Burke 2H discussion

This topic is about
Lord of the Flies
Final LOTF Post
message 1:
by
Kate
(new)
-
rated it 4 stars
Sep 26, 2013 08:54AM

reply
|
flag

I was really shocked with the ending of the novel. I really hoped and thought that all the savages would still be stranded on the island and Ralph was the only one who got rescued. But, I really liked that Jack lost all authority because there was an adult; he finally came back to reality. I was upset that Samneric were captured by Jack and his hunting tribe; I thought they would have resisted him. It sucks that Piggy died though, I really wanted him to be saved! Roger justs scares me, is he a psychopath or something?? I guess I'm glad that the the savages has come back to their senses and realized that they were actually human! I personally wouldn't recommend this book; it's too crazy and wild. From this novel, I learned that people should learn how to resist temptation.

Period 1
Lord of the Flies, to me, has taught me that anything can happen to people when they are put in a tough situation. Some people react and adapt to the circumstances while others continue to live by society rules. I loved the book because it has really shown me the evil that can appear in people, including innocent children. I would recommend this novel to some of my friends and also to parents. This book could open their eyes to see the crazy outcomes of life. The ending was not surprising after reading chapter 11, but I still enjoyed seeing the boys being rescued and finally viewing them as children again.


Period 1
As the novel drew to a close, several plot points surprised me. Firstly, the destruction of symbols, including both the Conch and the "Lord of The Flies" representing a deconstruction of civilization, with nothing holding the "Savages" back do do whatever they desire. Next, the instant appearance of and Adult, a Figurehead, a Leader, instantly snapped the boys back into reality, allowing readers to take a step back, and allowed us to realize the bigger picture forming, and realize the fact that the survivors on the island, are only kids.
I would recommend this book to not only my friends and family, but also to readers in general. The deep symbols, motifs and deeper meanings gives every reader a slightly different experience with the novel.
From the novel, I have learned to resist not only temptation, but also anger and hate. Blind rage causes many people, not only in the novel but in real life, to act on their intentions and do things they will likely regret later on.

Per 1
What really surprised me at the end of the book, was how fast Jack went from some savage, vicious, creature, to an innocent little boy like before as soon as they saw the officer. It showed how fast they could transition back to civilized children as soon as a figure of came into play. I was also very shocked that when the officer asked who was the leader, Jack did not oppose Ralph when he stepped forward. All in all, it was a great book and it taught me how evil a person could be when we are not surrounded by an enforced set of laws.

Ethan Fong
Period 3
#12

Period 3
Upon the arrival of the ship, Jack’s savages abruptly revert back to children, a surprising change given that Ralph noted earlier that the image of Bill as a normal boy in shorts was “ancient.” Despite the time the boys spent on the island and how far they stray from humanity, the presence of one adult is enough to bring them back to reality in a few minutes. That was peculiar because most who forsake their conscience do so permanently. In part, the boys’ return to their childhood stems from the fact that the navy officer’s appearance reminds them of society and, more importantly, family and home; the boys are still children despite the atrocities they have committed. In that sense, the ending of the story is consistent with human nature (children yearn to be with their parents) but contradicts the message Golding attempts to convey in Lord of the Flies, that all people are inherently evil.
I'd recommend this book to my philosophical, book-smart friends; they'd appreciate the many many MANY literary connections in this story.
Holistically, I find the story disturbing because of its plausibility. Although the chances of anyone crashing on an uncharted island are very slim, the odds of ending up in an equally tough situation are not. On the island, the boys are independent for once in their lives, and, similarly, I’ll eventually be on my own. The predicaments I’ll face will obviously differ greatly from those of the schoolboys, but in society, there are still more than enough ways to stray from good and honorable courses and become immoral beasts. This story serves as a reminder that rational thinking and conduct (proven by the fact that only Ralph is able to speak to the naval officer) is still more powerful than savage, animalistic behavior (the hunting of Ralph) even though it may not seem so.

