The Empty Hearse

[Monica]

Let's discuss because that was one amazing episode. Moffat and Gatiss really do read all our theories and fanfiction it seems.

[[deleted user]]

I have not seen it yet! *cries* Now I will have to avoid all Sherlock talk if I don't want spoilers.
Sad day here in America...

[Monica]

Have you tried streaming it? I live in NZ and I don't think we even have an airdate yet so I livestreamed in online.

[[deleted user]]

Oh! I will have to see it I can stream it somewhere!!

[Sinda]

I streamed it, and it was one of the most beautiful episodes. (Almost) Everything turned out how I hoped it would, and I just loved it.

[talltyrion]

Where did you stream it from? I've been looking for a site...

[shrish]

Has anyone even seen it??? I'm bored, I want to talk about it, IT WAS PERFECTION.

[Anna]

Oh my goodness, I was so happy with this episode!! It was amazing! (view spoiler)[Still not sure they actually told us how Sherlock did it, but it almost didn't matter because they gave us so many possibilities of how he COULD have done it. And John's reaction. And MARY! SO GOOD! I LOVE HER ALREADY! And she's Martin Freeman's actual partner, so that makes it even better. And the END! Sherlock is such a jerk! (hide spoiler)] For anyone who's still looking for somewhere to watch it, get this on Google Chrome: https://chrome.google.com/webstore/de... Then go to http://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/b018ttws and unblock the site.

[Monica]

(view spoiler)[ And what's even cuter is that Sherlock's parents were actually his real parents!! But the whole episode was amazing. No matter how much character development Sherlock gets he will never stop being a dick. Really hope Mary doesn't turn out to be evil though or end up dying cause I love her. Sooo funny though. It was just like giant fanfic. I don't ship Sherlolly but that kiss was adorable. And maybe I'm starting to ship Sheriarty now... Fave part of the ep though is probably the bit where it cuts between Sherlock and John and we get Fcough and the finger xDD Brilliant though. Can't wait for The Sign of Three!!
Also for spn fans: It's funny cause this time John was on fire instead of Mary. (Thanks tumblr -.- ) (hide spoiler)]

[[deleted user]]

asdfghjkl;
It was so good guys.

[Elaina]

Does anyone else think that Fanderson is a good shipper?

[Zapperzz]

Elaina wrote: "Does anyone else think that Fanderson is a good shipper?"
No, only Johnlock is permitted.

[Elaina]

Zapperzz wrote: "Elaina wrote: "Does anyone else think that Fanderson is a good shipper?"
No, only Johnlock is permitted."

You don't count. I know you.

[[deleted user]]

Oh my gosh, this episode was so good! (view spoiler)[It was so creative how they made Sherlock live, I never thought that it would be so simple yet so creative. I was thinking that he just wasn't human or something. xD (hide spoiler)]

[Anna]

Just watched it last night. I was amazing. I want to say that Sherlock interacting with his parents was hilarious. (view spoiler)[You would expect them to be like their sons. Here, Mycroft and Sherlock's father cannot even remember where he placed tickets. (hide spoiler)] Also, some one needed to tell Molly (view spoiler)[that Sherlock does not like to be upstaged in front of Lestrade. (hide spoiler)]

[Julia]

Good grief!!! I just watched it, and probably fangirled to hard... I yelled at the TV at one point, and it made my elbow hurt; I went to the doctor's earlier, and they tried to test my blood... (view spoiler)[The second theory made me sooo not happy. Moriarty NEEDS to be dead, in my opinion. The first theory made sense, but breaking the glass seemed like it wasn't right. But the last one; the code name was HILARIOUS! The air cushion thing didn't seem right either... I feel like none of the theories are right, but I'm probably wrong... (hide spoiler)]

[[deleted user]]

Actually, Julia, the producers said that the third theory is closest to the truth, but not entirely. Basically, after two years of waiting, no one theory would live up to that pressure. Well, that is my thought anyways.

[Theodosia of the Fathomless Hall]

Eee, we saw it last night!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Er, ahem, they said that didn't they? Hmf, typical. The best/worst thing is though, that we can't really complain since a good part of it is mocking the fan's theories :D. I thought Watson noting that didn't seem to be good enough was directed towards them too!

