The Catcher in the Rye The Catcher in the Rye discussion


11982 views
The Most Overrated Books

Comments Showing 4,251-4,300 of 5,680 (5680 new)    post a comment »

message 4251: by Danielle (new)

Danielle Tremblay Monty J wrote: "LOTR was the second movie I ever walked out of, after about the third monster or dragon or whatever. Fantasy monsters don't do ..."

Well said. I read and loved Ayn Rand's novels though. It was an open-minder for a leftist like me. They say: "Know your enemy...". ;) Nothing is perfect and we can learn from anyone, particularly those those who have a vision radically different from ours.

But forget me if you have a Tolkien's book to read. lolll That and books about zombies. I want nothing to do with zombies. Not interesting at all.


Paul Martin Danielle wrote: "It was an open-minder for a leftist like me. "

Open your mind, you never must.


message 4253: by Stephen (new) - rated it 1 star

Stephen Lindow Forgive me. I keep seeing the same 25 literature titles:
Bovary, on the road, the road, twilight, tree brooklyn, monte cristo, lord rings, beloved, da vinci, grisham, king, et al. I give my barbaric yawp from the Burj Khalifa for these titles:

PABLO NERUDA anything
PAUL ELUARD anything
C.D.WRIGHT "TREMBLE"
IVAN LALIC "THE RUSTY NEEDLE"
ANNIE DILLARD "TEACHING A STONE TO TALK"
DIANE ACKERMAN "A NATURAL HISTORY OF THE SENSES"
GEORGES BATAILLE "THE STORY OF THE EYE"
CARLOS CASTENADA "DON JUAN & THE YAQUI WAY"
GALWAY KINNELL "THE BOOK OF NIGHTMARES"
EMILE ZOLA "GERMINAL"
HONORE BALZAC "THE UNKNOWN MASTERPIECE"
ROBERT PIRSIG"ZEN & THE ART OF MOTORCYCLE MAINTENANCE"
GONZALES "DEEP SURVIVAL"
TED HUGHES anything
JERRY POURNELLE & LARRY NIVEN "INFERNO"
PETER MAYLE "A YEAR IN PROVENCE"
CORMAC MCCARTHY "BLOOD MERIDIAN"
BARRY LOPEZ "FIELD NOTES"
JEFF LONG "DESCENT"
JIM HARRISON & TED KOOSER"THE BRAIDED CREEK--A CONVERSATION IN POETRY"

CABANNE "DIALOGUES W/ MARCEL DUCHAMP"
JOHN HAINES "THE OWL IN THE MASK OF THE DREAMER"
ITALO CALVINO "MR. PALOMAR"
THOMAS MERTON "THE WAY OF CHUANG TZU"
LOREN EISELY "THE NIGHT COUNTRY"
NATHANIEL HAWTHORNE "RAPPACINNI'S DAUGHTER"
WILLIAM SAROYAN "YOUNG MEN ON THE FLYING TRAPEZE"
WADE DAVIS "ONE RIVER"
WILLIAM STAFFORD "THE WAY IT IS"
AI "SIN"
PAUL AUSTER "SELECTED POEMS"
BRILLAT-SAVARIN "THE PHYSIOLOGY OF TASTE"
CHRISTIAN BOK "EUNOIA"
ROBERT BLY "MORNING POEMS"
PAUL BOWLES "NEXT TO NOTHING"
MARY REUFLE "COLD PLUTO"
JEAN COCTEAU "GRACE NOTES"
JULIO CORTAZAR "CRONOPIUS & FAMAS"
NICOLA TADIC "THE NIGHT MAIL"

EUGENE GUILLEVIC SELECTED POEMS (Denise Levertov translation)
COVINGTON "SALVATION ON SAND MOUNTAIN"


H Anthony Yeah, I hate how everyone's always going on about how much they love The Physiology Of Taste.


Booksdigger S Geoffrey wrote: "Da DeVinci Cold by far is at the bottom of that list. Piece of crap, pandering to Anti Catholic Catholics.
And no, I am not Christian.

Atlas Shrugged was boring. Ayn Rand is boring. Her political ..."


