Reading the Detectives discussion
note: This topic has been closed to new comments.
Archived threads
>
What mysteries are you reading at the moment? Old thread
message 2651:
by
Judy
(new)
Jan 22, 2018 02:47PM

reply
|
flag





Donna Leon is an author I have been meaning to read. Do the books need to be read in order?

I missing out reading Envious Casca with the group since I got busy with work and things but I am going to pick it up sometime soon. Hoping it was as much fun as No Wind of Blame.
I am reading a review book The Long Silence: A 1920s' Hollywood Noir Mystery
It is set in 1922 Hollywood and is set around the murder of William Desmond Taylor. Enjoyable so far.

It is set in 1922 Hollywood and is set around the murder of William Desmond Taylor. Enjoyable so far.


Well, I'm probably not the best person to ask as I rarely read a series in order! But from the two I've read so far, the crimes are stand alone, while there is some continuity through Brunetti's family life and his interactions with his colleagues.
The next Leon book I have is #12 so I'll see if there's a huge leap forward!


It is set in 1922 Hollywood and i..."
That looks interesting.


My husband brought me a copy as a "Hi, I'm back from Oz after 7 weeks" present. It looks really interesting, I'd love to hear what you think.

Donna Leon is an author I have been meaning t..."
The crimes are standalone. The best benefit you'll get is the personal and family development, but it's a fairly flexible series.

Donna Leon is an author I have..."
Thanks Carolien!
And re: The Dry - I read it a few months ago and really liked it. It wasn't the best mystery ever but the setting and characters were so well done (especially for a first book!).

I have started our next buddy read The Documents in the Case
Really enjoying it so far - I've missed reading Sayers.

Really enjoying it so far - I've missed reading Sayers.
I'm really enjoying The Franchise Affair by Josephine Tey - very unusual because it isn't a murder mystery, but the story of two women who are accused of kidnapping a teenage girl. So far it has the same sort of fascination as Tey's Brat Farrar, which I enjoyed last year.

One of my all time favorites!
I am now very keen to read the third Campion book, having recently read, Mystery Mile. So pleased I gave the series another try.
Leslie wrote: "Judy wrote: "I'm really enjoying The Franchise Affair by Josephine Tey - very unusual because it isn't a murder mystery, but the story of two women who are accused of kidnapping a teenage girl. So ..."
Glad to hear you love it too, Leslie. I'm sad I have so few by Tey still to go now.
Glad to hear you love it too, Leslie. I'm sad I have so few by Tey still to go now.

I *loved* that book, too! I would re-read it but can't find my hard copy anywhere... at least with a Kindle books can't get lost.
I know the feeling re lost books - I'm sure I own a copy of Mystery Mile, but I had to borrow it from the library because I couldn't find it anywhere!
I've now finished The Franchise Affair and, while I really enjoyed it overall, I didn't think it was quite as good as the amazingly wonderful Brat Farrar.
Aside from the mystery, which isn't quite as brilliant, there is rather a lot of ranting about dreadful modern morals and attitudes, similar to some passages in later Christie books! So probably 3 1/2 stars overall for me. (I've put 4 though as I tend to round up.)
I've now finished The Franchise Affair and, while I really enjoyed it overall, I didn't think it was quite as good as the amazingly wonderful Brat Farrar.
Aside from the mystery, which isn't quite as brilliant, there is rather a lot of ranting about dreadful modern morals and attitudes, similar to some passages in later Christie books! So probably 3 1/2 stars overall for me. (I've put 4 though as I tend to round up.)


Am now starting The Documents in the Case for our group buddy read

I've now finished The Franchise Affair and, w..."
I think that my affection for The Franchise Affair has to do with how satisfying I find the ending to be. But given your comments, I think I should probably avoid rereading it so I can hold on to that affection (lol!).


I recently raced through a couple of historical mysteries.
One, Murder In the North End is set in Boston, USA, in the 1870's. This is a six book series with a definite arc that I am reading mostly to finish up the larger story (one more to go!). The mystery in this one was really only solved because a witness appeared and the murderer confessed. Also, I live near Boston, so enjoy the setting.
The second, What Remains of Heaven is set in the Regency period and has strong romantic elements. It is also a series with an arc and this series I love. I will probably pick up the next book when return this one.
I'm about to start the next Marsh.
One, Murder In the North End is set in Boston, USA, in the 1870's. This is a six book series with a definite arc that I am reading mostly to finish up the larger story (one more to go!). The mystery in this one was really only solved because a witness appeared and the murderer confessed. Also, I live near Boston, so enjoy the setting.
The second, What Remains of Heaven is set in the Regency period and has strong romantic elements. It is also a series with an arc and this series I love. I will probably pick up the next book when return this one.
I'm about to start the next Marsh.
Leslie wrote: "I think that my affection for The Franchise Affair has to do with how satisfying I find the ending to be. But given your comments, I think I should probably avoid rereading it so I can hold on to that affection (lol!). ..."
I loved the ending too, Leslie, and enjoyed the plot overall. I'd hate to put you off rereading - if I read it again in future, I will try to rush through any passages complaining about modern society, lol.
I loved the ending too, Leslie, and enjoyed the plot overall. I'd hate to put you off rereading - if I read it again in future, I will try to rush through any passages complaining about modern society, lol.

Oh, I have this book -- I look forward to hearing what you think.
Leslie wrote: "Tania wrote: "I'm reading Always a Cold Deck first book in a historical series with an insurance investigater."
Oh, I have this book -- I look forward to hearing what you think."
I too own it, so am also looking forward to your comments.
Oh, I have this book -- I look forward to hearing what you think."
I too own it, so am also looking forward to your comments.
Having an insurance investigator as detective sounds like a promising set-up.
I’ve started Mystery Mile and am remembering how much I love Allingham.
I’ve started Mystery Mile and am remembering how much I love Allingham.

I've found I have the first three in this series, all free from Amazon at some point. Looking forward to see what you think.

Tania wrote: "I have finished and would say 2.5* which I rounded up. Not bad, but an overly complicated plot, and I found it hard to care. I will read the next one at some point, but won't carry on if that one d..."
Well, guess I'll keep them on my TBR, but not move them higher up the list. Thanks for the feedback.
Well, guess I'll keep them on my TBR, but not move them higher up the list. Thanks for the feedback.



One of my favorites. Have you read it before?
I've started Over My Dead Body on audio in preparation for Black Orchids, our buddy read later.
And tonight I expect to start and finish A Bucket of Ashes, the final entry in a series that takes place in Boston after the Civil War (USA - both Boston and the war). It looks pretty short and they have been easy reads. I need to get this couple united after all their trials and tribulations.
And tonight I expect to start and finish A Bucket of Ashes, the final entry in a series that takes place in Boston after the Civil War (USA - both Boston and the war). It looks pretty short and they have been easy reads. I need to get this couple united after all their trials and tribulations.
This topic has been frozen by the moderator. No new comments can be posted.
Books mentioned in this topic
Earthly Remains (other topics)A Rule Against Murder (other topics)
Earthly Remains (other topics)
Earthly Remains (other topics)
The Lake House (other topics)
More...
Authors mentioned in this topic
Kate Morton (other topics)E.F. Benson (other topics)
E.F. Benson (other topics)
Ed McBain (other topics)
Leslie Charteris (other topics)
More...