this is true?The Zookeeper's Wife ???
Marilyn wrote: "I saw a list on Goodreads that said Murder on the Orient Express is being made into a movie again in 2017. Does anyone know if this is true?"I saw that on a list as well. No idea if it's true though.
Marilyn wrote: "I saw a list on Goodreads that said Murder on the Orient Express is being made into a movie again in 2017. Does anyone know if this is true?"IMDB has it with a Nov. 22, 2017 release date. Starring Johnny Depp as Poirot and costarring Michelle Pfeiffer and Daisy Ridley.
Marilyn wrote: "I saw a list on Goodreads that said Murder on the Orient Express is being made into a movie again in 2017. Does anyone know if this is true?"It is listed on IMDB as well, and on another list for 2017 book-to-movie releases. My Friend Dahmer was also on both those lists, which I think will be my choice.
Marilyn wrote: "I saw a list on Goodreads that said Murder on the Orient Express is being made into a movie again in 2017. Does anyone know if this is true?"Yup totally true. Kenneth Branaugh will direct and star as Poirot, with lots of big names in the cast. It's slated to come out a year from now, which also means they expect it to be good.
This category should be notoriously difficult to predict very far in advance. Movies get stuck in development hell at the drop of a hat. Read lists with caution and you can't trust everything on IMDB, especially early in development.
I hate to tell you that Ready Player One is scheduled for 2018, as is A Wrinkle in Time. All the Bright Places has been in pre-production for ages with zero chatter lately. I wouldn't hold your breath for The Silver Chair next year either.
There are some movies where you can interpret the release year for this challenge. Due to awards regulations, this year's eligible movies must be released in 2016, but only in L.A. To keep ALL the movies from releasing at the same time, some will release there in December but not go into wide release to the rest of the country until January 2017 or even later. I feel these could count for the 2017 prompt even if you see them officially listed as a 2016 movie. For example:
A Monster Calls Jan 1 UK, Jan 6 wide US
Hidden Figures: The American Dream and the Untold Story of the Black Women Mathematicians Who Helped Win the Space Race wide release Jan 6
Live by Night wide release on January 13
I think Wonder, A Dog's Purpose, The Zookeeper's Wife, The Dark Tower, The Circle, My Friend Dahmer, The House of Tomorrow, The Lost City of Z, and The Glass Castle are pretty safe bets.
This will be a blank for me because I'm sure to see a preview and decide I want to read it. My mistake in '15 was filling in too many prompts before and then feeling like it was a chore to finish by november/December.
Is A Court of Thorns and Roses coming as a movie? It was optioned a few years back, so this is a wait and see one?
Books Becoming Movies in 2017
Books Becoming Movies in 2017
Crazy Rich Asians https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/1... is going to be a movie in Spring 2017. It's being filmed right now!
All the Bright Places was on my TBR for 2016 but I haven't gotten around to it yet. Wonder is definitely an option too!
Nadine wrote: "Is A Court of Thorns and Roses coming as a movie? It was optioned a few years back, so this is a wait and see one?Books Becoming Movies in 2017 "
I hope it is. That's one of the books I was trying to squeeze in, and this is a prompt that I'm struggling with. It exists in both of my challenges, and I'm at a loss for books that are confirmed to become movies. Most that I've found say they're in pre-production.
Nadine wrote: "Is A Court of Thorns and Roses coming as a movie? It was optioned a few years back, so this is a wait and see one?"It's going to be a show on Hulu
Kirsten *Don't Be A Grinch* wrote: "I see that The Nightingale is becoming a movie next year, I think I'll read that one."
The movie for that book is still in development. They hired a director last summer but I haven't seen any news on it since. It's possible it could release next year, but I wouldn't bet on it. I did see a The Nightingale movie listed on IMDB for 2017 but it's set in Tasmania, not France.
Kirsten *Don't Be A Grinch* wrote: "Kenneth Branagh as Poirot? *shakes head in disbelief*"
I know, right? But hey, you never know. Maybe he will make a great fussy Belgian? (The poor man has a lot to live up to!)
Charissa wrote: "Crazy Rich Asians https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/1... is going to be a movie in Spring 2017. It's being filmed right now!"
Still casting. It has been fast-tracked for production, though.
Marianne wrote: "Same Kind of Different as Me is a wonderful book and the movie is being released in February."