Geoffrey wrote: "Da DeVinci Cold by far is at the bottom of that list. Piece of crap, pandering to Anti Catholic Catholics.
And no, I am not Christian.

Atlas Shrugged was boring. Ayn Rand is boring. Her political ..."



Very honest reviews! Enjoyed reading your reviews. I concur, though it's been a while since I read some of the books in the list.


Geoffrey I was very much bothered by the anti-Catholic sentiments presented in Dan Brown books. The Church deserved well his diatribe five centuries ago. Today, it's a much more moderate institution. Why not exercise all that bile against the CIA and its operations in Central America? Now that takes real guts.


message 4257: by chiara (new) - rated it 3 stars

chiara Eleanor & Park definitely.


Petergiaquinta H Anthony wrote: "Yeah, I hate how everyone's always going on about how much they love The Physiology Of Taste."

^^^
AND MOAR CAPS!!! RAWR!!!


message 4259: by Stephen (new) - rated it 1 star

Stephen Lindow H Anthony wrote: "Yeah, I hate how everyone's always going on about how much they love The Physiology Of Taste."

Sarcasm is easy H Anthony. Have you read the title? Just because you haven't heard of many of these titles doesn't mean I'm trying to impress by being elitist. Sorry about the caps, it was a pre-written list.


Petergiaquinta @Stephen

Anthony has a point, even if he was being a teeny bit sarcastic. But he can speak for himself.

But really? "Anything" by Neruda and Ted Hughes is overrated? The mind reels...pray tell.


H Anthony Stephen wrote: "H Anthony wrote: "Yeah, I hate how everyone's always going on about how much they love The Physiology Of Taste."

Sarcasm is easy H Anthony. Have you read the title? Just because you haven't heard ..."


I'm not suggesting you're being elitist - just that a list of titles that you didn't like, some of which would be hard to describe as having much impact on the broader culture, doesn't really qualify them as 'overrated'.


message 4262: by Mark (new) - rated it 5 stars

Mark Hey, guys, I haven't been in here for a long time. Are there new dick heads?

BTW, I thought Lalic's "The Rusty Needle" was fantastic! Right up there with with Willy Vlautin's "Lean on Pete." Both are almost as good as "I Dig A Pygmy" by Charles Hawtrey (and the Deaf Aids) ... particularly Chapter One ... in which Doris gets her oats.

I also have a much beloved and dog eared copy of
STEPHEN BOASTS A LARGE READING, ONE GOODER THAN MOST OF US


message 4263: by E.D. (new) - rated it 4 stars

E.D. Lynnellen Monty J wrote: "Danielle wrote: "Lord of the Rings

I hate these books and movies!"


LOTR was the second movie I ever walked out of, after about the third monster or dragon or whatever. Fantasy monsters don't do ..."


Monty, this brings a tear of joy to my eye. Thank you. :}


message 4264: by Kallie (new) - rated it 5 stars

Kallie I would rather mention an underrated book: Melville's 'Pierre: or the Ambiguities' which I'm reading now. It is a strange, beautiful, psychologically intricate novel in poetry. Took me a while to get into its rhythm and language but I'm hooked.


Geoffrey Not even funny, Mark. Nice try.


message 4266: by K. (new) - rated it 5 stars

K. R. M. This list is the stupidest thing I've read in quite a long time, really. People didn't just agree on considering "Waiting for Godot" a great play. And by the way, stupidity starts right there, calling it a "book", implying it's a novel. Surely it's subjective opinions, taste, and so on, but simply from an analyists point of view, some of these works mentioned are brilliantly done and really precious reads.


Petergiaquinta Mark wrote: "Hey, guys, I haven't been in here for a long time. Are there new dick heads?"

There just might be, and some of them are really weaving it, coming on strong all the time.


message 4268: by Karen (new) - rated it 5 stars

Karen Mark wrote: "Hey, guys, I haven't been in here for a long time. Are there new dick heads?

BTW, I thought Lalic's "The Rusty Needle" was fantastic! Right up there with with Willy Vlautin's "Lean on Pete." Both ..."


ROTFLOL !!! I spilled my coffee.


message 4269: by Saeed (new) - rated it 5 stars

Saeed no one has mentioned Slaughterhouse-Five yet?

that book is absolute torture to read!


