The Old Man and the Sea
question
What is the symbol of the big fish that the old man caught?

I think the big fish symbolizes old man himself. Old man is having a fight with himself. He steers himself to the extreme, and endures the pain.
reply
flag
Santiago's decision to venture far out to sea to where he believes big Marlins are tells us two things about him: first of his determination to stave off ridicule over not having caught a fish for nearly 3 months, and second, that he understands that striving for success inherently carries risk.
The Marlin he catches, though a symbol of his hubris or excessive pride, not only helps him understand himself, it also earns him the respect of his village, despite having lost most of the fish to the shark. Nevertheless, in doing so, he accepted the risk and overcame fear. I suppose one could argue that metaphorically, the fish represents life's challenges, reminding the Old Man and the reader that outcomes are fraught with trepidation and uncertainty, but our hubris causes us to forge ahead.
The Marlin he catches, though a symbol of his hubris or excessive pride, not only helps him understand himself, it also earns him the respect of his village, despite having lost most of the fish to the shark. Nevertheless, in doing so, he accepted the risk and overcame fear. I suppose one could argue that metaphorically, the fish represents life's challenges, reminding the Old Man and the reader that outcomes are fraught with trepidation and uncertainty, but our hubris causes us to forge ahead.
View 1 comment
I'm not an expert, but I believe that one popular interpretation from scholars is the fish represents Hemingway's work and the sharks represent critics. In other words, an allegory for Hemingway's literary career.
James North
There's a review of the book which I just found in the NYT by Orville Presott in 1952. You may wish to read it.
...more
· flag
· flag
all discussions on this book
|
post a new topic