Period 3
It is pretty disappointing that all of the boys that are left are allowed to leave, even Jack and Roger. They had murdered 2 boys and showed no sorrow. Although they are "just boys", they should have at least felt some guilt. After all, they were raised in a society for one portion of their life. All in all, Golding reveals that the beast inside everyone is restricted by civilization. It is clearly shown in Jack. Lord of the Flies was a very enjoyable book, but the deaths are somewhat horrifying. The idea that society controls the savagery in people is a very interesting topic that many people should look into.

Period 3
#6
This book showed how different people adapt under certain circumstances. It really shows the evil within all of us. It teaches that you don't really know someone until you've seen their actions in a tough situation. People will start to change when there are no authority or nothing controlling them. I was a bit surprised by the way Jack acted as soon as an adult appeared. It seemed like he became a completely different person and it shocked me. I would recommend this book to my friends and to readers. I normally don't like reading books but surprisingly, i really enjoyed this novel!

Period 1
I was surprised at how the novel ended, due to how Golding made Simon and Piggy die; I thought that Ralph would end up being killed by Jack and the other boys, losing the only symbol of civilization left, ending the novel with Jack and the other boys stranded on the island forever. However, the novel ended the opposite of what I imagined it to be, Ralph and the other boys are saved by an officer. I noticed how quickly Jack and the hunters snapped back to society when they saw the officer, and it made me think that children need an adult there to guide them towards the right path. After reading this novel, I realized that everyone has a dark side to them, but it does not show until they are in trouble.

The ending of Lord of the Flies came as a surprise to me. I thought that Ralph was going to end up killing Jack and taking control of the boys, but I was wrong. The book as a whole shows the darkness that is hidden within all of us. I would recommend this book to anyone in middle school or up because it introduces the reality that not everyone is good. This book does a good job at showing that everyone has a little evil in them and that no one is completely good. Even Sam and Eric, who were loyal to Ralph after Jack's tribe formed, ratted out Ralph's hiding spot. Overall, I enjoyed this book with it's exploration of human nature, and I would recommend it to anyone who has already lost their sense of "innocence".

Period 3
The ending of the book really surprised me because I was really hoping that Jack and the rest of the hunters would get what they deserve and stay stranded on the island. Ralph deserved to be rescued because throughout all of the events that took place, he was always concerned with getting rescued. His rationality and personality made him a well-liked character, along with Simon and Piggy. I was very upset with the deaths of both of them because they both were done in a way that left the hunters unphased. At the end however, I was impressed that after all the fighting Jack was able to give up his self-given title as chief and go back to the way things were before. This book has taught me that everyone has something inside of them that causes them to be savage and evil, but with the help of order and law, we are able to stay rational even in the midst of difficult situations.

period 1
#23
The end of Lord of the Flies was not expected on the part that the children were saved. I thought at the beginning of the end that Ralph and Jack were going to have and epic face off where Ralph would ultimately prevail. However when the Royal Marine showed up and rescues them from their trouble and craziness. This was a surprise because I personally thought that they would never be saved. I would recommend this to my sister and friends for it would give them a lot to think about. The lesson that I learned is not to lose my mind when my pride is hurt like Jack did.

Period 1
The ending of Lord of the Flies surprised me. From the various clues given by Golding like "[the] stick [being] sharpened at both ends," I expected that Jack and his tribe would find Ralph and do what they had planned to do to him. What surprised me the most was the fact that they quickly snapped back to reality after seeing an adult. Even though they had done many evil things, they begin to cry. Their evil disappears and they don't take the blame for any of their actions. Shouldn't they feel even a little guilt?
Overall, the novel is a great way to show readers the possible change in human mentality. I learned that even children can become evil and they are capable of doing evil things that adults usually do.

