Mockingjay
discussion
Our own fantasy ending for Mockingjay/What we liked and disliked about the book.
message 1:
by
Ali
(new)
-
rated it 4 stars
Nov 05, 2015 08:31AM
I HATED THE ENDING OF MOCKINGJAY!!!! So here we can write our own dream ending to Mockingjay if you are like me and disliked it!
reply
|
flag
Also you can write what you liked and disliked about the book!
Aaron wrote: "Everybody dies"what do you mean everybody dies????
So first here is my rant on the ending. Finnick and Prim just dies for the sake of death. I loved those characters and I think they should of had happy endings. Peeta and Katniss should not have ended up together. Gale would have never left Katniss and go to District 2. Katniss didn't even end up choosing anyone, she was just left with Peeta so that's who she married. Peeta was always just the guy she came to love, but as a really good friend. Katniss and Gale were always supposed to end up together, she even said it in one of the other books. Katniss would have not voted for another Hunger Games because she knew how terrible those were and the Capital kids never did anything. The ending was way too rushed and it made no sense!!!
I think Gale should've stayed in district 12. I was really mad when he left
Ali wrote: "So first here is my rant on the ending. Finnick and Prim just dies for the sake of death. I loved those characters and I think they should of had happy endings. DONT SAY WHAT HAPPENED AT THE END OF THE BOOK BECAUSE I DID NOT GET TO READ IT YET OR SSEE THE MOVIE
Christa wrote: "I think Gale should've stayed in district 12. I was really mad when he left"WHAT DO YOU MEAN GALE IS NOT IN DISTRICT 12 ANYMORE FROM THE OTHER TWO MOVIES I SAW I THOUGHT HE DIE IN ONE OF THE MOVIE
Ali wrote: "I HATED THE ENDING OF MOCKINGJAY!!!! So here we can write our own dream ending to Mockingjay if you are like me and disliked it!"WHAT IS SO BAD ABOUT THE ENDING OF THE MOVIE
Have you guys watched the movie? The mockingjay part 2 P.S. I haven't, so I am clueless here. Is the movie has the same ending as in book? Anyone
I haven't seen the latest movie yet, but with regards to the book, I was confused about the ending. As Ali said, the thigns that happened kind of go against everything Katniss stands for and everything we had come to expect based on how the rest of the series was written.Of course, that could be the point. There was so much of the ending that went totally against what I expected or wanted to happen that I wonder if the decision to end it like that was part of the story's themes. It's almost as if to say war doesn't have a happy ending, even if you win. Even the closest people change and are scarred forever. People who deserve to live, die. Decisions that people would have abhorred before the war and death and horrible experiences are now considered acceptable. When I look at this from an analytical perspective, this message sticks out really clearly. It's meant to be jarring and shocking and leave the reader with a bad after-taste, so to speak.
That's my idea anyway. It's the only way I can think of to explain why the ending chapters are so different and unexpected than the rest of the story.
I've seen other threads that analyze certain words and gestures on Katniss' part, and take that to mean something else, but I'm not inclined to believe that because you have to think really deeply to get there--deeper than your regular casual reader does, and that's who the main audience is. Feel free to disagree with me; I'd like to know other thoughts on this or if people feel the same way.
woah, thank you Christie. I finished mockingjay months ago and yeah the ending seem like it was following the movie 's flow. Let's just wait movie's released.
Btw this discussion is only on the ending of the book. The movie part 2 isn't in the theaters yet.
I totally agree with you Christie. The ending of the book was rushed and changed the book for me. Also, don't come to this discussion if you haven't read the ending yet. Sorry about the spoilers but this chat was about the ending...
Samanthaschuttenberg wrote: "Ali wrote: "So first here is my rant on the ending. Finnick and Prim just dies for the sake of death. I loved those characters and I think they should of had happy endings. DONT SAY WHAT HAPPENED..."
WHY ARE YOU HERE IF YOU HAVE"NT FINISHED YET??
IT'S LITERALLY ABOUT THE ENDING OF THE BOOK!!
I think that some of the deaths in the book happen for a reason and that it helped deepen the meaning of the story and the message that no matter what life moves on. Does anyone else agree or disagree?
Well it is true...Almost all the major/important characters died, Peeta, Gale, and Katniss were obviously the main characters and you don't kill your main character, but everybody else died, she just wanted a dramatic ending and everybody was waiting for the last book to come out, so she decided to rush and let everybody die, except a few characters who have "happy" endings and literally live on with their lives happily every after with no post-traumatic stress disorder and not even upset that everybody else they care about died.
itsmenokey wrote: "Have you guys watched the movie? The mockingjay part 2 P.S. I haven't, so I am clueless here. Is the movie has the same ending as in book? Anyone"
I have not watched mockingjay part 1 or part 2 part 2 vomes out 20th of november
I think that Peeta or Gale should have died (preferably Peeta) and Katniss should've ended up with either Gale or neither of them.
The book was the worst of the series, it was awful, catching fire was the best
WHAT NO GALE SHOULD'VE DIED
No, neither of them die, and everybody lives happily ever after with a statue of president snow with an arrow in his heart.THE END
It was definitely the worst in the series. I actually might say that the Hunger Games was the best since it started everything else. Catching Fire had a slow start but the Quarter Quell is extremely exciting.
I wouldn't have wanted Gale to die but I think one of them needed to make the ending more realistic.
Peeta ruined the whole book
NO SNOW RUINED THE BOOK,HE KILLED EVERYBODY
Gale should have ended up with Katniss. Peeta completely ruined that. HE SHOULD HAVE BEEN DEAD!
Gale ruined it because he blows up Prim, then leaves Katniss alone in district twelve with no one except for Peeta
And why was Gale acting so mean in Mockingjay? His character completely changed!
GALE SHOULD HAVE DIED
Yes but that was so not Gale. He would never do that.
He became a mean person because he was jealous of Katniss and Peeta's relationship and he was so obsessed with winning the war that he only thought about himself
No that was so not Gale
It was him because he changed and that became who he was
Maybe this new Gale should have died but old Gale should have been with Katniss.
I agree but even if old Gale stayed I think Peeta should have still ended up with Katniss
How about this:Katniss and Gale get together, Peeta and still-alive Prim get together. Katniss' still-alive family live together, Finnick lives happily ever after alone the way he wants to, still-alive nuts and bolts live together, and President Snow dead.
But Peeta wasn't meant for Katniss!!!!!
Finnick was married to Annie!!!
And Peeta and Prim would have been so good together!
Oh right, Finnick and Annie.
I know I'm a freakin genius
*In Batman voice*YES I AM
ew peeta and prim?
all discussions on this book
|
post a new topic
