The Filipino Group discussion

What We Talk About When We Talk About Love
note: This topic has been closed to new comments.
144 views
Archives > [F2F Book Discussions] February 2014: What We Talk About When We Talk About Love: Stories by Raymond Carver [Genre: Short Stories] | Moderator: Monique

Comments Showing 151-200 of 316 (316 new)    post a comment »

message 151: by Gwaxa (new) - rated it 3 stars

Gwaxa | 350 comments Tina: Benta ng M.U. mo. LOL talaga.

Monique: Yung discussion ng book I'm sure will be interesting. Ang iniisip ko eh yung mga tangent discussions. Alam naman naten na sa TFG, point A leads to point B, C, D, E, and so on and so forth. Lol.

Meliza: Yes na yes. Di pa ko nakatulog agad so pinanuod ko. ;)

Aaron: The pseudo-romanticism, of course. Mga gano ba kaminsan yan? Also, I didn't have doubts on your status as a pop culture slut. :p

Maria, Lynai: KAYO NA! :p

Cary: Auto friend zone? Paki explain. :)


message 152: by Cary (new)

Cary (forestercary) | 1370 comments GWAXA: panoorin mo yung tales from the friendzone ni ramon bautista para malaman mo. :D


message 153: by Meliza (new) - rated it 4 stars

Meliza (mecawish) | 720 comments Cary: Ako din, hindi ko rin alam 'yang auto friend zone.


message 154: by Cary (last edited Jan 24, 2014 12:27AM) (new)

Cary (forestercary) | 1370 comments Eto, panoorin nyo. haha! https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OvbSX...

panoorin nyo din yung ibang episodes.


message 155: by Meliza (new) - rated it 4 stars

Meliza (mecawish) | 720 comments Cary: Episode 3 lang papanoodin namin?


Monique (attymonique) | 2130 comments GWAXA: Tama ka, tulad ngayon, Point A has led to B, C, at eto na nga, Point Z na. LOL. :))

--------------------------------------

Will post the Reading Plan over the weekend so check back here for that. (view spoiler)

Happy weekend, friends, lovers, and friend-zoned friends! :P


message 157: by Tina (new) - rated it 5 stars

Tina (tinamats) | 2665 comments Cary: ay natawa ako sa feature na yan. At alam ko yang episode na yan! XD (view spoiler)

Meliza: watch everything na para masaya. :p

Cousin: natawa ako sa closing ng post mo. :))

Happy weekend, everyone. :D


message 158: by Maria Ella (last edited Jan 24, 2014 03:26AM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Maria Ella (mariaellabetos) | 1353 comments Ako honestly, takot ma-friendzone. Kesa gawin mo ang pre-emptive supalpal - isupalpal mo na lang. mas apparent, mas okay. LOL

Happy weekend~ :)


message 159: by Tricia (last edited Jan 24, 2014 04:27PM) (new) - rated it 4 stars

Tricia (triciuhhh) | 1752 comments Hindi din ako makarelate sa friendzoned thing. (view spoiler)

Ella, mahirap kasi masupalpal. Unahan mo na lang siya hahaha (view spoiler)

K. Move on. There are so many fishes in the sea~

Happy weekends, guys!


message 160: by Patrick (new)

Patrick (aboyandhisbooks) | 8 comments What is your love language?
(view spoiler)

Finish the sentence: When I hear the word "love," I think about - (view spoiler)


message 161: by Cary (new)

Cary (forestercary) | 1370 comments Naks patrick! (view spoiler) but seriously, sabi nga ni pareng monra, there's more to life than love (in a romantic sense). I think pare-parehas naman tayo ng definition and understanding ng love eh. Iba-iba nga lang ng object. :)


message 162: by Tina (new) - rated it 5 stars

Tina (tinamats) | 2665 comments Patrick: are you sure you weren't in the workshop I attended last night? Parang yan din yung sinabi kagabi ;)

Cary: I figure: God = love. God = way bigger than our comprehension. Ergo, love really is just too big for us to really comprehend it all. :)


message 163: by Maria (new) - rated it 3 stars

Maria (mariasm) | 2441 comments Patrick:

"I wish her happiness, even if it means being with someone else that's not me."

Boom!

;)


message 164: by Meliza (new) - rated it 4 stars

Meliza (mecawish) | 720 comments Patrick: I suddenly remembered when we sang "Gwaxa believed in magic..." Haha.


Maria Ella (mariaellabetos) | 1353 comments Hi Patrick - gusto mong sumama sa laslas fanatics? TMI ka rin eh. hehehe.

At pwede bang maglaslas rito - Or is it just some idealized image of that person you had been desperately clinging to in a fit of nostalgia?

