Reading the Detectives discussion
note: This topic has been closed to new comments.
Archived threads
>
What mysteries are you reading at the moment? Old thread
message 751:
by
Judy
(new)
Oct 01, 2016 03:04PM

reply
|
flag

Is the Murder on the Enriqueta her last book? I think her later books, especially the last one, were questionable. Either that or mymmemory of what I read about it was questionable.
I'm reading a few mysteries at the moment: The Devil's Feast (third in a good historical mystery series), The Two O'Clock Boy and The Big Book of Jack the Ripper
Jan C wrote: "I'm reading the biographical section of The Draycott Murder Mystery: A Golden Age Mystery.
Is the Murder on the Enriqueta her last book?"
Just checked and it was her second mystery , published in 1929, the year after The Draycott Murder Mystery. I'll be interested to hear what you think of that one.
Is the Murder on the Enriqueta her last book?"
Just checked and it was her second mystery , published in 1929, the year after The Draycott Murder Mystery. I'll be interested to hear what you think of that one.


I enjoy Connelly. Have seen him at readings several times.



I have been trying to work out which Scottish County one of the books might cover, but haven't had any luck, so for the moment only one county is crossed off my list.
I am enjoying them - nice light reading. I don't remember much of the TV series I think I only saw perhaps one episode and wasn't bothered enough to watch more. They were apparently quite different from the books.
I also read the first few mysteries and then stopped, Jay-me. Another series I would like to find the time to go back to. I think I preferred that to the Agatha Raisin mysteries, although I quite liked both.


I'm reading The Far Pavilions at the moment but I also have a copy of Death in Zanzibar Paperback publishers have not served this author well - both are falling apart!
I am currently reading a read for review copy of A Useful Woman I normally don't like non Heyer Regencies, but this is a mystery and the author has her own voice, so I'm enjoying so far.

I liked the MM Kaye mysteries too. My favorite was Death in Kenya
This reminds me that I got one of hers as an audio book a while ago, but I'm hopeless at listening to audio books... I would like to try her soon, though.
I'm just reading the second Alleyn mystery by Ngaio Marsh, Enter a Murderer.
I'm halfway through and enjoying it, but Alleyn keeps saying he has a "filthy memory", which is a bit annoying, since it's blatantly untrue! He seems to have a lot more mannerisms and banter in this book than I'd remembered - I think he becomes a bit more serious later in the series.
Also his better-known sidekick, Inspector Fox, features in this one alongside journalist Nigel Bathgate.
I'm halfway through and enjoying it, but Alleyn keeps saying he has a "filthy memory", which is a bit annoying, since it's blatantly untrue! He seems to have a lot more mannerisms and banter in this book than I'd remembered - I think he becomes a bit more serious later in the series.
Also his better-known sidekick, Inspector Fox, features in this one alongside journalist Nigel Bathgate.

I'm halfway through and enjoying it, but Alleyn keeps saying he has a "filthy memory", wh..."
I enjoyed this one, too.

I've started Far Pavilions, not sure how far in I am. I am guessing at not very.

Jan I'm in Part 6, but if you want a buddy to read with, I am using this group.
https://www.goodreads.com/group/show/... :)

Jan I'm in Part 6, but if you want a buddy to read with, I am using this group.
https://www.goodrea..."
Thanks. I think it is kind of an a back burner right now. I was going to say because I don't know where it is when I found it.

It's on a slight back burner for me just because I had 2 group reads for the start of the month.But I'll be back to it in a few days.
For those of us in the UK, there is a new series about books - beginning with, "Sleuth, Spies and Sorcerer's." http://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/p040pvpp
It starts on 17th October at 9pm on BBC4 - Andrew Marr's Paperback Heroes.
It starts on 17th October at 9pm on BBC4 - Andrew Marr's Paperback Heroes.
Currently reading two good contemporary mysteries - Lovemurder and The Book of Mirrors. The Book of Mirrors is an academic mystery and I know a few of us like those.
The Book of Mirrors is currently on NetGalley, Jan. I know quite a few of us are NetGalley users - I must admit that I get most of my books from them now.
I just finished Lovemurder (2nd Valerie Hart), which was a very good, fast paced crime novel. Just started Blood Lines (5th Kim Stone) and am halfway through Gaudy Night, which I have never read before.




