Fantasy Buddy Reads discussion
note: This topic has been closed to new comments.
Archive [General]
>
Buddy Read Invite (Retired)
message 1901:
by
Siobhan
(new)
Dec 19, 2017 12:46PM

reply
|
flag

Perfect excuse for a reread ;-). And I just asked the mods for a thread to be created for Six of Crows.

*blinks*
Oooookay. Brushing aside the whole "kids books are worthless" subtext, that was a bit... illogical. I don't think that's how buying habits work...
Edit: ooops sorry I didn't see the drop the subject bit till later. dropping it now.

Yes I remember smiling at some references from Grisha trilogy :) Grisha trilogy is good too but can't beat the Six of Crows. Everything is fast paced and deeper compared to Grisha.
Sha wrote: "Nyssa wrote: "Lynn Shepard - Attitude: See Article"
*blinks*
Oooookay. Brushing aside the whole "kids books are worthless" subtext, that was a bit... illogical. I don't think that's how buying hab..."
I was part of "tangential topic ring" a few weeks ago... when we start these interesting side discussions, we can just create a thread over in Hodge Podge and continue them....
I created a topic just now for it: https://www.goodreads.com/topic/show/...
*blinks*
Oooookay. Brushing aside the whole "kids books are worthless" subtext, that was a bit... illogical. I don't think that's how buying hab..."
I was part of "tangential topic ring" a few weeks ago... when we start these interesting side discussions, we can just create a thread over in Hodge Podge and continue them....
I created a topic just now for it: https://www.goodreads.com/topic/show/...

Raymond E. Feist - Magician.."
I'd love to buddy read Magician, but I don't think I can fit it into 2018.

I created a topic just now for it: https://www.goodreads.com/topic/show/...
"
Thank you for this!
Nyssa wrote: "Jenna wrote: "Anyone interested in reading any of these books next year (I'm very flexible as far as scheduling goes):
Raymond E. Feist - Magician.."
I'd love to buddy read Magician, but I don't ..."
That's okay - some other time :)
Raymond E. Feist - Magician.."
I'd love to buddy read Magician, but I don't ..."
That's okay - some other time :)

Its on my list, but I still ha..."
Delitealex wrote: "Siobhan wrote: "Sarah wrote: "Siobhan wrote: "Hailee and I are planning to read Six of Crows around March 15th. Just checking if anyone else would be interested? :)"
Its on my list..."
I've just read a number of things that insist its better to read the Grisha trilogy first, so that's how I'm going to do it or else I'd feel like I was reading it wrong. I'm just weird like that. *shrugs*

I'm with you Ahdam.

I also have some middlegrade series that I want to get back to, if anyone is interested in buddy reading them. I'll be picking up the Fablehaven series with book two and the Ranger's Apprentice series with book five.

Rea wrote: "@Jenna I need tooo, I shelved it, made it 50% in and got sucked into another series."
Oh, hate it when that happens. The other series must have been really good though!
When do you want to read it?
Oh, hate it when that happens. The other series must have been really good though!
When do you want to read it?


Oh, hate it when that happens. The other series must have been really good though!
When do you wan..."
I guess we have The Way of Kings BR in april. We can do it after WOK and WOR ?

That blasphemy has 6.2 bonus points :)
Did you guys see the cheatery we discovered with The Way of Kings? There's a Nook edition listed with 3159 pages because Nook measures pages as what fits on the screen... that's 7.9 bonus points from challenge and 15.8 bonus points from buddy read, on top of 31.6 regular points... for 55.3 points... I don't think that edition could count, but I'll leave that to the mods to decide... there's also a weird ebook edition with 2400 pages, then the mass market paperback has 1258 pages...

I must have missed this decision... it will save time, tho if true...
It does kinda make all this work some of us did putting this reference together for all the Buddy Reads a waste, tho... and I would think Jenna would have stopped us for doing it wrong...
https://www.goodreads.com/topic/show/...
It does kinda make all this work some of us did putting this reference together for all the Buddy Reads a waste, tho... and I would think Jenna would have stopped us for doing it wrong...
https://www.goodreads.com/topic/show/...

Whatever y'all agree on should work though. That's a lot of work y'all did there..

I would be down whenever. I'm jumping head first into Malazan, and hoping to wrap up *fingers crossed* ASoFaI as well as WoT.
None of the mods except me have really been around, I'm leaning towards making it just the most popular edition because all of this is starting to become a big hassle when it doesn't need to be, but I'll get back to you on it.

