Tome Topple Readathon discussion

418 views
Book Discussions > A Game of Thrones by George R.R. Martin

Comments Showing 1-50 of 76 (76 new)    post a comment »
« previous 1

message 1: by Samantha (new)

Samantha (thoughtsontomes) | 49 comments Mod
Use this thread to discuss A Game of Thrones!

DO NOT post spoilers of any kind without using the spoiler tag (the goodreads HTML info is listed in the corner for how to do that) and don't post spoilers for any other books in the series.

Note: These discussion boards will not be heavily moderated, so please do be careful about spoilers and using the tags, as we probably will not catch any slips. Also keep all discussions in here civil, friendly, and on topic. If there are any questionable threads happening, please contact the mods via messaging. Thank you for doing your part to make these buddy reads a happy and engaging experience :)


message 2: by Jackie (new)

Jackie (goodreadscomrumbelle517) I'm going to start this one, but it will be a reread of the first one. I barely remember, so rereading as a refresher.


message 3: by Christeena (new)

Christeena (christeenagot) | 4 comments Never read it, but have seen the show, and plan to read it! :) I can't wait!


message 4: by Joanna (new)

Joanna  (joreadsalot) | 7 comments I literally just bought the illustrated edition yesterday and I am a bit scared. I need to buddy read this with someone LOL


message 5: by Tyra (new)

Tyra (cloverhandreader) | 1 comments I'm going to try and read this, it's my priority read for this readathon


message 6: by Christeena (new)

Christeena (christeenagot) | 4 comments I saw the illustrated version! So lucky!! I'm making this one a priority, too! Starting Saturday most likely!


message 7: by Kaitlin (new)

Kaitlin Hicks | 3 comments I am so scared to start this but I cant wait!


message 8: by Jackie (new)

Jackie (goodreadscomrumbelle517) I won't be able to start reading this one until Sunday or Monday with moving and all. I hope I'll remember what happens better this time around.


message 9: by Elina (new)

Elina Tola (Bookeliina) (elinatola) | 3 comments I just started first book on audiobook - it's 200 hours long! But I've put it off for too long.


message 10: by Ellana (new)

Ellana Thornton-Wheybrew (ellanarosetw) | 5 comments I'm waiting for my Kobo to finish charging, then I'm going to start reading this. I have a collection of the first five novels in one eBook, so I'm just going to work my way through the series.

If anyone wants to buddyread, I'm on Litsy @EllanaRose or you can just add me on here as a friend.


Lourdes (Chapters We Love) (chapterswelove) | 3 comments Jackie wrote: "I won't be able to start reading this one until Sunday or Monday with moving and all. I hope I'll remember what happens better this time around."

I'm starting this one tonite!


message 12: by Aspen (new)

Aspen (aspenschuette) Just started reading this today! I've been putting it off for FAR too long.


message 13: by Kelley (new)

Kelley | 4 comments @leona I'm listening to the audio book and reading it. I hope it's not considered cheating lol.


message 14: by Elina (new)

Elina Tola (Bookeliina) (elinatola) | 3 comments My illustrated version just arrived and I'm switching from audio to book. I'm ~20% done with book 1 and I love it.


message 15: by Kelley (new)

Kelley | 4 comments @Elina what do you think of the narrator?


message 16: by Elina (new)

Elina Tola (Bookeliina) (elinatola) | 3 comments @ Kelly how is your reading/listening going on?
I like Roy Dotrice as narrator. I saw an interview with him and I was surprised to find out that he was doing voices for all of the of characters by himself. For me I might have liked female voice for female characters a bit better, but he makes perfect Sansa in my mind.
I am constantly switching betveen audio and book - audiobook allows me to multitask and hardcover allows me to relax at evenings.


message 17: by Kelley (new)

Kelley | 4 comments @Elina I do like his voice for the men characters but I wish they had a female narrator for the female characters. I think it would have made the audio book more enjoyable.


message 18: by Heather (new)

Heather | 14 comments Leona wrote: "I'm trying to decide if I should listen to this on audio or tackle this monster on my own...choices, choices, choices"
I would try the audio book, if you have access to it. This seems like a good audio to listen to while exercising, or sitting in traffic...kill two birds with one stone, and squeeze in extra reading time eyes-free ;)


message 19: by Jackie (new)

Jackie (goodreadscomrumbelle517) I'm starting Clash of Kings for this round of Tome Topple.


message 20: by Beth (new)

Beth Andrews | 4 comments I'm reading the 1st book for this round of the Topple, I'd totally be down to have a buddy to read with, discuss and keep up motivation!


message 21: by JazzRJ (new)

JazzRJ (jazz_reads) | 3 comments Beth wrote: "I'm reading the 1st book for this round of the Topple, I'd totally be down to have a buddy to read with, discuss and keep up motivation!"
I'm planning to read the first book too and would love to buddy read it with someone. Maybe we can team up.


message 22: by Beth (new)

Beth Andrews | 4 comments JazzRJ wrote: "Beth wrote: "I'm reading the 1st book for this round of the Topple, I'd totally be down to have a buddy to read with, discuss and keep up motivation!"
I'm planning to read the first book too and wo..."


