Reading the Detectives discussion
note: This topic has been closed to new comments.
Archived threads
>
What mysteries are you reading at the moment? Old thread
message 1551:
by
Jill
(new)
Jun 01, 2017 02:58AM

reply
|
flag

I really enjoyed The Golden Age of Murder but I don't think there was anything about Patricia Wentworth in it, as far as I remember.




oh, goody. I downloaded it on Kindle a couple of days ago, looking forward to it!!
currently reading "The Mad Tea Party" long story (or short novella, 45 pages small type) from ADVENTURES OF ELLERY QUEEN, 1934
and likely to finish up rereading Ngaio Marsh ARTISTS IN CRIME, 1937 this weekend.


Tagged for Death is on my TBR so would like to hear what you think of it.
I've started Dear Old Dead, the father's day entry in the Gregor K. series. Jane Haddam must have felt confined by her holiday theme as this book has little to do with the holiday.
Just finished The Incredible Crime
by a relative of Jane Austen. Very much a Golden Age mystery, but gets a bit lost, plot wise.



I have read several book in the Great Merlini series in which the detective is a magician and they were fun reads.

I am half through The Woman in Blue and loving it, for the personal relationships as well as the mystery. I had to read this fairly soon after the prior entry in the series as I am on the waiting list for the latest entry. Always feels good to be caught up. Then I get upset by having to wait.

Having read all of Christie, Sayer, Heyer, Wentworth, and some of Allingham, Marsh etc, I thought of myself as an expert on the Golden Age but am only now realising that I had only scratched the surface. Trent's Last Case (I know it's a group read at present so I am staying well away from that thread until I can find a copy), The Poisoned Chocolates Case, Malice Aforethought...
When it comes to short stories, I am less embarrassed as I read a few anthologies of detective stories when I was young which, I now discover, unsurprisingly selected the best ones. The Tea Leaf, for example, which I think is one of the most ingenious locked room mysteries I've come across. But I certainly have a lot of catching up to do on novels.

ohhh, yeah, Mis A, y'know, THAT way lies madness!!! (grin)
and if you'd like a, um, "deeper" (g) view, check out my Fems Project Shelves at My Books: https://www.goodreads.com/review/list...
my feeble attempt to (eventually...) read fem authors who I believe wrote in styles similar to Christie (she used many, many!) and were originally published around the same time as she was, and to also try and read them sequentially (sigggh). Started out only being for books/authors who wrote/pub'd 1920s, 1930s, but "somehow"... has grown exponentially.
YOU'VE BEEN WARNED...

but, as A is finding out, there's a TON of GA authors "out there"! that many, if not most of us haven't heard of! I'd also recommend btw, the current books by Sarah Weinman, not sure spelling, each reprints several great mysteries from 1940s, 1950s, of now-forgotten female authors who were, at the time, very famous and loved. She also writes extremely interesting and beautiful introductions, histories, etc, for these authors and suggests others.

Annabel wrote: "I mentioned earlier that I am reading The Golden Age of Murder, which is about the Golden Age writers and in particular those in the Detection Club. Just to say that this book is giving me such a l..."
I found just the same when I read this, Annabel - it gave me loads of names of authors to try. I've tried a few of them but still have many more to go. The Poisoned Chocolates Case is fun - I haven't read Malice Aforethought yet.
If you read on Kindle, Trent's Last Case is cheaper under the alternative title The Woman in Black (nothing to do with Susan Hill's book) at Amazon and there is also a free edition under that title at Gutenberg.
I found just the same when I read this, Annabel - it gave me loads of names of authors to try. I've tried a few of them but still have many more to go. The Poisoned Chocolates Case is fun - I haven't read Malice Aforethought yet.
If you read on Kindle, Trent's Last Case is cheaper under the alternative title The Woman in Black (nothing to do with Susan Hill's book) at Amazon and there is also a free edition under that title at Gutenberg.

I am reading The Secret of Chimneys, in my feeble attempt to read Christie in order. Lots of humor, a likable scamp for the male lead, a bright and interesting female lead, enjoyable!
I want to reread Daughter of Time someday. Just seems unlikely with so many first reads.
I want to reread Daughter of Time someday. Just seems unlikely with so many first reads.

btw (grin) my MOST-fave Christie heroine is Anne Beddingfield of MAN IN THE BROWN SUIT - and it's obvious that Elizabeth Peters had her in mind when she wrote the Amelia Peobody series, the similarities between several Christie novels and the earliest Amelia books are lots of fun to spot!


I love Chimneys too - Seven Dials a little less because it is a tad silly but both are great fun nonetheless and very Wodehousian.

that was VERY popular style at the time, mid-1920s, Christie was playing to what her publishers thought the audience wanted, and those light'n'fluffy mysteries were big big sellers!
Allingham did the same sort of thing, initially (1929) Albert Campion was exTREMEly Bertie Wooster-ish and slowly moved into sharp-tongued and sharper-witted detective as the series progressed; she continued to use "that sort of bloke" as his camoflage (can't spell it...) for a long time, but readers became more accepting of the intelligence rather than the physical presentation of the detective in the 1930s. So did Sayers with Lord Peter circa beginning ~1923, initially "a total ass" but over time showed more overt brains and less "flummery".