Petergiaquinta If by "absolute torture" you mean one of the best experiences you'll ever have with a book, then I agree enthusiastically.

Maybe you just didn't get it...


message 4271: by Mark (last edited Nov 13, 2014 02:37PM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Mark Geoffrey wrote: "Not even funny, Mark. Nice try."

No offense, Geoffrey. But the day I use you as a resource to gauge how I'm doing in the "make 'em laugh" department is the day I turn in my comedic gun and badge (not that I, uhm, have such things). Besides, I thought I had some seniority and, therefore, more latitude to be a dick head (but lovable) myself.


message 4272: by Karen (last edited Nov 13, 2014 02:42PM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Karen I thought it was funny, that's why I spilled my coffee when I read it.
A gun and a badge would be exciting.


message 4273: by Renee E (new) - rated it 4 stars

Renee E Karen wrote: "I thought it was funny, that's why I spilled my coffee when I read it.
A gun and a badge would be exciting."


And chaps. Leather chaps.


message 4274: by Renee E (new) - rated it 4 stars

Renee E Karen wrote: "I thought it was funny, that's why I spilled my coffee when I read it.
A gun and a badge would be exciting."


And chaps. Leather chaps.


message 4275: by Karen (new) - rated it 5 stars

Karen Renee wrote: "Karen wrote: "I thought it was funny, that's why I spilled my coffee when I read it.
A gun and a badge would be exciting."

And chaps. Leather chaps."


Riding a Harley


message 4276: by Renee E (new) - rated it 4 stars

Renee E Bareback.


message 4277: by Mark (new) - rated it 5 stars

Mark Renee wrote: "And chaps. Leather chaps."

I feel validated. Thank you Renee and Karen. And ... is there such as thing as chaps that aren't leather?

Let me tell you how close I can get to what you are all imagining. Theme song: http://youtu.be/97YE-LvXxKc


message 4278: by Karen (new) - rated it 5 stars

Karen Renee wrote: "Bareback."

How else would you ride a Harley?


message 4279: by Karen (last edited Nov 13, 2014 02:55PM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Karen Mark wrote: "Renee wrote: "And chaps. Leather chaps."

I feel validated. Thank you Renee and Karen. And ... is there such as thing as chaps that aren't leather?

Let me tell you how close I can get to what you ..."


Chaps that are lace and not leather don't do what they're supposed to do.


message 4280: by Renee E (last edited Nov 13, 2014 02:55PM) (new) - rated it 4 stars

Renee E Karen wrote: "Renee wrote: "Bareback."

How else would you ride a Harley?"


Think about it for a sec.

Now . . . form a mental image . . . :D

And yeah, Mark, there are waxed canvas chaps.

But they aren't . . . you know . . . . . . . leather . . . .


message 4281: by Mark (new) - rated it 5 stars

Mark Renee wrote: "Bareback."

You are right up to the edge of naughty, Renee.

And I like it.

Or does that sound like typical patriarchy bullshit?

I don't want it too, but you never know.


message 4282: by Kallie (new) - rated it 5 stars

Kallie Mark wrote: "Renee wrote: "And chaps. Leather chaps."

I feel validated. Thank you Renee and Karen. And ... is there such as thing as chaps that aren't leather?

Let me tell you how close I can get to what you ..."


There are fleecy chaps. I think they are sheepskin but the inner, smooth side is very, very soft. I've felt guilty wearing sheepskin. The softness reminds me of lambs I think. (A Jody Foster as what'sername moment?)


message 4283: by Renee E (new) - rated it 4 stars

Renee E Mark wrote: "Renee wrote: "Bareback."

You are right up to the edge of naughty, Renee.

And I like it.

Or does that sound like typical patriarchy bullshit?

I don't want it too, but you never know."


If it sounded patriarchal, wouldn't it also sound incestuous?


message 4284: by Karen (new) - rated it 5 stars

Karen Kallie wrote;
"There are fleecy chaps. I think they are sheepskin but the inner, smooth side is very, very soft. I've felt guilty wearing sheepskin. The softness reminds me of lambs I think. (A Jody Foster as what'sername moment?)"