Period 1
#21
I personally was surprised and disappointed by the ending to the Lord of the Flies. I did not think that Jack and the rest of the boys would be rescued. Instead, I would have liked to see the boys slowly start to turn on one another and kill each other off. This way, Golding could further emphasize how our own savagery could lead to our own downfall. Without morals and logic, we will gradually cause our own annihilation. The rest of the novel is a great representation of what our uncontrollable inner "beast". I would recommend this book to those who are intrigued by human behavior, and the idea of nature versus nurture. What I took away from this novel is that people will be people, and it is a natural instinct to look out only for themselves. As long as we think of ourselves, shall we remain within the clutches of our inner animals. It is our morality and ability to look out for others that separates us from beasts to humans.

Period 1
The ending of the novel was very fast paced, intense, and took an unexpected turn. Ralph's panicked state and the chaos of an island crumbling down around the boys really emphasized how the boys had gone to a point of no return. I think the event of the burning island built up a great climax which ultimately ended in a touching resolve. I really enjoyed the detailed descriptions Golding used to depict either the serenity of Simon or the brutality of Jack and his savages. I also liked the subtle hints and foreshadowings of death and almost tangible feelings of fear that Golding conveyed. His descriptions of characters overall brought the situation to life; Ralph's scraggly appearance and unstable mind due to Piggy's death, Jack and Roger's methods of slaughtering pigs and torturing littluns. This novel was really enjoyable and was an intense adventure overall.

Tamara Mustafa #33
period 3

To be honest, i expected the kids to be rescued. Not many authors will write a book that ends with all of the characters doomed. As far as the novel itself goes, i truly enjoyed it. The way it was written, and all of the subtle details that Golding inscribes within it makes it very enjoyable. I would recommend the Lord of the Flies to everyone who is in 8th grade or higher, being that kids under that age might not understand the message behind the book.

The book taught me what really separates a savage and an animal from a civilized human being. I learned that companionship and order is necessary in order to form a civilized society, and once we are taken out of society we become more and more like animals. All human beings, even children, are capable of killing animals and people while in the conscious mind.
I think I would recommend this book to anyone who is in middle school or older. If someone reads this at an age that is too early, they may not understand or catch all the symbolism that lies on every single place, and that's really important to know of. It was a great book overall, and it's really changed my perspective on the nature of human beings.
Doris Li #17
Period 1

Dillon Kim #13
Period 1

Period 1
The ending of the novel came as a surprise for me. I did not expect the surviving boys to be rescued by a naval officer. Even when the boys were rescued, I did not expect them to change there savage personality, especially Jack, so quickly. I overall enjoyed reading this gripping, action-based novel. I would recommend this book to my mom because she constantly asks what is happening. This novel has shown me to not over react and to control my emotions to avoid consequences. I also learned that children are capable of becoming savage beasts when uncivilized.

Kristen Yoo #31
Period 1

Period 1
The ending of Lord of the Flies is very unexpected, yet it is easily predicted. Jack had set the whole island on fire, and Ralph before was also trying to create fire so that they can all be rescued. As a result of the tragic fire, a naval officer comes and rescues them. I really liked the scene where everyone started crying after Ralph explains to the British officer about everything that had happened. I believe that the reason they started crying is because they had realized what they had done and were not themselves. They had murdered two of their friends out of sheer instinct and savagery. When the officer asked for the leader of the group, Ralph said that he was instead of Jack who hesitated to answer. This shows that even though Jack is now leader of the tribe only the civilized Ralph can confront a high authority naval officer. All in all, the ending was quite satisfying to read and I would recommend this book to anyone who is trying to find a good novel to read.

Period 1
The final events at the novel were expected, but the timing was a surprise. I was surprised by how fast the boys snapped back to reality. The prescence of just one adult made them realize how violent they were acting. I thought that Ralph would have been killed or one of the main characters would have died. I had hoped that all the boys in the story would survive. Everyone has as a very bad side to them that is shown when put through tought situations. This book is relatable to everyone in at least one way which makes it such a interesting novel.