Ano yan ne? Move on move on rin pag may time ha? 2014 na~ :D


message 166: by Ranee (new) - rated it 4 stars

Ranee | 1902 comments Gosh Patrick! But I still believe that the opposite of love is indifference. That you can only hurt up to the limit that which you let yourself be hurt. And that blackholes are created when a star dies, when all the combusting elements stop causing the reaction, so as long as you keep that fire burning, no blackholes will be created


message 167: by Cary (new)

Cary (forestercary) | 1370 comments Tsk, tsk! Iba talaga ang nagagawa pag love ang pinag uusapan, nagiging poetic ang mga tao. Pero I agree, pwede ka naman magmahal unconditionally nang hindi nasasaktan. Because to love means making that commitment/choice to care for people whether they love you back or not. :)(view spoiler)


Monique (attymonique) | 2130 comments Patrick wrote: "Love is when you just wish the person who hurt you to be well and not have any guilt left over from the bad experience you've both gone through. To see the other person happy even though you know this person can never have the same feelings for you."

I went through this so I agree. But when I think about it now, the person who hurt me actually did me a favor - if it had not been for that person, I wouldn't be where I am now, right? :D

Haha Patrick, TFG ba talaga ang dapat mag-chill o ikaw? Haha! See you sa F2F ha? And thank you dahil ang tyaga mong mag-backread ng unicorns at halaman. :D

DOC RANEE: I agree with you that the opposite of love is indifference. ;)

--------------------------------------

Here's the reading plan, friends, as promised. You don't need to follow this strictly, but remember that I will be posting questions per week based on this. :)

READING PLAN

WEEK 1 (Jan. 26 - Feb. 1)
- Why Don't You Dance?
- Viewfinder
- Mr Coffee and Mr Fixit
- Gazebo


WEEK 2 (Feb. 2 - 8)
- I Could See The Smallest Things
- Sacks
- The Bath
- Tell The Women We're Going


WEEK 3 (Feb. 9 - 15)
- After The Denim
- So Much Water So Close To Home
- The Third Thing That Killed My Father Off
- A Serious Talk


WEEK 4 (Feb. 16 - 22)
- The Calm
- Popular Mechanics
- Everything Stuck To Him
- What We Talk About When We Talk About Love
- One More Thing


Okay, carry on! :D


message 169: by twstrfries (last edited Jan 25, 2014 07:57AM) (new) - rated it 2 stars

twstrfries | 231 comments (1) When I hear the word "love," I think about (view spoiler)

(2) What is your love language?
(view spoiler)

Patrick: sabi ko sayo teh wag nagpupuyat eh! Haha! Ampalaya pa!

Meliza: Friends to exclusive works. Pero you have to clarify kung asan na ba kayo. Para walang blurred lines.

MU Topic: Yung mga "Parang Kayo, Pero Hindi" stage ba to? Hahaha! Isa lang naman ang lesson diyan, wag asyumera. Di bale ng dense. Tapos bagsak niyan - friendzoned lang pala. (Watch: RB's TFTFZ Episode ZERO)


message 170: by Gwaxa (new) - rated it 3 stars

Gwaxa | 350 comments Patrick: T_T
Di na kita tatanungin bout the taboo subject. ;)


message 171: by Ma. Lalaine (new)

Ma. Lalaine (goodreadscomfirelightlalaine) | 15 comments Love reminds me of Jesus because his love is pure and selfless. That is ideal love.

My language is mostly quality time. Pinipilit ko nga touch pero di talaga. Best answer that describes you e. Haha!


message 172: by Tricia (new) - rated it 4 stars

Tricia (triciuhhh) | 1752 comments Wow, Patrick. (view spoiler)


message 173: by Tricia (new) - rated it 4 stars

Tricia (triciuhhh) | 1752 comments Guys, may PDF copy kayo?


message 174: by Monique (last edited Jan 26, 2014 06:44PM) (new) - rated it 4 stars

Monique (attymonique) | 2130 comments Tricia wrote: "Guys, may PDF copy kayo?"

Tricia, sa first page ng thread na 'to, may link si Mae for ebooks. Message no. 4. Pero mobi and epub format. :)


message 175: by Tricia (new) - rated it 4 stars

Tricia (triciuhhh) | 1752 comments Monique wrote: "Tricia wrote: "Guys, may PDF copy kayo?"

Tricia, sa first page ng thread na 'to, may link si Mae for ebooks. Message no. 4. Pero mobi and epub format. :)"


Yuh! I saw that pero kung walang pdf, convert ko nalang :D


message 176: by Lynai (new) - rated it 4 stars

Lynai | 1188 comments Lovely poster, Monique! :)


Monique (attymonique) | 2130 comments Lynai wrote: "Lovely poster, Monique! :)"

Thank you Lynai! :)


message 178: by Gwaxa (last edited Jan 27, 2014 12:37AM) (new) - rated it 3 stars

Gwaxa | 350 comments Love the poster.
But........the stories feel so "bitin". I'm only on the 3rd one, btw.