I'd love to team up, send me a message!


message 23: by Pooka (new)

Pooka Cronan | 2 comments Reading the first A Song Of Ice And Fire book:
A Game Of Thrones
Would love somebody to team up with to tackle this almost 1000 page monster. :)


message 24: by Danielle ♥ (last edited Apr 04, 2017 07:31AM) (new)

Danielle ♥ (readwithmedani) | 17 comments @beth @jazz @dylan do you guys want to make a little group? I'm reading GOT #1 too & could use buddies and motivation too! maybe we can have twitter sprints or even live google hangouts every other day or so? i'd be happy to host. LMK! I ordered the box set, it will arrive Thursday :D


message 25: by JazzRJ (new)

JazzRJ (jazz_reads) | 3 comments Danielle ♥ wrote: "@beth @jazz @dylan do you guys want to make a little group? I'm reading GOT #1 too & could use buddies and motivation too! maybe we can have twitter sprints or even live google hangouts every other..."

I'm already buddy reading this with Dylan and Beth. If both of them are okay with it I'm totally in for the 4 of us teaming up. Regardless I'm willing to read with all three of you if you want. I'm just learning to use google hangouts but it seems like a good way to chat if you're up for hosting.


message 26: by Beth (new)

Beth Andrews | 4 comments JazzRJ wrote: "Danielle ♥ wrote: "@beth @jazz @dylan do you guys want to make a little group? I'm reading GOT #1 too & could use buddies and motivation too! maybe we can have twitter sprints or even live google h..."
Doing a bigger team up sounds like a ton of fun, I'm all for it!


message 27: by Danielle ♥ (new)

Danielle ♥ (readwithmedani) | 17 comments Oh, I definitely don't want to impose, it's totally up to you.


message 28: by c e l w e n e (new)

c e l w e n e Hey, if it's ok for you, is it ok for me to join you? I want to read a game of thrones, I've started it a while back and i want to read it from the beginning. Is that ok if I join your little group of 4?


message 29: by Danielle ♥ (last edited Apr 05, 2017 04:33PM) (new)

Danielle ♥ (readwithmedani) | 17 comments I'm going to host a google hangout just about every other night around 9pm EST starting tonight :D If you want to join to discuss, please do!!! I'll post here before I go live. You can join here: https://hangouts.google.com/group/nbU...


message 30: by c e l w e n e (new)

c e l w e n e I would love to join but I've never used Hangouts i don't quite know how it works. Do you have to invite me in the group or how can i join you?


message 31: by JazzRJ (new)

JazzRJ (jazz_reads) | 3 comments Danielle ♥ wrote: "I'm going to host a google hangout just about every other night around 9pm EST starting tonight :D If you want to join to discuss, please do!!! I'll post here before I go live with the info."

Okay great. I think us chatting there will be the best way to figure out our approach. I'll message Dylan and let him know about the group.


message 32: by Danielle ♥ (last edited Apr 05, 2017 04:33PM) (new)

Danielle ♥ (readwithmedani) | 17 comments Glenshaw wrote: "I would love to join but I've never used Hangouts i don't quite know how it works. Do you have to invite me in the group or how can i join you?"

You just need a google/gmail account to do it :) you can join here: https://hangouts.google.com/group/nbU...


message 33: by Danielle ♥ (new)

Danielle ♥ (readwithmedani) | 17 comments Bookchat starts in 10 minutes! 9pm EST. You need a google/gmail login to join. The video chat is enabled so grab your earbuds with the little microphones! The speakerphone mics don't work as well. You can just chat if you don't want to join the video call. https://hangouts.google.com/group/nbU...


message 34: by Abigail (new)

Abigail Phillips | 2 comments I've been sitting on this audiobook for a while now but im excited to finally get to it!!


message 35: by Meredith (new)

Meredith Wilson (likoali) | 11 comments I just finished A Storm of Swords, which is the third book! It is my favorite so far!! I can't wait to get into the fourth one! I'll probably post a review on my Youtube channel Liko Loves Books. It is a long read but it is sooo worth it!