Overall, I really enjoyed the book, from all the vivid imagery and symbolism, to the main and obvious facts that the story presented. This book really opened my eyes to see that maybe people are really evil on the inside. I really wonder what would happen if we were left alone for a week without ANY authority.
Crystal Tran #28
Per. 3

Teja Chilukuri, #8
per. 3

The ending of the book was surprising because I did not think Jack and the rest of the savages would be rescued. However I knew Ralph would be saved and the fact that he is the only one able to respond to the officer is no surprise. Roger was definitely the biggest surprise in the novel because Golding leads you to believe that Jack is the most evil, violent, and savage beast on the island. Although I thought this was an entertaining book the point Golding gets across to the reader is horrid and terrifying. There really is evil in all of us and it gets me thinking about how myself and others would act toward one another if we were not taught to control it. What if civilzation disappeared and the order was gone? The endless possibilities are frightening.

Maxwell Zhu #33 Per.1

The ending of the novel was not a surprise to me. Although I was shocked that Jack gave up his authority so easily, I always thought the boys were going to be rescued. However, I did think some of the savages that lost their sense of civilization, like Roger and Jack, would have preferred to stay on the island to continue to hunt. I guess the sight of adults, and authority snapped them back to reality. Since the beginning of the book, I've noticed a great resemblance to the TV series, Lost. Apart of me expected an ending similar to the series finale. Overall the ending to the novel was satisfying as a reader.


Golding once again emphasizes how all men are inherently evil, as seen in Jack's attempt to kill Ralph by setting the fire. However, not all lives were saved: the two probably most "innocent" characters of the novel, Piggy and Simon were eradicated for their superior mentality and morality. In comparison to the other boys of the group, these two boys were what truly showed the purity yet harshness of nature. The ending was, in a way, a complete shock to me for I believed Golding would have thought that Jack did not deserve to be saved. From the very beginning, I believed that Golding would write how Jack chose to stay on the island with the hunters and continue their savage, animalistic ways of life.
I would definitely recommend this book to any individual that wishes for a novel filled with symbols, allegories, vivid descriptions, and imminent deaths. All in all, this book had taught me to control my inner personality, and in any way possible leave such a characteristic hidden inside.

Jonathan Rodriguez
Period 1
#24

Period 3
Personally, the ending was rather surprising to me. The sudden violent change of the boys was a shock that completely changed the end of the story. After the death of Simon, the savagery and violence of the group of boys escalated very quickly. Simon's death was quickly followed by Piggy's and nearly ended in Ralph's too. The sudden change of attitude from an obsession with hunting to a blood-thirsty and murderous mindset shows the extent in which people can change once removed from the rules of society. Overall, this book was a very good read and I would definitely recommend it to anyone. This book taught me that we all have an evil within us, and without society and rules to control it, we would live very savage lives.

Adelynne Chang, #1,
Period 1

Period 3
The ending of Lord of the Flies was definitely shocking and intense. When Ralph was hiding, and all the close calls of being caught was very intense. I thought all hope of them being rescued was lost and that the boys would end up killing each other like the savages they are. When they ran into the navy officer, it was very surprising to see the boys reactions. It was good to see that the boys still had civil thoughts and that they were able to understand that everything they did on the island was reality and that there is no changing that. Ralph was the only one who stepped up when the man asked who was in charge. I was glad that Jack was not the one who stepped forward. Jack is not worthy or able to hold such responsibility because or his savage ways. Overall, the novel was like a roller coaster of events just like life. I'd recommend this book to future leaders as this book shows how power can change the way someone behaves and show the extent of what people are willing to do to get power.

Period 3
I was surprised at the ending of the novel. I did not think that the group of boys would be rescued before another death occurred. When the novel was nearing its end, I began to hope that Jack and Roger would either be killed or not rescued, to prove that a savage life is not a proper life. Due to the fact that Jack was unable to believe in anything other than hunting, I was surprised at how quickly his savage, violent ways were cast aside and he became silent. Ralph on the other hand, remained civil throughout the novel and was easily able to respond to the officer about the events and to claim himself as chief. Overall, I really enjoyed reading this book, because it teaches you to respect the civil ways that you have been taught, otherwise you may lose all sense of humanity to savagery. I think that the way that Golding was able to emphasize how the evil inside us is easily revealed is what makes this novel very interesting and satisfying to the reader.