Maria Ella (mariaellabetos) | 1353 comments Gwaxa - (view spoiler)


message 180: by Monique (last edited Jan 27, 2014 12:39AM) (new) - rated it 4 stars

Monique (attymonique) | 2130 comments Gwaxa wrote: "Love the poster.
But........the stories feel so "bitin". I'm only on the 3rd one, btw."


Hehe. That's Carver's (dirty realism) style. :D


message 181: by Gwaxa (last edited Jan 27, 2014 12:48AM) (new) - rated it 3 stars

Gwaxa | 350 comments Ella: (view spoiler)

Monique: Sorry, I'm not familiar with that style. Mr. Wikipedia gave me this, (view spoiler).
So basically, what? Naninibago talaga ko. Hehe.


message 182: by JL (new) - rated it 3 stars

JL Torres (jltorres) | 137 comments Sorry, late post:

(1) Finish the sentence: When I hear the word "love," I think about sacrifice and a lot of Heart Bending ala Avatar: the Last Airbender :)

I can't access the Love Language link here in the office, so it's still a mystery :)


message 183: by Maria (new) - rated it 3 stars

Maria (mariasm) | 2441 comments Gwaxa: That's my impression of this book when I read it last year. But I realized, a story does not have to have an ending, in order for me to realize the wholeness of it. :) Try the audiobook after reading, it's another bout of awesome reading experience.


Maria Ella (mariaellabetos) | 1353 comments Maria wrote: "Try the audiobook after reading, it's another bout of awesome reading experience."

Maria, I wanna try that. Pag may ulan tapos malamig ang panahon. Kapartner ang kape at pagbabasa at pakikinig (view spoiler) May point ka jan - and Gwaxa, I think it is better to just fill in the gaps, and feel them. it evokes the dark side of things - those lonely side.

But seriously, my take on each and every Carver's short story is different when explained. i-feel mo ata dapat, ineng.
(view spoiler)


message 185: by Angus (last edited Jan 28, 2014 02:48AM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Angus (angusmiranda) | 4337 comments Ella: I-blender mo na lang ang mga blades tapos ihalo mo sa kapeng mainit. Death by espresso!


message 186: by Maria (new) - rated it 3 stars

Maria (mariasm) | 2441 comments Ella: I'm halfway done with the audiobook. When I was listening to Gazebo, (view spoiler)

Try mo girl, ung audio, dali. :)


message 187: by Monique (last edited Jan 28, 2014 05:32PM) (new) - rated it 4 stars

Monique (attymonique) | 2130 comments WEEK 1 QUESTIONS

Why Don't You Dance?
In the first story, the unnamed narrator appeared to be having a yard sale. If you were to have one, which items/things would you choose to let go and why?

Viewfinder
The photographer in the story had two hooks in place of his hands. Do you think there's any real significance to this detail? If yes, what is it and if there's none, why do you say so?

Mr Coffee and Mr Fixit
The narrator is telling about his wife's lover, Ross aka Mr Fixit. Who is Mr Coffee?

Gazebo
Duane's infidelity is threatening to break his marriage apart. I read somewhere that if you're erasing phone messages so that your partner won't see them, you're getting there. Do you agree? Have you ever cheated or been cheated on? (view spoiler)


message 188: by Joy (new) - added it

Joy (joyabundo) | 80 comments Late post.

Finish the sentence:When I hear the word "love," I think about ________.

(view spoiler)

My Love Language
(view spoiler)


Thank you Mae and Mommy Louize for the e-book and audiobook, respectively. :)


message 189: by Tin (new) - rated it 4 stars

Tin (rabbitin) | 560 comments Week 1 Questions
(view spoiler)


message 190: by Monique (last edited Jan 29, 2014 05:14PM) (new) - rated it 4 stars

Monique (attymonique) | 2130 comments Hi JOY! :) I would sum up your answers in this: when you think about love, you also think about life and the beauty that is life. Do you agree? :)

I think most of us have Quality Time as the primary love language. More of that soon! ;)

TIN: Thanks for your answers! I love your answer in Mr Coffee and Mr Fixit - I never would have thought of the narrator as Mr Coffee for those exact reasons. :)


message 191: by Maria (new) - rated it 3 stars

Maria (mariasm) | 2441 comments Answers to Week 1 Questions:
(view spoiler)


message 192: by Mae (new) - rated it 5 stars

Mae (jamaeca) | 330 comments WEEK 1

(view spoiler)


message 193: by Maria (new) - rated it 3 stars

Maria (mariasm) | 2441 comments A love letter for Duane of Gazebo:
(view spoiler)


message 194: by Angus (last edited Jan 29, 2014 09:09PM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Angus (angusmiranda) | 4337 comments WEEK 1 ANSWERS

