European Royalty discussion
European Royalty Discussions
>
What have you read lately?
message 351:
by
Nona
(new)
Mar 22, 2009 11:47AM

reply
|
flag



I am just finishing Daphne Du Maurier's Mary Anne which is based on her great-great-grandmother who had quite a scandalous affair with Frederick Duke of York. Quite an interesting ride.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Frederic...




[b:I, Elizabeth A Novel|56353|I, Elizabeth A Novel|Rosalind Miles|http://photo.goodreads.com/books/1170......"
I have I, Elizabeth and I absolutely love it. Thick as it is I've read it several times. I love the voice of Elizabeth that Miles creates.

I have read it and while I loved Weir's book on Jane Grey, I wasn't quite as thrilled with this one. It was good and I enjoyed it, just not as much as I enjoyed "Innocent Traitor." The direction she goes with some of the things in Elizabeth's life (though there were all kinds of rumors) just don't seem to fit with history.

Oh yes, a really interesting take on it - and very well-written

It's pretty good...though it took me a long time to become really engaged in it.
I'm glad it was condensed into one novel, because the whole first book was sort of slow for me.
I don't love Plaidy's take on some events that I've read about in other books by other authors before. I wonder, though, if that's specific to this book and Katherine's story...
I think I'm almost overly-familiar with Katherine's life - I keep waiting for different things to happen. That may be why I find the book slow.
I think I'm going to read Sunne in Splendor next.


It's pretty good...though it took me a long time to become really engaged in it.
I'm glad it was condensed into one novel, because the whole fir..."
I'm the same way, sometimes you know too much about some of these historical figures and it ruins the fiction. I think it's unfortunate when the authors can't be bothered to even consult a timeline sometimes! That's why I had to stop watching the Tudors. Even though I love Jonathan Rhys-Meyers, the ridiculous plots and costumes were really getting to me.

This is the one we read as a group (as well as The Innocent Traitor). Susanna's reading the non-fiction book about Elizabeth by Weir whereas we read the novel about Elizabeth by Weir (who's on first, who's on second!?!?).
I preferred the Innocent Traitor. I did not like a twist that Weir put in the Lady Elizabeth, but I don't think that bothered too many other people. I still enjoyed it though for the most part.


I'm getting it from the library but I'm not holding my breath that I'll finish it, just wanted to try her books once to see.
PS, Patricia we have a Richard III group. Come on over and join us.

No need to heckle. Her novels are thoroughly Ricardian.

Hmmm, then was the blurb about her book at fault, saying that it was about Richard's imprisonment of the Princes? Perhaps I should go and check this out... has anyone else met her?


I thought it was a good book but I really didn't like the way she portrayed Elizabeth as being a clingy female that can't make any decisions on her own. History shows that she wasn't like that. But I enjoyed the book nonetheless.

It is about the mystery of the Princes, but it's mainly about the identity of Perkin Warbeck. The novel opens shortly before the Battle of Bosworth, and Richard appears only briefly. He's a major character in Smith's first novel, A Rose for the Crown, which is about Richard III's mistress. I didn't care for A Rose for the Crown much (the heroine was way too perfect for my taste), but if a sympathetic Richard is your main criteria, it'll meet it. Some of the characters in Rose reappear in King's Grace. Smith is a member of the Richard III Society.



I really enjoyed Abundance also. The opening bits, especially the scene where Marie talks about her body, were a little off-putting to me--they had a "Gee, Ma, I'm writing literary fiction!" tone to them--but once the story started rolling, I was hooked.

I really enjoyed Abundance. I didnt' expect to, but I did. (I'm not a Marie Antoinette fan.) I thought Nasland handled the historical background very well...but then, she's a fantastic writer.




"
Hi~ I read Ahab's Wife about 8 years ago and, although I can't recall specific details, I can tell you it was one of my favorite books of any genre! For me, it began a quest to find other books on the adventures of the whaling industry and the women involved and is one of the (very)few books that I would read a second time!
Enjoy! :)


Only a few chapters into it, but it's good so far - though it seems to be quite fictional.



I think you're right, the book is quite fictional. There is (from what I found) limited hard evidence out there about Bathory - so difficult to parse the truth from legend. Any book about her is bound to include a fair amount of fiction, mine included!
I hope you enjoy Codrescu,
Alisa

Robin, I'm so glad that you enjoyed Katherine of Aragon. I also love that book!

Hi, Sera. I also have Anne Easter Smith's books waiting for me -- will you share your thoughts once you have finished your reading of The King's Grace? Thanks.

Wanda, I'm reading it right now and so far I am really enjoying it. After reading so much on the Tudors post Henry VII's time, its refreshing to read about what happened before Henry VIII's soap opera. :)

Thank you, Robin. I am anxious to start Anne Easter Smith's books - are they all stand-alones or must they be read in order to make sense?

..."
If you haven't already, do read Norah Lofts Katherine of Aragon book, Queen In Waiting. I think it is the best, but then I do have a girly crush on NL ....

I think you can probably read them on their own, though the two that come before "The King's Grace" obviously cover events that happen prior to this book.
I enjoyed "The King's Grace." As there really is not much about Grace in historical record, I suppose it was pretty easy for the author to fit her in to different parts of the known history. I liked the character okay most of the time. Her extreme stubbornness when it came to her feelings for her cousin John of Gloucester and trying to help him, and then her wanting to believe Perkin Warbeck (even though she'd never seen her half brother Richard), got a bit irritating, but I enjoyed the book and I've got the book that came before it, "Daughter of York" to read.

Books mentioned in this topic
The Book of Royal Useless Information: A Funny and Irreverent Look at the British Royal Family Past and Present (other topics)Katherine (other topics)
Queen of the North (other topics)
Victoria and her daughters (other topics)
The Heir Apparent: A Life of Edward VII, the Playboy Prince (other topics)
More...
Authors mentioned in this topic
Noel Botham, Bruce Montague (other topics)Alison Weir (other topics)
Alison Weir (other topics)
Alison Weir (other topics)
Jean Plaidy (other topics)
More...