Period 3
The ending of the novel was shocking and unexpected. Who would of known that Jack and the rest of them would be brought back to civilization. Although I kind of knew that Ralph would not die, when the hunters found Ralph, I kept thinking that this is the end. The moment the officer started talking I was a little surprised because I did not know how or when he got here until I remembered that the island was set on fire. Also, the fact that Jack didn't say that he was the leader of the group of boys when the officer asked, sort of surprised me because he has this sense of pride and confidence to stand up and speak; however, he doesn't, mainly because he has lost his rationality and Ralph is the only one who still has it. The whole novel was really intense especially when I remembered that the people on the island acting as savages were children! I learned that when put in tough situations, one may end up shedding his or her civilized self in order to survive. would recommend this book to anyone who's around seventh grade and up. The vocabulary isn't too difficult and as long as you pay attention while reading, it isn't that hard to understand what is going on.

Period 1
From the novel, readers learn that without society to keep us in line, people are able to disregard all the accepted rules of society. However, in the presence of a person with superiority, the savageness is contained. At the end of Lord of the Flies, I felt relieved. When both Simon and Piggy are dead, and Ralph is being hunted down, I was shocked to see the extent of the boys’ savagery. Although I was surprised learn about the naval officer, I was relieved when Jack and his hunters were silenced by the appearance of an adult. Overall, I really enjoyed the book. I was met with unexpected events, suspense, and the satisfying use of symbolism throughout the novel. I feel that Golding was able to bring out the novel's full potential through the contrasting foil characters. I would recommend this book to friends and family who haven't read this book yet.

Period 3
The ending of the book was an anticlimax for me. All the dramatic and gruesome death foreshadowed a third, final death. I was expecting a final confrontation between Jack and Ralph symbolizing logic v.s. savagery. Furthermore, the boys sudden change of heart at the end of the book seemed to unreal and fake. However, it is interesting to speculate why Golding had inserted the rescue right after Piggy's death. I think Golding had a final hidden theme: knowledge and reason will always come up on top, as shown with the arrival of the officer. As for recommendations, I would recommend this book to anyone interested. One of the core themes I feel, is the theme of evil and darkness in each and every person, bound by civilization.

Period 1
Although I had pretty much expected that the stranded boys would get rescued, I felt disappointment when the "savages" were privileged enough to leave and live the rest of their lives, especially Jack and Roger. What surprised me, though, was the scene when the inhumanity immediately diminished when they stumbled across the militant officer. It warmed my heart to see Jack finally understand that he was not fit to be leader, as he tried to speak up to the officer, but couldn't. I was truly glad to see Ralph the one who walked forward, instead of foolish Jack. The entire novel never ceased to put pressure and suspense on the occurring events and conflicts, which amplified the novel's overall quality. I would definitely suggest it to a friend, simply because it includes dramatic sequences that would not cease to amaze. This novel not only taught me that evil lies within all beings, but also to resist the tantalizing temptation that haunts everyday life.

Period 3
I thought the ending of the novel was a bit unsatisfying. Sure, the boys were finally in sight of rescue, but I felt as if the novel should have continued on a little and explained to the readers how the boys went back and coped with "regular" surroundings and how they would fit back in to society. Just having the boys see a naval officer after all the troubles they went through made the ending weak in my opinion. More could have been done to elaborate on the scene, at the very least. However, even though I found the ending not up to par, I think that Lord of the Flies was an excellent novel in whole. It represented how people acted when unchecked by a system of authority. It showed me that as much as people may dislike society the way it is, it's like that for a reason. The troubles that the boys were placed in and the ways they dealt with these problems were also very eye-opening. They reminded me of what the most important things to do were if one got lost and stranded with no way to contact others.
I would probably recommend this book to my colleagues in Boy Scouts, for they could learn a great deal about surviving with what nature provides. The Boy Scouts in my troop have learnt all about these situations and they should know what to do in a theoretical situation. However, reading this novel and seeing how survival techniques could be applied in a real life scenario could be very beneficial to them.
After reading Lord of the Flies, I learned that society is strict for a reason. If a government was not strict its citizens, things could become chaotic. The result would be something far worse than what the governing system offered. Another thing to be gained from this novel is that one should always try to be rational and logical. Once those two things are thrown out the window, other unpleasant thoughts begin to rise. This novel has many life lessons embedded in its pages.

