Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows
discussion
Ambiguity in Riddle and Harry's bond
date
newest »
newest »
I definitely think there's a bond between Harry and Voldemort that can't be denied. It's all over the series but it presented itself most clearly to me when Harry says something like "I see a future where Ginny can have a husband whereas I can only see Voldemort". It does imply a kind of marriage between Harry and V that Othello and Iago have in Shakespeare's play. I'll always remember that analysis of Othello when the professor was talking about the scene where they bond. I don't think there's homoeroticism in the sense that they want to have sex though. But the relationships betweeen people of the same gender are ultimately relationship between two human beings and there's more to us than our genetials. I can see how you're making light of the scene but I think your comments are revealing of Rowling's intentions. Lastly, although I think Rowling definitely has feelings for her character I don't think they dwarfed other elements of the storytelling. her love of Snape for example also came clear. Hell, I think she even had some feelings for Riddle. I've heard she's been depressed after finishing the series and I don't blame her. I would feel the same way.
There are examples of a similar bond between enemies in all of literature.
The gay theme I can't help but shake is Dumbledore! I never can quite buy that whole loner thing when he has so much going on with him to make him a great lover, and no person is ever mentioned in that vain from his past. Has anyone else felt that way?
The bond between Harry & Voldemort was intense I'll admit but I don’t think J.K.'s intention was to make it seem at all homoerotic. I think Harry's connection to Voldemort and the likenesses they shared were more of an affliction than anything, caused in more ways than one, by the night when the curse went wrong. As far as Dumbledore, J.K. revealed that Grindlewald was the love of his life up until the day he passed. I don’t know about any post “for the greater good” relationships but if his feelings were truly to that extent I wouldn’t doubt that he remained partner-less for the better part of his life.
all discussions on this book
|
post a new topic
The Bees (other topics)
Born a Crime: Stories From a South African Childhood (other topics)
Coraline (other topics)
A Woman First: First Woman: A Memoir (other topics)
More...
Selina Meyer (other topics)
Toby Clements (other topics)
Bronson Pinchot (other topics)
Bahni Turpin (other topics)
More...
Books mentioned in this topic
Between the World and Me (other topics)The Bees (other topics)
Born a Crime: Stories From a South African Childhood (other topics)
Coraline (other topics)
A Woman First: First Woman: A Memoir (other topics)
More...
Authors mentioned in this topic
Stephen Briggs (other topics)Selina Meyer (other topics)
Toby Clements (other topics)
Bronson Pinchot (other topics)
Bahni Turpin (other topics)
More...

Sorry if I've stepped too far outside the boundaries of appropriate analysis of a children's series.
Let me also say that I doubt anyone will agree with this radical interpretation of several asides made by characters in the heat of battle, but yet, something about their bond became rather unique in this final installment.
I wonder if the bond the two have is akin to what Rowling feels for Harry. By the end of the series, her own obsession for the character seemed to dwarf other elements of her storytelling (much like Anne Rice's fixation with Lestat in her own chronicles, if anyone is familiar), and perhaps severing the tie to Harry was as intimate as having him sever the tie to his enemy.
Okay, okay, I'm digging way too deep here. Time to put down the shovel.