I'd be fairly happy just going with whatever edition I'm actually reading. I'm really particular about shelving the right one! Haha.
I do totally understand using the longest one available to keep it fair, but like Iain said with WoK there are some crazy anomalies. I'll be reading that as two books, wonder what the page count is there...
It'll suck having to re-do the reference list, but it will balance out on time saved in the future, I think...
and remove all the oddities we encountered from contention...
Now that we're in the thick of it, we are finding the problems with the system and ironing them out... save everything learned for if/when you guys choose to do this again (I assume this won't be an every year thing if you choose to repeat it... some people might find the competition stressful, especially towards the end, when holidays are keeping people busy elsewhere)
and remove all the oddities we encountered from contention...
Now that we're in the thick of it, we are finding the problems with the system and ironing them out... save everything learned for if/when you guys choose to do this again (I assume this won't be an every year thing if you choose to repeat it... some people might find the competition stressful, especially towards the end, when holidays are keeping people busy elsewhere)

I'm exactly the same about shelving the particular edition I am reading. In fact gone so far as to join the goodreads librarian group because several times the edition I own hasn't been there, is missing a cover or had an incorrect page count and so I've requested that it be corrected otherwise it drives me mad.
Yea... I'm a member of the Librarian Group, altho I don't use it much... I joined after reading the "prequel" to World of the Lupi by Eileen WIlks...
Turned out, it was actually an earlier version of the first book, published as a novella, with weird differences (like a pet cat instead of a dog) and made getting into the first book really hard...
I think so many people complained about the novella and getting warnings attached to it, that the book has been deleted from Goodreads now, because I can't find it anymore, and I used my review to warn people before the Librarians updated the blurb...
Turned out, it was actually an earlier version of the first book, published as a novella, with weird differences (like a pet cat instead of a dog) and made getting into the first book really hard...
I think so many people complained about the novella and getting warnings attached to it, that the book has been deleted from Goodreads now, because I can't find it anymore, and I used my review to warn people before the Librarians updated the blurb...
Iain wrote: "It'll suck having to re-do the reference list, but it will balance out on time saved in the future, I think...
and remove all the oddities we encountered from contention...
Now that we're in the ..."
That's what I'm thinking and generally leaning towards because as buddy reads are added, we'll constantly be doing this. Still waiting to hear back from other mods, but don't put any more work into for now.
and remove all the oddities we encountered from contention...
Now that we're in the ..."
That's what I'm thinking and generally leaning towards because as buddy reads are added, we'll constantly be doing this. Still waiting to hear back from other mods, but don't put any more work into for now.
Beste wrote: "Jenna wrote: "Rea wrote: "@Jenna I need tooo, I shelved it, made it 50% in and got sucked into another series."
Oh, hate it when that happens. The other series must have been really good though!
W..."
I don't mind waiting, but if there's anyone who wants to do Oathbringer earlier we could do a different buddy read.
Oh, hate it when that happens. The other series must have been really good though!
W..."
I don't mind waiting, but if there's anyone who wants to do Oathbringer earlier we could do a different buddy read.
Rea wrote: "I'm down whenever. I'll kust have to jumble some stuff around but it's doable."
Is February good for you or do you need more time?
Is February good for you or do you need more time?

I'm exactly the same about shelving the particular edition I am readin..."
I need to do that too. My boyfriend reads a lot of old obscure books and he hates when his edition doesn't have the right cover photo or page count etc.
Maybe I just read too much, but if I kept everything accurate like that, I'd waste days more than I already do on Goodreads... I messed with it a bit the year I read 100,000 pages to try and get an accurate count, and changing editions when books had 0 pages listed... but I mostly just live with whichever edition comes up...

I'm exactly the same about shelving the particular edit..."
@Siobhan. Its a good way to do it. I've never had to wait more than a couple of hours for the librarians to fix my issue. One time they answered me within 4 minutes!!

I know it bothers people a lot less. But if I didn't get the right edition every time there would be a constant niggle in my brain everytime i logged in and looked at my home page. Plus if the page count isn't correct I get the wrong total page count at the end of year stats. But yeah I only average about 40 books a year so I can see why you might not have the time to worry about each edition of the 1 million books you read a year 😂😁
I read 70,431 pages across 180 books this year +/- 1-2k pages... compared to 63,764 pages across 187 books last year (13 books aren't being counted because I didn't go back and fix them when multiple read dates were implemented... and 4 had no page number... so it's probably more like 68k pages across 200 books)...
So despite any small discrepencies, I know I met my goal of reading longer books in 2017... and that's good enough for me...
I'll be able to say tomorrow, once all my edition and review changes are recognized on the stats page...
So despite any small discrepencies, I know I met my goal of reading longer books in 2017... and that's good enough for me...
I'll be able to say tomorrow, once all my edition and review changes are recognized on the stats page...


Hi Nicole, I’ve read it but if you’re willing to continue the series I want to do buddy read for The Stone Sky.
Rea wrote: "@ Jenna Febuary is good for me. School will be thick in the throws for me and I welcome all open avenues of escape 😂"
Sweet, I'll set it for Feb 1st for now and we can always change it.
Sweet, I'll set it for Feb 1st for now and we can always change it.
This topic has been frozen by the moderator. No new comments can be posted.
Books mentioned in this topic
Legend (other topics)Sixteen Ways to Defend a Walled City (other topics)
Dragon and Thief (other topics)
Fairy Tale (other topics)
Dragon and Thief (other topics)
More...
Authors mentioned in this topic
Stephen King (other topics)Stephen King (other topics)
Stephen King (other topics)
Stephen King (other topics)
Stephen King (other topics)
More...