YOUNG ADULT BOOKWORMS ツ discussion

The Hobbit, or There and Back Again
146 views
Lord of the Rings > The Hobbit

Comments Showing 1-29 of 29 (29 new)    post a comment »
dateUp arrow    newest »

message 1: by Sikhandi, Founder (new) - added it

Sikhandi Thiagarajah | 494 comments Mod
The capitalization says it all :P.. The book that started it all (sorta..im being dramatic so bear with me). This is the book that brought on the lord of the rings series but lets not talk about that right now . What did you think of the Hobbit and did you think the movies matched the book?
Bilbo Baggins ..enough said :D


message 2: by Perlite, Mod #2 (new) - rated it 5 stars

Perlite | 227 comments Mod
Hobbit is u knw amazeball!...But yes Bilbo Baggins (in the movie obvi) says everything & u should add Lord of The Rings trilogy!! Even though I hadn't read it who the hell cares?


message 3: by Sikhandi, Founder (new) - added it

Sikhandi Thiagarajah | 494 comments Mod
i did check


Renee (renspill) | 22 comments Loved the book (it took me twice to get through the whole thing the first time tho). And the first two movies were impressive although I don't think three movies were necessary.


message 5: by Sikhandi, Founder (new) - added it

Sikhandi Thiagarajah | 494 comments Mod
Renspill wrote: "Loved the book (it took me twice to get through the whole thing the first time tho). And the first two movies were impressive although I don't think three movies were necessary."

There's a third??? I thought desolation of smaug was the last ?


Renee (renspill) | 22 comments They already made two hobbit movies and the third is coming out in the next year I believe


message 7: by Sikhandi, Founder (new) - added it

Sikhandi Thiagarajah | 494 comments Mod
oh right


message 8: by Leah (new)

Leah | 620 comments Ye. I never really got into The Lord of the Rings trilogy. I'm determined to read them all but so far I've never really been that interested.


message 9: by Sikhandi, Founder (new) - added it

Sikhandi Thiagarajah | 494 comments Mod
Leah wrote: "Ye. I never really got into The Lord of the Rings trilogy. I'm determined to read them all but so far I've never really been that interested."

Honestly ive just read the Hobbit .. i havent read the lord of the rings books ..ever since i was small i had this weird fear of the characters in it.. the darkness overwhelmed me :P


message 10: by Rafael (new)

Rafael Sparks | 3 comments Leah wrote: "Ye. I never really got into The Lord of the Rings trilogy. I'm determined to read them all but so far I've never really been that interested."

You should start with the Hobbit! It's much lighter and hearthly than Lord of the Rings, being a breeze to read and and amazing and very entertaining story, as most of the times, better than the movies too :)

Give it a go and tell me what you think!


message 11: by Leah (new)

Leah | 620 comments Thanks! Will do. I've started the hobbit many times and never really got it. Oh and why does the dragon talk?? That's so stupid!!


message 12: by Sikhandi, Founder (new) - added it

Sikhandi Thiagarajah | 494 comments Mod
I'm gonna read it after the mortal instruments


message 13: by Rafael (new)

Rafael Sparks | 3 comments Leah wrote: "Thanks! Will do. I've started the hobbit many times and never really got it. Oh and why does the dragon talk?? That's so stupid!!"

usually most dragons talk :( at least in a sense, some actually have verbal speech, other talk through the mind or even some cases of body control, hardly you´ll see a dragon that doesn´t communicate.

they´re supposed to be one of the most ancient and powerfull races in most "worlds"


message 14: by Leah (new)

Leah | 620 comments I think it woulda been better if it communicated through the mind.


Lissa  (lissa99) Also, "the Hobbit" was written for children and talking dragons does sound like something that would be included in a children's book


message 16: by Kris (new) - rated it 5 stars

Kris | 22 comments I have an interesting connection to this book. My 7th grade English teacher suggested we read it. It was the year "The Fellowship of the Ring" came out in theaters. So I decided to try it a year later. I wanted to see if I would understand the story before I started reading the series. When I did read it, the second movie was about to come out in theaters. Rumor was that our next theater production at school that year was "The Hobbit". I went out for it and got the part of Gollum. My dad and a few of my friends had read the books already (I got sidetracked and still have to read the third book) so I saw the movies with them. I was one of the few girls in the whole theater! I saw the second one twice: once with my dad just after the performance, and once with my sister (who I had to explain the entire series to) before the show. I've since attempted to finish reading the series and have seen all (and own all on DVD) movies except the most recent "Hobbit" movie. From what I can tell, the movies are fairly close to the books. I can't say how close as I haven't read all the books yet.


message 17: by Leah (new)

Leah | 620 comments My Year 8 English teacher has recommended two books (one book one series) to me and I don't know how she knows me so well, they have both occurred on my favourites list!! And Top 10!! How?? She just recommends book and I fall in love with them!! It's a bit creepy and I don't know how she does it.


Sanjna (frost45) | 89 comments Are spoilers allowed in these discussions? Sorry, I am new to the group...


message 19: by Sikhandi, Founder (new) - added it

Sikhandi Thiagarajah | 494 comments Mod
Yeah they are :)


message 20: by J (new)

J Johnson Loved the hobbit!!!! Book was better then the movie as always. Definitely a have to read, I actually just recently read this. I really enjoyed it


message 21: by Valerie (new)

Valerie | 75 comments Is there a fandom name for this series?


message 22: by Sikhandi, Founder (new) - added it

Sikhandi Thiagarajah | 494 comments Mod
I think it falls under the LOTR fandom


message 23: by Emma (new) - added it

Emma | 421 comments Should you read the hobbit before LOTR or is there no special order?


s.shadereads Emma wrote: "Should you read the hobbit before LOTR or is there no special order?"

Technically you don't need to read it first because they are both standalone's but by reading the Hobbit first it definitely gives you a little more insight into LOTR.


message 25: by Emma (new) - added it

Emma | 421 comments Ah thank you so much!


message 26: by Lyra (new) - rated it 5 stars

Lyra (lyramarvelle) | 9 comments HOBBIT is one of the best books I've read. It is PERFECT and LOVELY and I don't think I'll ever get tired of reading it!! <3 I love the book so much!


message 27: by [deleted user] (new)

I love the hobbit so much :-) I read it when I was ten, then watched the films when they came out then I read the lord of the rings and I'm halfway through the Silmarillion. They're hard to read but worth it, I'm 14 and managed the lord of the rings in 6 weeks so everyone should try to get through it and at least past Tom Bombadill


charlotte_reads_reviews | 49 comments has anyone read the Silmarillion
also noticed Legolas and Tauriel aren't in the book ;( and no TaurielxKili as well


✮ ⋆ ˚。 ᗩᑌᗷᖇIE ⋆。°✩ | 2 comments I love the book and the movies!! The Hobbit is my favorite book of all time and I really enjoyed the movies, I cry so much on the third movie though 🥲


back to top