Reading the Detectives discussion
note: This topic has been closed to new comments.
Archived threads
>
What mysteries are you reading at the moment? Old thread


What did you think of it? It's in my pile somewhere.

Yes, I've read the first and third, which is why I went back to get this one. They are not readily available via Kindle, I think, and have picked them up as used books. I don't know that they all have to be read in order, but there is a character development in the third that I might have preferred not knowing now. Pears writes with wit in these, by the way.
Carolien wrote: "Susan wrote: "I just finished Snowblind
which I have meant to read for ages."
What did you think of it? It's in my pile somewhere."
I liked it, Carolien. Unlike a lot of Nordic Noir, it's not particularly violent and has more of a traditional mystery. There is even the amateur dramatic society, so beloved of us all :)

What did you think of it? It's in my pile somewhere."
I liked it, Carolien. Unlike a lot of Nordic Noir, it's not particularly violent and has more of a traditional mystery. There is even the amateur dramatic society, so beloved of us all :)


What did you think of it? It's in my pile somewhere."
..."
Thanks, will move it up the pile.



We are virtually reading the same books, Jill. I read Murder has a Motive (I too can't bear to read books out of order) and am currently reading Coffin, Scarcely Used. I can't recall who suggested the Flaxborough books, but I am glad that I have found them!
Jill wrote: "I was overly impressed with the Colin Watson, but as first in series they may grow on me"
I haven't finished it yet, but I am enjoying it so far. Also reading, Lucifer Falls, a NetGalley book, and the first in a series, which is set in Essex Road, quite close to where I work.
I haven't finished it yet, but I am enjoying it so far. Also reading, Lucifer Falls, a NetGalley book, and the first in a series, which is set in Essex Road, quite close to where I work.

Balaji wrote: "Reading The Imbroglio at the Villa Pozzi by Clara Benson. At this point in the series, I'm very much interested in knowing more about Angela, than the case itself."
I enjoyed the first two books in the series, Balaji. Stalled a bit in book 3, but I am keen to read on.
I enjoyed the first two books in the series, Balaji. Stalled a bit in book 3, but I am keen to read on.

You should check the rest out too. Story-wise it is not that captivating, the mysteries are not that complex, but the main character is developed very well through the series.

Started Singing to the Dead, I read the first in the series a while ago and enjoyed it. I am mainly looking for books set in cold places at the moment, we are in the throes of a heatwave.
Balaji wrote: "You should check the rest out too. Story-wise it is not that captivating, the mysteries are not that complex, but the main character is developed very well through the series...."
I've read the first four Clara Benson books so far and it is definitely the characters and the witty writing style which hook me in, rather than the plots as such. Hoping to get back to this series soon.
I've read the first four Clara Benson books so far and it is definitely the characters and the witty writing style which hook me in, rather than the plots as such. Hoping to get back to this series soon.

Anyway, I digress. I've bumped this up my reading list and I shall make sure to check the group read threads when I start reading. Better late than never right?!

Thanks Susan!

I need to actually try and read this series in order. I have a whole shelf full of them.

I need to actually try and read this series in order. I have a whole shelf full of them."
I don't know if all of them have been translated. Also I can't see there is any advantage to reading them in order.

Did you like Murder Has a Motive, Jill? I enjoyed it but liked Murder for Christmas more. I read that one first when it was republished, then caught up with Murder Has a Motive when the publisher brought out a few more of his titles.

Yes . I thought Mordecai Tremaine was a really likable character , and I liked the way we were able to know thoughts most of the time. His suspicions of everyone were quiet feasible and had me thinking along his lines. Not sure this was actually the first book he wrote in the series but maybe there are more to come. I do have the other three.
I'm planning to read Motive for Murder before our December read - which I have read before but remember nothing. Hope Motive will refresh Mordecai for me.
Certainly Motive was before Christmas, as they mention his antics in Dalmeering in the first chapter or two.

At the moment, I'm listening to Dying Light
the second Stuart MacBride novel. I love the narrator of these books, Steve Worsley.

I'm half thru Murder has a Motive; good story but I'm finding it a bit wordy. (Perhaps its just that I'm eager to move on in my reading list so I can pick up requested books at the library.)
Susan wrote: "Having to rush a read, or wanting to do so, can spoil your enjoyment of it, I find, Sandy."
Very true!
Very true!


Did you read the first in the series? Is this one that absolutely *should* be read in order?


How many of you reread your favorite mystery authors/books?
That was serendipity, Lark! I do reread my favourite mysteries, especially Sayers and Allingham. I first discovered Marsh in the 70s too!
Balaji wrote: "I recently found out that Agatha Christie's best selling novel of all time is And Then There Were None. So I am reading that at the moment. The premise is very intriguing and I'm dying..."
Ooh, my fave Christie, Balaji. Can't wait to hear your thoughts. I am currently re-reading (or listening, rather) to Murder on the Orient Express. Lovely comfortable listening, with David Suchet as an excellent narrator (although I do prefer Hugh Fraser to be honest, but, sadly, no Hastings on the train!).
Ooh, my fave Christie, Balaji. Can't wait to hear your thoughts. I am currently re-reading (or listening, rather) to Murder on the Orient Express. Lovely comfortable listening, with David Suchet as an excellent narrator (although I do prefer Hugh Fraser to be honest, but, sadly, no Hastings on the train!).

It is brilliantly written. I read it all night long and completed today around 4 am. It had me on the edge of my seat throughout the night and I was dying to know what would happen next, who would be the next victim, and also the killer's identity. At every turn, I thought okay he must be the killer, only to find him dead in the next few pages. Especially when (view spoiler) died I was lost for good. I had no more theories and had to read till the end. And then it came down to 4...then 3... and then 2, I was super alert at this point, I read on as fast as I could, I did not even pause to fetch water from the next room. I was thoroughly enjoying the experience. Finally, when it was revealed I was amazed at how a detective story could keep a reader on edge from page 1 till the very end. I am glad I picked it up and hoping to read more AC books in the future. Definitely, 5 stars this one. This is one of the best AC books that I have read till now.
Murder on the Orient Express: I read it last year and liked it very much. Have you seen the film adaptation? I hear its good.
Balaji and Susan, I'm looking forward to discussing Murder on the Orient Express next month in the Poirot buddy reads - just a few days to go!

I did, and it does help as it sets the context for the second book. The first book is excellent and the author takes a huge gamble in it - very brave.
This topic has been frozen by the moderator. No new comments can be posted.
Books mentioned in this topic
Earthly Remains (other topics)A Rule Against Murder (other topics)
Earthly Remains (other topics)
Earthly Remains (other topics)
The Lake House (other topics)
More...
Authors mentioned in this topic
Kate Morton (other topics)E.F. Benson (other topics)
E.F. Benson (other topics)
Ed McBain (other topics)
Leslie Charteris (other topics)
More...
Elizabeth, have you read the first one in the series? This looks like it may be (yet) another series to add to the list.