The 2015 Book Genre Challenge discussion
Suggestions
>
October Suggestions - Fairy-Tale Retelling
date
newest »

message 1:
by
Silvia, (grangerandherbooks)
(new)
Sep 29, 2015 08:38PM

reply
|
flag



Other than that? I may try Cinder by Marissa Meyer.
As for recs, only one I can actually think of is The Sleeper and the Spindle which I really enjoyed and with Chris Riddell's illustrations is one of the most gorgeous books I own


I love this genre! I'll recommend

I read just the first story but it is beautifully written, it really makes you feel, this woman was amazing with words. They have a feminist touch, these retellings, and it's so refreshing because women are so often maligned in fairy tales. Here's a quote of the story that has stayed with me through the years, because it's so powerful:
"You disobeyed him," he said. "That is sufficient reason for him to punish you."
"I only did what he knew I would."
"Like Eve," he said.
Have a good one :)

I love this genre! I'll recommend

I read ..."
You had me at feminist fairy-tale retellings! With that description, I'm definitely adding The Bloody Chamber to my TBR! Thanks Pau!


(On a sidenote, how awesome is it that this coincided with the return of OUAT?)

I just finished A Discovery of Witches, and am trying to decide if I wan to continue with that trilogy as well :)

I just finished A Discovery of Witches, ..."
Hey I just got A Discovery of Witches! What did you think of it???

I've heard good things about Cruel Beauty and Crimson Bound.
I can't wait to see which book we pick ^__^


@Renuka I was very underwhelmed by Sisters Red tbh, I liked the premise (& the cover) more than the execution.

I just finished A Discov..."
I just finished it this afternoon, so that usually has an impact on how I feel about a book :)
I would say it's a solid three. Slow to start, needs a much more aggressive editor for sure, and I don't like the 'insta-love' story line at all. I'm more of a slow burn person myself. And the more I think about it the more I don't like Diana. However, I do like Mathew and several supporting characters. I like the world that Harkness has build, and I actually do want to know what happens next (it's a trilogy). So for me it's definitely a three, maybe 3.5. I read it for my irl book club.

Cinder is pretty bad. I mean, it's fun to read and all but has no depth or nuance. To me it was so badly written I couldn't consider reading the sequel. That's just my opinion, of course if that's what most people want to read then awesome.
The opposite, I think, can be said for Wicked. I loved it, it' s one of my favorite books, but consider, it is a very heavy book. It is big and complicated and sometimes painfully slow. I really like this book, but be forewarned, it is not light reading in any way.
The Sleeper and the Spindle is just pure beauty. More of a graphic novel, though.
That's it :) Your suggestions are exciting. Keep suggesting! I might read more than one :)
Good night.

Cinder is pretty bad. I mean, it's fun to read and all but has no depth or nuance. To me it was so badly written I couldn't consider reading the sequel. ..."
I've read so many bad reviews on Wicked, now it all makes sense: if it's slow and complicated, people tend not to like it. But if you like it, I probably will too. I own it, so I'll definitely give it a shot.



I've read Dorothy must must die. Met was a solid three (out of five) for me. She didn't do a lot of world building or fleshing out of characters from Oz, but one could argue it's not necessary. I liked Dorothy's struggles, and who can resist a flying monkey? Overall it was a good read.

I've read Dorothy must must die. Met was a solid three (out of five) for me. She didn't do a lot of world building or fleshing out of characters from Oz, but one could argue it's not necessary. I liked Dorothy's struggles, and who can resist a flying monkey? Overall it was a good read.

Some suggestions that I've loved:
- Beauty by Robin McKinley
- Deerskin by Robin McKinley
- The Bloody Chamber and Other Stories by Angela Carter
- Some of Neil Gaiman's short stories- The Sleeper and the Spindle was suggested but also Snow, Glass, Apples is amazing
- Deathless by Catherynne Valente, obviously.
- Ella Enchanted is an oldie but still great.
I'm looking forward to reading The Girls at the Kingfisher Club.

Also have you voted already for our group book of the month??

Oh no! Didn't you get the message? Damn now I'm worried it didn't get sent :( here it is: https://www.goodreads.com/poll/show/1...

I'll probably read Cress next, I held it back so I could read it this month. But also thinking about reading Hild and a thousand nights!

I'll probably read Cress next, I held it back so I could read it this month. But also thinking about reading Hild and a thousand nights!


Books mentioned in this topic
The Girls at the Kingfisher Club (other topics)Beauty (other topics)
The Bloody Chamber and Other Stories (other topics)
The Sleeper and the Spindle (other topics)
Deerskin (other topics)
More...
Authors mentioned in this topic
Angela Carter (other topics)Angela Carter (other topics)
Kate Forsyth (other topics)