message 36: by Danielle ♥ (last edited Apr 08, 2017 06:10PM) (new)

Danielle ♥ (readwithmedani) | 17 comments GoT Book 1 Live Chat every night at 9pm EST. https://hangouts.google.com/group/nbU...
You need a google/gmail login to join. It's a semi-no-spoiler chat, people are reading for the first time who haven't seen the tv show either, so we discuss no further than necessary. Announce how far you are when you arrive in the chat (use page #, percentage, etc and not an event so as not to spoil). Video chat can be enabled upon request of the participants' majority vote (earbuds w/ microphones required). Hope to see you there!


message 37: by Danielle ♥ (new)

Danielle ♥ (readwithmedani) | 17 comments 55% Do NOT care for the Arryns so far... :[ I love Catelyn but I don't understand what she is hoping to accomplish by (view spoiler)


message 38: by Meredith (new)

Meredith Wilson (likoali) | 11 comments You're going to love it! I'm starting the fourth book soon. It has swept me away!


message 39: by Danielle ♥ (new)

Danielle ♥ (readwithmedani) | 17 comments Meredith wrote: "You're going to love it! I'm starting the fourth book soon. It has swept me away!"

This thread is only for book one, though, right?


message 40: by Meredith (new)

Meredith Wilson (likoali) | 11 comments I'm not going to talk about the other books, but I wanted to be a part of the discussion for Tome Topple. If it's ok. If not I understand. Thanks


message 41: by Danielle ♥ (new)

Danielle ♥ (readwithmedani) | 17 comments Meredith wrote: "I'm not going to talk about the other books, but I wanted to be a part of the discussion for Tome Topple. If it's ok. If not I understand. Thanks"

Oh absolutely; I'm just making sure I'm in the right place so I don't get spoiled :)


message 42: by Meredith (new)

Meredith Wilson (likoali) | 11 comments Thank you! I wouldn't spoil it for anyone but I love the story so much that I like participating in the discussions. I hope you enjoy it, it's my favorite series so far!


message 43: by Danielle ♥ (last edited Apr 10, 2017 10:38AM) (new)

Danielle ♥ (readwithmedani) | 17 comments I am REALLY loving it! I have seen the tv show so that helps A LOT otherwise I think I'd be a little overwhelmed with characters and roles. I'm just over halfway, about pg 460, after Tyrion & Catelyn go to (view spoiler)


message 44: by Meredith (new)

Meredith Wilson (likoali) | 11 comments Nice!! You will love it. I only watched half of the pilot and decided to read the books first. Usually shows or movies tend to ruin the books for me. But I heard in this case I would have been safe because the shows are amazing.


message 45: by Danielle ♥ (last edited Apr 11, 2017 10:10AM) (new)

Danielle ♥ (readwithmedani) | 17 comments Meredith wrote: "Nice!! You will love it. I only watched half of the pilot and decided to read the books first. Usually shows or movies tend to ruin the books for me. But I heard in this case I would have been safe..."

Its SOO impressive how closely the episodes match the books. Obviously some minor things are left out due to time constraints, otherwise they do a fantastic job of choosing what to include/leave out. I'm watching right after I read it. I found an awesome Chapter to Episode chart, I can share if you're interested, it covers the first three seasons which is the first 4-5 books.


message 46: by Danielle ♥ (last edited Apr 11, 2017 10:16AM) (new)

Danielle ♥ (readwithmedani) | 17 comments I just passed page 500 ... into the part where Ned and Cersei (view spoiler) and Robert returns from hunting and (view spoiler). Now you KNOW something bad is going to happen. Or a plot for something bad is totally going to start. Nothing good can come of all this.


message 47: by Meredith (new)

Meredith Wilson (likoali) | 11 comments Sure I would love that! You will definitely grow to not like the Lannisters at all! Although later on I'm okay with Jamie and Tyrion


message 48: by Meredith (new)

Meredith Wilson (likoali) | 11 comments But Cersei and Joffrey....ugh those two are so awful. I see where he gets it from


message 49: by Snail (new)

Snail Oh, good luck to everyone! Enjoy :D I'm reading "A Dance with Dragons" for the readathon so I won't be posting I guess, don't want to spoil the fun.


message 50: by Meredith (new)

Meredith Wilson (likoali) | 11 comments It's okay Snail I'm on A Feast for Crows but I just make sure I talk about the first book. It's fun! You can stay 🙂


« previous 1
back to top