Do they have lace on the outside?


message 4285: by Karen (new) - rated it 5 stars

Karen Renee wrote: "Karen wrote: "Renee wrote: "Bareback."

How else would you ride a Harley?"

Think about it for a sec.

Now . . . form a mental image . . . :D


Ohhhhhh... okay.



message 4286: by Kallie (new) - rated it 5 stars

Kallie Karen wrote: "Kallie wrote;
"There are fleecy chaps. I think they are sheepskin but the inner, smooth side is very, very soft. I've felt guilty wearing sheepskin. The softness reminds me of lambs I think. (A Jod..."


Don't see why Mark couldn't applique some lace if he likes that look.


message 4287: by Karen (new) - rated it 5 stars

Karen Kallie wrote;
"Don't see why Mark couldn't applique some lace if he likes that look."

Ya!!


message 4288: by John (new) - rated it 5 stars

John Rogers OK. I get it. People don't like books that are hard.


message 4289: by Kallie (new) - rated it 5 stars

Kallie John wrote: "OK. I get it. People don't like books that are hard."

Huh? Where did anyone say that?


message 4290: by Gary (last edited Nov 13, 2014 07:02PM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Gary John wrote: "OK. I get it. People don't like books that are hard."

Many people do prefer paperbacks.


Anne Hawn Smith "Anne, I couldn't get past Katie's and Johnny's relationship. It seemed so sad and disfunctional to me that I put the book aside. Perhaps if I had made it to Francie' s story I would feel differently. "

I think you're right. Katie and Johnny's lives were a mess, but I only considered them the backdrop to Francie's story.


Paul Martin Ginesthoi wrote: "Has anyone read Isaacson's book on Steve Jobs? I thought that one for sure would fall into the overrated category. But it pleasantly surprised me. I thought it was very well done."

I haven't read the book, but as the biography of the co-founder of the most perversely overrated brand in human history, it sure fits in this thread.


message 4293: by Kallie (new) - rated it 5 stars

Kallie Gary wrote: "John wrote: "OK. I get it. People don't like books that are hard."

Many people do prefer paperbacks."


HaHa.


message 4294: by Shannon (new) - rated it 4 stars

Shannon Robinson I think that Pulitzer Prize-winning book "The Goldfinch" was completely over-hyped and over-rated. It was a pretty good book, only about 350 pages too long. It was overly wordy and written in a strange vintage Brit style in what was meant to be modern day New York, and the timelines of events were all off. I don't understand how it won a Pulitzer.


message 4295: by Mark (new) - rated it 5 stars

Mark Shannon wrote: "I think that Pulitzer Prize-winning book "The Goldfinch" was completely over-hyped and over-rated. It was a pretty good book, only about 350 pages too long. It was overly wordy and written in a str..."

Amen. Amen. Amen. I'm am so friending you right now.


message 4296: by Shannon (new) - rated it 4 stars

Shannon Robinson I really appreciate people who agree with me. :D heeeee


Booksdigger S Shannon wrote: "I think that Pulitzer Prize-winning book "The Goldfinch" was completely over-hyped and over-rated. It was a pretty good book, only about 350 pages too long. It was overly wordy and written in a str..."

That is my book to read for 2015. So is it worth spending time on?


message 4298: by Shannon (new) - rated it 4 stars

Shannon Robinson Booksdigger wrote: "Shannon wrote: "I think that Pulitzer Prize-winning book "The Goldfinch" was completely over-hyped and over-rated. It was a pretty good book, only about 350 pages too long. It was overly wordy and ..."

If you want to wade through it for lack of anything better to do...but it's never going to make my Recommended Reading list. I wouldn't read it again, that's for sure. My favorite books are ones that I want to re-read. This ain't one of 'em. There are so many well-written books to choose from out there! :)
(Short answer - NO) hehehe


Booksdigger S Shannon wrote: "Booksdigger wrote: "Shannon wrote: "I think that Pulitzer Prize-winning book "The Goldfinch" was completely over-hyped and over-rated. It was a pretty good book, only about 350 pages too long. It w..."

Thanks !!


message 4300: by Michael (new) - rated it 5 stars

Michael Sussman I really disliked Virginia Woolf's Orlando, and now I'm struggling to get through The Waves. What am I missing?


back to top