Boxall's 1001 Books You Must Read Before You Die discussion
note: This topic has been closed to new comments.
Archives
>
Which LIST book did you just start?
message 3351:
by
Stacie
(new)
Jan 02, 2011 05:34PM

reply
|
flag

I think this is a wonderful book. I hope you enjoy it.

what did you think of Oscar and Lucinda?
i loved Blind Assassin.

what did you think of Oscar and Lucinda?
I felt like I should have been more enthralled by Oscar and Lucinda than I actually was. It was a well written story with a good twist at the end but it's not up there in the top 20 for me. Nearly finished the blind assassin and have loved every minute!
i loved Blind Assassin."

I think this is a wonderful book. I hope you enjoy it."
I thought this was great too. Am not sure about going to see the film version though.

3rd in the Regeneration Trilogy about WWI soldiers and the English pacifists of the period.


I read it for the first time years ago and was not especially impressed. So this time I'm listening to the unabridged audio version.
I'm also watching the movies (I've found obtained three) The 1939 version with Merle Oberon & Laurence Olivier, the 1992 version with Juliette Binoche & Ralph Fiennes and the 1970 version with Anna Calder-Marshall and Timothy Dalton.
So far I've viewed the 1970 film version and was disappointed in that. They changed the story a lot. Heathcliff is shot & killed? They did make one interesting change that may be the key to the story for me. They suggested that Heathcliff may have been illegitimate son of Earnshaw Senior.
That made several aspects of the original novel more understandable to me. And it's just the kind of thing Ms. Bronte may have wanted to write but feared would not be accepted at the time. The father's reason for bringing the child home. His seeming preference for Heathcliff over Hindley. Also, Hindley's initial antipathy was better motivated this way. The similarities in temperment between Catherine and Heathcliff could also be better explained. They were both their father's kids while Hindley may have favored the mother.
This speculation also made the relationship between Heathcliff and Cathy even more doomed.
I'm wondering if anyone else inferred that from the writing and I just missed it.

I loved this book - one of my top 20 on the 1001 list so far. Hope you're enjoying it too

I am the same way. I just don't know how it will translate to the screen - or if I will like the translation.



I read it for the fir..."
I read this about 3 months ago and something in the book did make me think that Heathcliff was his illegitimate son.
Also, around the time the father was dying he said about Hinley, "I doubt thy mother and I must rue that we ever reared thee!" Made me think that he doubted whether he was Hinley's father.


Looks like there are several of us who are reading this right now. Will be interested to see what we all think!

Interest of what you think of "Nervous Conditions". Let us know, please.

Romance of the Three Kingdoms, Vol 1 -Lo Kuan-chung
Tirant Lo Blanc -Joanot Martorell
The Life and Opinions of Tristram Shandy -Laurence Sterne
I just started Gone With the Wind. I'm only one chapter 2 but so far so good. I love her descriptive writing style.



Interest of what you think of "Nervous..."
Liking it so far, but haven't gotten too far into it. Kid home sick which inhibits reading some. As does cooking.

it's ASTONISHING--some of the best prose I've ever read--literally stayed up all night reading-it's 5AM and this is the first time I've put it down since I started.



No, I haven't. You mean comments here on Goodreads?

Just post your review, Shay. We are all a little insane...

I read The Handmaid's Tale for the first time a year ago. I thought about it for weeks after I finished it. It's a fantastic book and I plan on re-reading it this year.

No, I haven't. You mean comments here on Goodreads?"
Not on this group and thread, but on the GR page for the book:
http://www.goodreads.com/book/show/51...
If someone posts a negative review of this book, here are some of the comments:
Don't hate what you don't understand.
dense review. Obviously Holden is hypocritical. That's the whole point.
Obviously got an F. Never open with a quote. Learn how to write
I've noticed that many people--men or women--who "hate" Catcher have had a narrow band of life experience.
I will start The Picture of Dorian Gray tonight.


I'm a little late in posting, but I'm 367 pages into Infinite Jest by David Foster Wallace. I love it so far.

Tom Sawyer didn't make the list, but Huck Finn did, if you're interested.
I really loved Northanger Abbey...one of my favorites on the list, actually.
This topic has been frozen by the moderator. No new comments can be posted.
Books mentioned in this topic
City of Bones (other topics)Bouvard and Pécuchet (other topics)
Lolita (other topics)
O Homem Sem Qualidades (other topics)
Jonathan Strange & Mr Norrell (other topics)
More...
Authors mentioned in this topic
Barack Obama (other topics)Mario Vargas Llosa (other topics)
Iain Banks (other topics)
Chinua Achebe (other topics)
V.S. Naipaul (other topics)
More...