(view spoiler)


message 195: by Gwaxa (new) - rated it 3 stars

Gwaxa | 350 comments WEEK 1 QUESTIONS

(view spoiler)


message 196: by Meliza (last edited Jan 30, 2014 01:31AM) (new) - rated it 4 stars

Meliza (mecawish) | 720 comments WEEK 1 QUESTIONS

(view spoiler)


message 197: by Louize (new) - rated it 4 stars

Louize (thepagewalker) | 1831 comments WEEK 1 QUESTIONS

Why Don't You Dance?
In the first story, the unnamed narrator appeared to be having a yard sale. If you were to have one, which items/things would you choose to let go and why?


(view spoiler)

Viewfinder
The photographer in the story had two hooks in place of his hands. Do you think there's any real significance to this detail? If yes, what is it and if there's none, why do you say so?


(view spoiler)

Mr Coffee and Mr Fixit
The narrator is telling about his wife's lover, Ross aka Mr Fixit. Who is Mr Coffee?


(view spoiler)

Gazebo
Duane's infidelity is threatening to break his marriage apart. I read somewhere that if you're erasing phone messages so that your partner won't see them, you're getting there. Do you agree? Have you ever cheated or been cheated on? [If you want to elaborate, please do so. If not, tell us about the lesson you learned from the experience, if any.


(view spoiler)


message 198: by Tricia (last edited Feb 01, 2014 11:45PM) (new) - rated it 4 stars

Tricia (triciuhhh) | 1752 comments Why Don't You Dance?
In the first story, the unnamed narrator appeared to be having a yard sale. If you were to have one, which items/things would you choose to let go and why?

(view spoiler)

Viewfinder
The photographer in the story had two hooks in place of his hands. Do you think there's any real significance to this detail? If yes, what is it and if there's none, why do you say so?

(view spoiler)

Mr Coffee and Mr Fixit
The narrator is telling about his wife's lover, Ross aka Mr Fixit. Who is Mr Coffee?

(view spoiler)

Gazebo
Duane's infidelity is threatening to break his marriage apart. I read somewhere that if you're erasing phone messages so that your partner won't see them, you're getting there. Do you agree? Have you ever cheated or been cheated on? [If you want to elaborate, please do so. If not, tell us about the lesson you learned from the experience, if any.

(view spoiler)


message 199: by Tina (new) - rated it 5 stars

Tina (tinamats) | 2665 comments Before I answer the questions -- a little input on Love Languages ulit. Apparently, it is true that whatever your primary love language is, it also tells you how you withhold your love from someone. For example, if your primary love language is Words of Affirmation, when you are hurt or angry or if you choose not to love someone, you use your words to hurt them too. I guess pag Quality Time, you withhold your time from them -- you don't hang out with them, you don't go out of your way for them anymore, etc. (view spoiler)

And also, Patrick! (view spoiler)

Tralala ang dami ko na naman sinabi. Answering questions now! :D

Why Don't You Dance?
(view spoiler)

Viewfinder
(view spoiler)

Mr. Coffee and Mr. Fixit
(view spoiler)

Gazebo
(view spoiler)


Monique (attymonique) | 2130 comments WOW. Just... wow. Thank you guys. :)

MARIA: Sis, hindi ka naman galit masyado kay Duane nyan? Bakit parang may pinaghuhugutan yata? LOL!

MAE: I wish I could also say I would sell old clothes because they're too large for me already! And, you had French classes in high school? Wow! :D

BUDDY: On your answer to Gazebo: So is it your opinion that if a person starts to cheat, whether just by thinking it or by performing overt acts, he/she must have already fallen out of love with his partner? Am I correct? :)

GWAXA: If a photographer with hooks for his hands were to knock on your door and offer you a photograph that he took of you, would you let him in for the same reasons that the house guy did? :)

MELIZA: Same follow-up question as Gwaxa's, haha!

MOMMY LOUIZE: At what point do you think any couple should be better off without their relationship, if one has admitted to cheating the other? :)

TRICIA: Aww. (((HUGS))) Don't worry - these things happen for a reason. Isn't it true that whatever doesn't kill us only makes us stronger? And you're still alive, yes? ;)

COUSIN TINA: I agree with your preliminaries (haha!). There wasn't any discussion on that but we can do it sa F2F. :) Also, I totally did the burning thing. LOL.

---------------------

Awesome answers, guys. Keep 'em coming. ;)


back to top
This topic has been frozen by the moderator. No new comments can be posted.