Well, (view spoiler)[ So. Watson. And Sherlock. With the bomb. In the train car.
He honestly says(while he's laughing) "Your face!"
I hate him, really, awful, and also the best character there incidentally (hide spoiler)]

(view spoiler)[ Some of it didn't seem like the first season, though, just the filming and such? (hide spoiler)]

[Julia]

Wait, so none of them were right?!?!? I feel so smart now... I was thinking how none of them were quite right... (view spoiler)[It makes me so mad that Sherlock showed himself RIGHT WHEN JOHN WAS ABOUT TO PROPOSE!!! I was not at all happy with him then. (hide spoiler)]

[[deleted user]]

yeah, it was rude of him, but that is Sherlock. And it was comical!
(view spoiler)[Am I the only one that like that Watson did not attacked Sherlock once but three times! It is a reasonable reaction, and I loved it!! (hide spoiler)]

[Theodosia of the Fathomless Hall]

@Rebecca - (view spoiler)[ I loved it. Dear, old, mild Watson going berserk. That was what I liked and more. (hide spoiler)]

Hey Julia! Good job :). I loved and hated it, the French accent sort of justified it...though...

[Julia]

Yeah, Rebecca (view spoiler)[I was sooo happy when Watson attacked Sherlock. I kind of yelled at the TV telling Watson to punch Sherlock... It worked!!! ;D (hide spoiler)]

[Monica]

And I loved how (view spoiler)[ each time John attacked Sherlock they got kicked out of the place and each time we next see them they've been degraded to a cheaper place xD (hide spoiler)]

[Julia]

That was sooo funny, but I really felt bad for (view spoiler)[Mary. (hide spoiler)] I don't know if that really is a spoiler though... I mean, I cannot WAIT until (view spoiler)[then next one when John and Mary get MARRIED!!! (hide spoiler)]

[[deleted user]]

I think (view spoiler)[ Mary found it all very amusing. She is awesome! (hide spoiler)]
And THE SIGN OF THREE IS AMAZING!!!

[Julia]

Sign of Three???

[[deleted user]]

That is the next episode.

[Julia]

Ahhh... I haven't seen it yet... :'(

[[deleted user]]

You'll get to see it on Sunday, right?

[Julia]

Yes!!! If my mom lets me...

[Theodosia of the Fathomless Hall]

Oh! Yesterday we re-watched it and realized Molly's fiance was part of Sherlock's despicable fan club.
No wonder he looked so irked :D.

[Julia]

He is?!?!?! I never noticed that!!! That's really weird... I have watched it twice now too...

[Theodosia of the Fathomless Hall]

I know!! We had no idea when we first saw it, excepting the look on Sherlock's face, but when we watched it again - well - he(e.g. Molly's fiance) wears a (view spoiler)[ scarf, a coat, a long, black, coat, and is wearing shoes that are too big for him(presumably they are shoes that are Sherlock's size).
(hide spoiler)]
Voila, I hid it in a spoiler in case you would like to figure it out via the episode!

[Julia]

I noticed what he was wearing... Even Watson (sort of) noticed that something was up!!! I don't think that he knew exactly what, but he knew something!

[Theodosia of the Fathomless Hall]

Great!
(The ending was rather priceless, anyway.)

[Julia]

Yes!!! I was like, who the heck is that?!?!

[Theodosia of the Fathomless Hall]

Me too!

[Julia]

I WANT TO KNOW WHO HE IS!!!!!!! And why he (view spoiler)[was trying to kill Watson!!! (hide spoiler)]

[Theodosia of the Fathomless Hall]

Milverton...?
The man at the very end you mean? With the somewhat eerie hideout?

[Julia]

YES! I seriously really need to read Conan's books, but my sister took it to college...

[Theodosia of the Fathomless Hall]

Oh, that guy! I don't know either, and in fact his name is Milverton in the books but not in the series(in which it's Magnusson).
You could check it out from your library if you can?
And do you want me to say who he is?

[Julia]

Yes, please tell me who he is!

Good idea, I'll try to find it in the library!

[Doctor Who Fan]

FINALLY SAW IT! I wanna know exactly how he survived!!

[Theodosia of the Fathomless Hall]

Julia wrote: "Yes, please tell me who he is!

Good idea, I'll try to find it in the library!"

I'm sorry for taking such a long time! I know that the former point is a bit moot by now -- It's been an age since we chatted! -- Have you read the stories as of now?

[Jazzy]

Excellent reentry to the show after waiting an eternity and two months for the season to come out. I just wish they had shown how Sherlock did it!