What's your favorite book to movie adaptation of a fantasy or science fiction novel?

[C.J.]

...or what adaptation do you think DIDN'T work?

Personally, I loved The Lion, the Witch, and the Wardrobe movie by Walden Media. Even though some things were changed from the book, all were great. It was simply... magical!

Prince Caspian and The Voyage of the Dawn Treader were disasters, IMO. They changed way too much to please this avid fan.

The Hunger Games movies were wonderfully done as well, but Divergent? Meh. Didn't love those.

There's Ender's Game (which I didn't see or read the book yet)

[Ashley]

I agree with you about the Narnia movies. The first one was great, but the other two didn't follow the books at all!

[C.J.]

I know! I think the silly changes were the big problem. They alienated their biggest fans by doing so.