Period 1
I feel very ambivalent towards the ending of Lord of the Flies. True, it is inferred that the remaining people who are alive get off the island, there is still something that doesn't satisfy the reader. Piggy and Simon are still dead, and the island is left in a war-torn state. It's similar to the people who go fight in World War II. In the end, the people who are still alive return home, yet some still have war traumas. Same concept in Lord of the Flies. I was taken aback but happy when I saw the naval officer finally arrive, yet the boys' overall savagery throughout the entire plot of the story is too much to consider it a happy ending or a sad ending. I learned from this story that we need law and order in our lives in order to restrain ourselves, and I would recommend this book to anyone.

Period 1
The ending of the book was a kind of a surprise to me. When Ralph comes running out of the jungle, I would expect him to be hunted down and murdered. It comes as a surprise that there is a Navy officer there on the beach watching this unrealistic scene unfold in front of him. I wish though, that only Ralph with Sam and Eric could be taken off the island, and leave the Group of savages behind. They deserve it and they think they can handle it themselves too anyway. I was also surprised that when Ralph told the twins his hiding spot, the just gave it away the next day when only being hut a little. In my opinion, a true friend would have held your secret until death. Overall, the novel shows that there is a seed of evil in every human and it only needs to be in the right conditions to sprout and grow into catastrophe. I would suggest this book to anybody that could understand the nature of human evil and what actions are deemed bad. Otherwise, this would just be another action survival typical Island story.

Period 3
The ending of Lord of the Flies wasn't as a great as I thought it would be. Although it was a good book,it wasn't very satisfied with its ending,I felt like the ending happened to fast, all of a sudden Jack is searching for Ralph,the island is on fire,and then they just got rescued, I think things should have moved a bit slower. The fact that all the boys simply snapped back into the reality of things just by seeing an adult didn't really make a good ending.
Although the ending did not meet up to my standards,the overall novel was great. I would recommend it to my brother,church friends, and teammates. I believe they would able to learn how fast people can change, I think this would help them stay true to themselves even in the most difficult times.
After reading,Lord of the Flies, I learned that evil is embedded in us from the moment we are born,it just takes certain events to make us snap and let the evil come out.

Judy Kim #14
Period 1

I would recommend this book to anyone, especially to high school students and young adults. Nowadays, we are so fascinated with material things that we can take our resources (and civilization!) for granted. By reading about the loss of morality within a group of young children who are supposed to represent innocence, maybe we can learn to value what we have and recognize that there might be a tinge of evilness inside us that we should learn to control.
Alison Chang, #2
Period 3

#18
Period 1
To be honest, I was pretty disappointed in the book. Someone told me that there would a lot of violence such ad cannibalism, but there was no cannibalism or as much gruesome details as I thought there would be. However, some of the symbols and little details on the book got me thinking and I found that interesting. Also, I did not want Jack and the over savages to be rescued and saved. Furthermore, I wish there was an epilogue of some sort telling us how the boys cope with the events that took place on the island.
Overall, I enjoyed reading the book. However, there were a few things I was not satisfied with including the vague ending.

Per. 1
I found myself to be rather shocked by just how savage the boys had become. I was rather disappointed with the ending of the Lord of the Flies. Jack and his savages seem to be pardoned despite having taken two lives and performed torture on Samneric. However Golding's novel as a whole was a very enjoyable experience. It was as if I had watched the events unfold on the island myself rather than through words on bound paper. I recommend this book to anybody that is in high school. Anybody younger than that might not be mature enough to appreciate the beauty of the writing. From this book, I learned about the true nature of man. I learned about the evil people are naturally born with and its cage - society.