We have a winner! Trailer
Sorry y'all. Movies are kinda my thing. I'm just trying to save people from reading something for a prompt it won't actually fill. Here are a few that are pretty safe so far: (Of course, they pulled A Little Prince a week before it's scheduled release, so... )Ghost in the Shell - Trailer
Tulip Fever - Trailer
The Zookeeper's Wife - Trailer
A Dog's Purpose - Trailer
Colour Bar: The Triumph of Seretse Khama and His Nation - A United Kingdom Trailer
Before I Fall - Trailer
Tommy's Honour: The Extraordinary Story of Golf's Founding Father and Son - Clip
Rachel wrote: "Nadine wrote: "Is A Court of Thorns and Roses coming as a movie? It was optioned a few years back, so this is a wait and see one?
Books Becoming Movies in 2017 "
I hope it is. That's one of the books I was trying to squeeze in, and this is a prompt that I'm struggling with. It exists in both of my challenges, and I'm at a loss for books that are confirmed to become movies."
ditto!!!
poshpenny wrote: "Sorry y'all. Movies are kinda my thing. I'm just trying to save people from reading something for a prompt it won't actually fill. Here are a few that are pretty safe so far: (Of course, they pulle..."
Thank you! I appreciate all your input on this. I like movies, but I don't have time to see very many, and I have a problem apparently, because any movies being made from books for next year are either (a) based on books I've already read, or (b) based on books that I have zero interest in. I'm really hoping for that grey area, "book I haven't read yet that I think I could kinda sorta enjoy." For this year, I ended up reading Miss Peregrine, and I really did not like that book. I wish they hadn't repeated this category. This is my list, and I'm not excited about any of them: Red Sparrow, The City of Shifting Waters, Three to Kill, Live by Night, All the Bright Places, Murder on the Orient Express Are any of these iffy for 2017? Mostly I'm banking on Three to Kill. I guess Poirot is like my "safety school" here.
ETA: I guess I might like Ghost in the Shell, actually. I had missed that one.
Books Becoming Movies in 2017 "
I hope it is. That's one of the books I was trying to squeeze in, and this is a prompt that I'm struggling with. It exists in both of my challenges, and I'm at a loss for books that are confirmed to become movies."
ditto!!!
poshpenny wrote: "Sorry y'all. Movies are kinda my thing. I'm just trying to save people from reading something for a prompt it won't actually fill. Here are a few that are pretty safe so far: (Of course, they pulle..."
Thank you! I appreciate all your input on this. I like movies, but I don't have time to see very many, and I have a problem apparently, because any movies being made from books for next year are either (a) based on books I've already read, or (b) based on books that I have zero interest in. I'm really hoping for that grey area, "book I haven't read yet that I think I could kinda sorta enjoy." For this year, I ended up reading Miss Peregrine, and I really did not like that book. I wish they hadn't repeated this category. This is my list, and I'm not excited about any of them: Red Sparrow, The City of Shifting Waters, Three to Kill, Live by Night, All the Bright Places, Murder on the Orient Express Are any of these iffy for 2017? Mostly I'm banking on Three to Kill. I guess Poirot is like my "safety school" here.
ETA: I guess I might like Ghost in the Shell, actually. I had missed that one.
Live by Night is an absolute yes. It's in the mix for awards season this year. The City of Shifting Waters has a Trailer and a fairly early release date, so it's likely.
Red Sparrow has a director and two stars signed on, so it's possible but could easily wait a year or so. (It's had a director and one star for a year and a half.)
I haven't seen anything about Three to Kill since talk from three years ago, and the people it talked about do not have it listed anywhere I can find. This one is stuck in development hell.
All the Bright Places probably not before 2018.
Orient Express is probable for 2017, but a year is a long time.
Emma Watson & Tom Hanks are starring in a movie based The CircleHere is the trailer: https://www.wired.com/2016/12/the-cir...
Liz wrote: "Emma Watson & Tom Hanks are starring in a movie based The Circle
Here is the trailer: https://www.wired.com/2016/12/the-cir..."
Wow somehow I completely missed this one! It wasn't on any of the lists. 4/28/17 sounds pretty definite. Thanks! This will probably be the book I read for this category.
Here is the trailer: https://www.wired.com/2016/12/the-cir..."
Wow somehow I completely missed this one! It wasn't on any of the lists. 4/28/17 sounds pretty definite. Thanks! This will probably be the book I read for this category.
Liz wrote: "Emma Watson & Tom Hanks are starring in a movie based The CircleHere is the trailer: https://www.wired.com/2016/12/the-cir..."
Yes! I just saw the trailer the other day on facebook! This is going to be my book for this prompt and I *need* to see the movie when it comes out!
