Reading the Detectives discussion
note: This topic has been closed to new comments.
Archived threads
>
What mysteries are you reading at the moment? Old thread
Elizabeth (Alaska) wrote: "Gardener0126 wrote: "I just finished two of the Hardcastle series by Graham Ison. They are police procedurals, with a bit of a cozy feel, set in the time of the First World War. I’m not always a fa..."I don’t think they need to be read in order. The characters do get older as evidenced by their children growing up, but the stories themselves don’t depend on earlier stories in the series. However, bear in mind that so far I have only read a couple of them. I plan to start another one this evening.
Judy wrote: "I've only read various introductions by Curtis Evans and there is also lots of good stuff on his blog, http://thepassingtramp.blogspot.com/I am interested in the sound of his book [book:Masters o..."
The word “humdrum” sort of makes you think “yawn” doesn’t it? I wonder what that says about me, since I have read and liked books by those authors!😂
Gardener0126 wrote: "However, bear in mind that so far I have only read a couple of them. I plan to start another one this evening. "Probably makes your observation even more accurate, as those you read were later ones. Thanks!
Jill wrote: "Now reading Real Tigers by Mick Herron and can't put it down."
Good to hear, Jill. I plan to re-read it when I have finished Black Roses
(another buddy read - we have a few this month).
Good to hear, Jill. I plan to re-read it when I have finished Black Roses
(another buddy read - we have a few this month).
I was only able to get Black Roses as an audiobook on Scribd, and wasn’t sure if I’d read it or not since I’m trying to catch up on other books so, to help decide, I listened to the first chapter and was drawn right in! If it keeps up at that pace, I know I’ll enjoy it. I look forward to getting back to it.Sorry, I’m not familiar with Curtis or Curt Evans.
Real Tigers was next on my TBR but I have it in hard cover and need a kindle book for the next couple of days so it will wait for the weekend. Bobby Owens may be next.
Gardener0126 wrote: "The word “humdrum” sort of makes you think “yawn” doesn’t it? I wonder what that says about me, since I have read and liked boos by those authors!😂 ..."
Apparently another detective story author, Julian Symons, called these writers "humdrum", because of the puzzle element to their books - but Curtis Evans said they are "of great interest to me for their clever puzzles and period English flavor."
This quote is from an interview with him:
https://pastoffences.wordpress.com/20...
I've read and enjoyed a couple of books by Crofts and by Street under his Miles Burton pen name, but would like to read more by them - I don't know anything by Alfred Walter Stewart but will look out for him!
Apparently another detective story author, Julian Symons, called these writers "humdrum", because of the puzzle element to their books - but Curtis Evans said they are "of great interest to me for their clever puzzles and period English flavor."
This quote is from an interview with him:
https://pastoffences.wordpress.com/20...
I've read and enjoyed a couple of books by Crofts and by Street under his Miles Burton pen name, but would like to read more by them - I don't know anything by Alfred Walter Stewart but will look out for him!
Judy wrote: "Gardener0126 wrote: "The word “humdrum” sort of makes you think “yawn” doesn’t it? I wonder what that says about me, since I have read and liked boos by those authors!😂 ..."Apparently another det..."
Alfred Walter Stewart wrote under the name of J. J. connington.
Gardener0126 wrote: "Alfred Walter Stewart wrote under the name of J. J. connington...."
Thanks, Gardener - have you read any of his books, and if so did you like them? He's a new name to me under either name...
Thanks, Gardener - have you read any of his books, and if so did you like them? He's a new name to me under either name...
Judy wrote: "Gardener0126 wrote: "Alfred Walter Stewart wrote under the name of J. J. connington...."Thanks, Gardener - have you read any of his books, and if so did you like them? He's a new name to me under..."
I read a couple in the Sir Clinton Driffield series a few years ago. I tend to like those old fashioned British police procedurals, so I enjoyed them. I think there was another series character as well, plus a few stand alone. Amazon US has some of his books in Kindle format.
Gentlemen & Players by Joanne Harris. Set in an independent boys' school, the chapters are narrated alternately by Roy Straitley, the elderly Latin master, and one of the new young teachers (which one not yet revealed) who has infiltrated the school for the purposeof revenge. Very exciting.