Right now I'm reading Agatha Christie's Witness For the Prosecution and Other Stories which are obviously a collection of short stories. This will be my first time plowing through this collection though I am familiar with the first story 'Witness For The Prosecution' which I definitely recommend -- it's a story you will never forget!


Speaking of "Austenesque" have you read P.D. James Death Comes To Pemberley? She uses some of the characters from Jane Austin's Pride & Prejudice and incorporate them into a murder mystery.


Like Abigail I've also just read A Useful Woman. I thought it sagged a bit in the middle & had a few anachronisms, but still enjoyed it enough to give it 4★
Brian I own Death Comes to Pemberley but an unlikely to read before next year. I still haven't read The Murder Room by PD James which is supposed to be a far better book.


Welcome, Brian! I don't remember the book Death Comes to Pemberley very well now, although I think I possibly liked it a bit more than Abigail and Michelle did... looks as if it is one I forgot to rate on GR! But I do remember enjoying the TV adaptation, which had a great cast.
I liked Death Comes to Pemberley. I am willing to forgive P D James almost anything though, just because I adore her books so much...

Regarding Death Comes to Pemberley, I agree with Abigail. But I am not in general very tolerant of "fanfiction" -- I have liked a few but mostly I feel that authors should create their own characters rather than 'borrowing' someone else's.
I think P D James had always wanted to write Pemberley - but knew the reaction it would get. Having reached a good age, she was probably just at the point where she thought that if she didn't write it then, she never would. I do agree though, that the current trend for resurrecting another author's work is fraught with problems - at best - and really best avoided.

But it can also be approached as (a) a way of revisiting important themes in a modern context, (b) an homage to a master, or (c) a re-envisioning of a classic story or myth—among other possibilities. Was James Joyce borrowing or resurrecting The Odyssey by writing Ulysses? (Or take a look at The Decameron, or many other works of literature from the past that are based on Greek and Roman lit.) I’m currently reading Jeanette Winterson’s book The Gap of Time, which she describes as “a cover version of William Shakespeare’s The Winter’s Tale.” Such authors are writing novels of literary ambition that are dialogues with classic works of the past, that explore their meaning and reinterpret that meaning for their own era’s readers. There exist writers of such ambition even in Jane Austen fan fiction. (Not many, I admit; but it’s too sweeping to dismiss the entire genre.)

Abigail, I agree that fan fiction and sequels by other authors do vary hugely in quality. I must say I'm quite often tempted to try them, and am often disappointed but sometimes excited, and the best ones can shed light on the originals and send me back to them yet again.
I also think it's understandable that publishers are keen to bring out sequels/prequels etc as there is a guaranteed market for them, but it's a shame if authors find it hard to get a deal to publish books with their own original characters too.
I also think it's understandable that publishers are keen to bring out sequels/prequels etc as there is a guaranteed market for them, but it's a shame if authors find it hard to get a deal to publish books with their own original characters too.


My favorite of Dorothy Gilman's non-Mrs. Pollifax books -- I have read and reread it. Glad to hear that despite some dated elements it continues to charm some new readers :)

Michelle, I ordered Magpie Murders from the library the other day after peeking in it in a bookshop - it looks really good.
I loved Magpie Murders, it was a really unusual read. I am currently reading The Owl Always Hunts At Night and Murder at the Brightwell and just finished Gaudy Night, which I read for the first time.


This topic has been frozen by the moderator. No new comments can be posted.
Books mentioned in this topic
Earthly Remains (other topics)A Rule Against Murder (other topics)
Earthly Remains (other topics)
Earthly Remains (other topics)
The Lake House (other topics)
More...
Authors mentioned in this topic
Kate Morton (other topics)E.F. Benson (other topics)
E.F. Benson (other topics)
Ed McBain (other topics)
Leslie Charteris (other topics)
More...