Goodreads has teamed with Fences for Books to Film 2017. They are asking WHAT BOOK WOULD YOU LIKE TO SEE ADAPTED FOR FILM AND WHY? and they made a handy and actually reliable listopia list of Early 2017's Biggest Book-to-Film Adaptions. You can also watch a trailer for the movie, for which I will be shocked if Viola doesn't win at least one award.
I'm actually thinking of using Big Little Lies for this one. Technically it will be a short series, but it's coming to HBO, & it's got movie-star power galore. Unless something comes up later in the year to replace it, I'm satisfied with this as my pick for this prompt.
Kirsten *Don't Be A Grinch* wrote: "Kenneth Branagh as Poirot? *shakes head in disbelief*"I know, right?
My pick is Hidden Figures: The American Dream and the Untold Story of the Black Women Mathematicians Who Helped Win the Space Race.
Amy wrote: "If a book becoming a movie is coming out Christmas Day 2016, is it not ok to read it for this prompt . The book is live by night by Dennis Lehane ? Any thoughts or should I find another pick"
It must be coming out on Christmas in only a select few cities, because the trailer says "In theaters Jan 13" - in which case, I say it counts for our 2017 challenge.
It must be coming out on Christmas in only a select few cities, because the trailer says "In theaters Jan 13" - in which case, I say it counts for our 2017 challenge.
I don't know if comic books/graphic novels are counting here, but Logan, Thor: Ragnarock, Guardians of the Galaxy 2, Wonder Wonan and The Justice League are all coming out this year. Also, My Cousin Rachel by Daphne DuMaurier, It by Stephen King, The Dinner by Herman Koch, and Beauty and the Beast are getting adaptations this year.
Jennifer wrote: "I don't know if comic books/graphic novels are counting here, but Logan, Thor: Ragnarock, Guardians of the Galaxy 2, Wonder Wonan and The Justice League are all coming out this year.
Also, My Cou..."
I think graphic novels count, but the trick is figuring out which set of comic books the movie is based on. Sometimes there isn't any one set of comic books you can read, because often they take the characters and backstory from the comic and write a new story for a movie. Same issue with Sherlock Holmes or James Bond (not that either of those have movies coming out this year, that I know of). And since the category is "a book that's becoming a movie", I'm not sure if it counts to read a book that's developed from the movie. What do you think?
Also, My Cou..."
I think graphic novels count, but the trick is figuring out which set of comic books the movie is based on. Sometimes there isn't any one set of comic books you can read, because often they take the characters and backstory from the comic and write a new story for a movie. Same issue with Sherlock Holmes or James Bond (not that either of those have movies coming out this year, that I know of). And since the category is "a book that's becoming a movie", I'm not sure if it counts to read a book that's developed from the movie. What do you think?
I just finished "The Mountain Between Us" by Martin Charles.The movie is to be released late in 2017.
I chose Hidden Figures as well.Kira wrote: "My pick is Hidden Figures: The American Dream and the Untold Story of the Black Women Mathematicians Who Helped Win the Space Race."
I think I'll do The Zookeeper's Wife for this one, as it was already on my Want-to-Read list and it's good for me to read some non-fiction; I've read other things by Diane Ackerman so I'm sure it will be good. And maybe I'll even see the movie!
I'm probably doing The Dark Tower by Stephen King. I've been meaning to read it ever since I read a related short story in... 1999/2000 sometimes. Should be about time. Otherwise, if you consider series as counting there's always American Gods by Neil Gaiman. It's supposed to air in 2017 .
Books mentioned in this topic
My Cousin Rachel (other topics)First They Killed My Father: A Daughter of Cambodia Remembers (other topics)
Wonderstruck (other topics)
Mudbound (other topics)
The Circle (other topics)
More...
Authors mentioned in this topic
Dave Eggers (other topics)Dave Eggers (other topics)
Dave Eggers (other topics)
Dave Eggers (other topics)
Dave Eggers (other topics)














All the Bright Places -- absolutely loved this book
Ready Player One -- on my TBR
Wonder -- *heart melts with fondness*
A Dog's Purpose -- the trailer for this looks amazing (see also "nonhuman perspective")
The Bell Jar -- what the what?
A Wrinkle in Time
Here's one of the lists I found: http://booksandchardonnay.com/books-b...
Here's another: http://www.mtv.com/news/2917285/books...
I Google so you don't have to. ;-)