I loved Gentlemen and Players. Probably one of the best books I have read.Just finished Real Tigers by Mick Herron and The Scarecrow by Michael Connelly Now starting Black Roses
I loved Gentlemen and Players too. I'm reading several books. Loving, The Wych Elm
and have started Death Of A Doll
and have started Death Of A Doll
I just finished Death Of A DollI read that Hilda Lawrence only wrote 4 novels and that this one was considered her best. It was also the third one about her three series sleuths and I might have found it easier to get into, if I had actually read the publishers description of the book or had read the earlier books.. As it was, the sleuths showed up and I was wondering who on earth they were. (Once I went back to the description, I figured it out, so most people would not have that problem.). I thought that the book was extremely good, and the author really conveyed a strong sense of fear and menace, despite using next to no violence.
I am about half way through The Black Dahlia
. Whether I am ultimately not a fan of the hard-boiled detective variety, or this book is just particularly graphic and violent, I am not enjoying it at all. I am a true crime buff, and I have been intrigued by the real world case this was based on (and which has never been solved), but the characters are depressing, unsympathetic, and uninteresting.
Tara wrote: "I am about half way through The Black Dahlia
. Whether I am ultimately not a fan of the hard-boiled detective variety, or this book is just particular..."I had heard of The Black Dahlia but having read the synopsis, don’t think it’s for me. Best of luck with it Tara.
I’m just starting The Hanged Man of Saint-Pholien by Georges Simenon. I read the previous 2 books last year and they were both in my top 5 of the year, so I’m looking forward to this, number 3.
Tara wrote: "I am about half way through The Black Dahlia
. Whether I am ultimately not a fan of the hard-boiled detective variety, or this book is just particular..."You made it farther than I did, when I looked at it perhaps 10 years ago.
I've started Money in the Morgue: The New Inspector Alleyn Mystery by Ngaio Marsh and Stella Duffy - thought I'd slip this one in while the wartime books from the Marsh challenge were still fresh in my mind!
I'm quite enjoying it so far, but I think the change between the two authors was fairly noticeable as their styles are not very similar.
I'm quite enjoying it so far, but I think the change between the two authors was fairly noticeable as their styles are not very similar.
Judy wrote: "I've started Money in the Morgue: The New Inspector Alleyn Mystery by Ngaio Marsh and Stella Duffy - thought I'd slip this one in while the wartime boo..."
I have that on two week loan so will be reading it soon. Started Real Tigers last night and found it hard to put down.
I have that on two week loan so will be reading it soon. Started Real Tigers last night and found it hard to put down.
Jill wrote: "Labouring a bit with Black Roses so starting The Brass Verdict by Michael Connelly"I had no problem with Black Roses - found it a very interesting and satisfying read.
I'm reading The Age of Treachery by Gavin Scott, my Mum enjoyed it and passed it on to me. So far, so good - it's a murder and espionage mystery set in Oxford post-WWII. Several real-life characters make an appearance too which is quite fun.
I’m enjoying my reread of The Crossword Mystery and it is reminding me how much I like Mitchell! Looking forward to our discussion.
I’ve never read this author - I have The Crossword Mystery on Kindle, and found Information Received, the first in the series, on Scribd (my library didn’t have either in dead tree form).Do you recommend reading the first book first, or does it matter?
First, I always read in order so am prejudiced. These books are not linked plot-wise but in the first, Information Received, Bobby Owen (our hero) is new to the force and meets his boss / mentor Mitchell. By Crossword they have a working relationship. I found the second book, Sunbathers, rather weak.
Sandy wrote: "First, I always read in order so am prejudiced. These books are not linked plot-wise but in the first, Information Received, Bobby Owen (our hero) is new to the force and meets his boss / mentor Mi..."Thank you, good to know - I always read in order, if possible. I can forgive weaker plots in earlier books, but we often learn a lot about main characters, so they matter! Gives me a taste of an author’s style, as well.
I think Sunbathers cements the idea of how young and inexperienced is Bobby Owens and how he is perceived by other detectives, including his boss, Mitchell. I don't know that *all* of them need to be read in order (have read only the first 3), but I would definitely recommend reading the first two.