I can see the flaws in both those books now but I still love then for their irresistible liveliness.
Abbey, I love the Amelia Peabody series but never spotted similarities to Christie. I hope to re-do Amelia on audio someday (having discovered Barbara Rosenblatt's narration) and will pay more attention. Thank you for the excuse to re-visit one of my favorite families.
And, another author has taken up the series: The Painted Queen. I'm excited but apprehensive.
And, another author has taken up the series: The Painted Queen. I'm excited but apprehensive.
The Amelia Peabody series is another I started and never finished. I must go back to it as I recall enjoying it a lot.
I seem to be mainly reading non-mysteries at the moment but am about to start next month's Miss Marple, The Mirror Crack'd from Side to Side.
Re the 'Silly Ass' detectives, I remember being disappointed as a teenager that Albert Campion became less silly in the later books! I can understand it more now though... as Jill says, this type of character could wear thin after a while.

CROCODILE ON THE SANDBANK by Peabody, 1975 #1 Amelia, has tons of similarities to Christie's MAN IN THE BROWN SUIT, particularly the beginning, where we see Anne at home when and just after her anthropologist father dies - same family set-up, same Independent New Woman ethos for Anne and Amelia.
And CURSE OF THE PHAROHS (Amelia #2 or 3, not sure, its the one with Lady Baskerville) is a deliberate re-working of Christie's MURDER IN MESOPOTAMIA, with the archeological dig set-up AND most of the characters being similar, and Amelia as the Poirot detective, lovely!
and Barbara Rosenblatt's narrations are wonderful.

I haven't read the first Amelia Peabody yet but the ones I read made me think very much of the Mummy movies - though teh characters in the book were far "crazier" if anything. I wondered if they were an inspiration.

"
well, I *do* remember that in the early-to-mid-1990s there was a lot of talk about an Amelia Peabody movie being made, but they producers wouldn't come to terms with Elizabeth Peters. They essentially stole some of her material tho, because I definitely remember that just around that time there was a movie with maybe Stephanie Zimbalist? as a suspiciously Amelia-like archeologist! and then the two famous Mummy movies were 1999 and 2001 or so, and Evie *is* smart and brave and wild at times like Amelia, but the plots are quite different, plus they're set in mid-1920s and early 1930s; the Amelia stories ran from ~1885 thru the early 1920s.
and another connection to an earlier topic: around 1980 Stephanie Zimbalist played Anne Beddingfield in a wonderful production of MAN IN THE BROWN SUIT, lots of fun, plus it had Rue McClanahan as Mrs van Zant the worldly-wise wealthy widow who befriends Anne.

The plots are very different of course but the characters felt to me similar - in their temperament and actions.
I didn't know about the series. And I ahven't seen that adaptation of Brown Suit either. Stephanie Zimbalist was the one in Remington Steele, right?


THE GIRL I USED TO BE, April Henry, reviews etc are great, sort-of YA (ykwim) but she's a good strong plotter usually, so have high hopes, the premise sounds wonderful: 3-yo's Mum killed in front of her, and Dad vanishes, he believed to have done it, she sent to Foster Care but 14 yrs later HIS body turns up close to where the Mother's body found and it's obvious that he was killed the same time and same way too. The now-17yo girl wants answers, goes home for the Dad's funeral and realizes nobody recognizes her sooo... a bit soapy, but might be fun, it's my weekend treat!
also received:
ISLAND OF TEARS, Troy Soos, NYC immigrants, and those who use and abuse them circa 1890s as a reporter searches for a missing woman. First in series, I *loved* his baseball historical mysteries from a decade or two ago!
DEATH IN THE OFF-SEASON, Francine Matthews, #1 Merry Folger, Nantucket, my summerish treat, if I can't GET to the islands physically, then...! and will probably also reread Phoebe Atwood Taylor's "Asey Mayo, Cape Cod" series this summer too, yum! She's one of my all-time faves, another of those "forgotten Fems" authors from between-the-wars that I so love!
I've just started The Quiet Girl by Peter Høeg which so far seems extremely well-written but confusing! I remember being both hooked and infuriated by Miss Smilla's Feeling for Snow by the same author years ago... this one could have the same effect.
I'm giving up on The Quiet Girl - it jumps around too much for me to understand what is going on.

I finished this book. No, no, no!!! Won't be reading any more in that series.
If anyone is interested here is my short review.
https://www.goodreads.com/review/show...


It was really good. I will be reading the second in the series as soon as I finish two of my current reads.
I've just started reading Italian noir novella Almost Blue by Carlo Lucarelli, set in Bologna. It's a compelling start - partly narrated by a blind witness who hears colours in people's voices.


Thanks, I'm completely overloaded at work at the moment, but will get to this one soon.

Hag's Nook is one I keep meaning to read, but it isn't on kindle and I am really trying not to buy any more books, so it goes on the back burner again, Jan.


Why has Hag's Nook been on my shelf for so long? I put it down at 3 AM and seriously considered continuing to read.

I'm glad that I am not the only one who often buys books that I already have!!!! Happy reading, Jan C.
This topic has been frozen by the moderator. No new comments can be posted.
Books mentioned in this topic
Earthly Remains (other topics)A Rule Against Murder (other topics)
Earthly Remains (other topics)
Earthly Remains (other topics)
The Lake House (other topics)
More...
Authors mentioned in this topic
Kate Morton (other topics)E.F. Benson (other topics)
E.F. Benson (other topics)
Ed McBain (other topics)
Leslie Charteris (other topics)
More...