Tidal
discussion
What book did you like the best out of the watersong series
date
newest »
newest »
message 1:
by
Brianna
(new)
-
rated it 5 stars
Jan 03, 2014 05:14PM
I liked the whole series but if i had to choose just one i think I would choose Elegy it was a page turner
reply
|
flag
Brianna wrote: "I liked the whole series but if i had to choose just one i think I would choose Elegy it was a page turner"
I have to say Wake. I loved it because it was the intro and it was supposed to draw you in and it did it was amazing like the first bite of your favorite food.
I have to say Wake. I loved it because it was the intro and it was supposed to draw you in and it did it was amazing like the first bite of your favorite food.
Brianna wrote: "Nicely said!!!!"
Thank you! I always wanted someone to say that to me!
Thank you! I always wanted someone to say that to me!
I disagree. I thought the first two books were pretty poor. And the second two really stepped up, and one me over which I didn't expect to happen. I can't decide which book was best out of Tidal or Elegy but they were both great!!!
Maddie wrote: "I disagree. I thought the first two books were pretty poor. And the second two really stepped up, and one me over which I didn't expect to happen.
I can't decide which book was best out of Tidal ..."
I think that's because Tidal and Elegy were the big action parts. By then we know all there is to know and now something big has to happen. So that's why elegy and tidal may appear to be better. Either your the type of person who likes that first bite or the person who likes the juicy meaty part.
I can't decide which book was best out of Tidal ..."
I think that's because Tidal and Elegy were the big action parts. By then we know all there is to know and now something big has to happen. So that's why elegy and tidal may appear to be better. Either your the type of person who likes that first bite or the person who likes the juicy meaty part.
While I enjoyed the series, I was simultaneously disappointed by it, oddly enough. There were a lot of places for potential growth that Ms. Hocking either didn't seem to have enough space to flesh out properlly or simply ignored (I'm looking at you, Thea as an older sibling angle).What I liked best was the combination of siren and mermaid lore into a cohesive package that didn't feel forced. The characterizations were well done. The drama and suspense were at the right tempo. The books were a great read, but I can't help but feel that with a bit of TLC to certain aspects, they could have been amazing.
You have a good piont I agree
I would have to say Wake because it really drew me into the Watersong series. Also, maybe Elegy but I have to read it first and decide for myself but based on what some people have told me, it is a really good book.
I liked all of them but I think Elegy would be the best because it's thicker compared to the other three books and it's also the last book of the series which makes it more interesting and hard to put it down :)