Elizabeth (Alaska) wrote: "I think Sunbathers cements the idea of how young and inexperienced is Bobby Owens and how he is perceived by other detectives, including his boss, Mitchell. I don't know that *all* of them need to ..."Thanks, Elizabeth- I’ve gotten hold of 1 and 3, I’ll see if I can get Sunbathers!
Susan in NC wrote: "Told you I’d get there - eventually! So many great books, so little time..."So right!
I am about half through Money in the Morgue, the book started by Marsh and finished by Stella Duffy. Alleyn is still in New Zealand and I think Duffy is emphasising that more than Marsh did. Lots of talk about New Zealand traits. Alleyn misses Fox and his crew every few pages. Of course he's been away longer and it is Christmas in the summer; quite unnerving for us from the northern hemisphere.
Susan in NC wrote: "Finished Dead Lions, dove right into The List: A Novella
."
Hurrah again! I love the novellas, Susan. The Drop: A Slough House Novella follows on from The List, if you like it.
."Hurrah again! I love the novellas, Susan. The Drop: A Slough House Novella follows on from The List, if you like it.
Sandy wrote: "I am about half through Money in the Morgue, the book started by Marsh and finished by Stella Duffy ..."
Are you enjoying this one, Sandy? I've nearly finished it now - while I enjoy the descriptions of the New Zealand scenery, so far I have found it rather slow and not as entertaining as Marsh on her own, to be honest.
Are you enjoying this one, Sandy? I've nearly finished it now - while I enjoy the descriptions of the New Zealand scenery, so far I have found it rather slow and not as entertaining as Marsh on her own, to be honest.
I fell behind so I’m busy reading ‘Singing Sands’ at the moment. I’m loving the story. It’s like a mystery and a travel book and a voyage of self discovery all at once.
Judy wrote: "Sandy wrote: "I am about half through Money in the Morgue, the book started by Marsh and finished by Stella Duffy ..."
Are you enjoying this one, Sandy? I've nearly finished it now..."
Only a so-so read for me. There were many parts I enjoyed but much felt drawn out with a rather strange ending. Have you read Stella Duffy? This book did not inspire me to try her.
Are you enjoying this one, Sandy? I've nearly finished it now..."
Only a so-so read for me. There were many parts I enjoyed but much felt drawn out with a rather strange ending. Have you read Stella Duffy? This book did not inspire me to try her.
Jemima wrote: "I fell behind so I’m busy reading ‘Singing Sands’ at the moment. I’m loving the story. It’s like a mystery and a travel book and a voyage of self discovery all at once."
Singing Sands has many layers, Jemima. Take your time and enjoy them all. The threads are always open.
Singing Sands has many layers, Jemima. Take your time and enjoy them all. The threads are always open.
Susan wrote: "Susan in NC wrote: "Finished Dead Lions, dove right into The List: A Novella
."Hurrah again! I love the novellas, Susan. [book:The Drop: A S..."
Ah, good to know, thank you - I thought that came later. I bought this on kindle, opened just to read the first few pages get a feel, and of course I was sucked right in! I read half before bed, I would’ve finished it if my eyes weren’t so tired and it wasn’t late!
Jemima wrote: "I fell behind so I’m busy reading ‘Singing Sands’ at the moment. I’m loving the story. It’s like a mystery and a travel book and a voyage of self discovery all at once."Lovely - that’s how I felt, as well!
Sandy wrote: "Have you read Stella Duffy? This book did not inspire me to try her. ..."
No, I haven't and not sure I will, although her own books with her own characters might be better.
No, I haven't and not sure I will, although her own books with her own characters might be better.
This topic has been frozen by the moderator. No new comments can be posted.
Books mentioned in this topic
Earthly Remains (other topics)A Rule Against Murder (other topics)
Earthly Remains (other topics)
Earthly Remains (other topics)
The Lake House (other topics)
More...
Authors mentioned in this topic
Kate Morton (other topics)E.F. Benson (other topics)
E.F. Benson (other topics)
Ed McBain (other topics)
Leslie Charteris (other topics)
More...







The publisher could fix that there. But at least it appears all of his books are under the one Curtis Evans profile here.
I used the "look inside" feature at Amazon. I haven't browsed this group enough to see whether anyone has been reading the three authors in that book. Where are we on those?