David Estes Fans and YA Book Lovers Unite! discussion

Monsters (Ashes Trilogy, #3)
This topic is about Monsters
59 views
Buddy Reads! > Monsters Buddy Read

Comments Showing 101-117 of 117 (117 new)    post a comment »
1 3 next »
dateUp arrow    newest »

Karen’s Library | 11320 comments Mod
Just finished. I get it now, Caitlin!! I get the ugh and the SPECTACULAR!

Am I the only one that wept when (view spoiler)

Yes, the gore was gruesome. (view spoiler) But after that scene, like David said, the gore lost its impact.

I think the entire series was incredibly well written! I've been living with Alex and Tom and Ellie for two years now and am sad that it's over.

Ilsa was on Facebook one day while she was writing Monsters and she said she had been crying over how much her characters suffered while she was writing one of the scenes.

Do you do that, David? I would imagine that you do! ;-) I can think of quite a few scenes from your books where I bawled!!


Caitlin (caitlinsiem) | 409 comments Finely, I can speak! Lol. Karen I'm glad you see what I mean now but I do understand where the others were coming from about the gore ruining it a bit. None of that really bothered me but growing up with an ER Nurse for a stepfather who discussed things in detail over dinner problem cured my of that haha.

But yes, I agree (view spoiler)

This easily slipped into one of my top 5 favorite series. And I had more to say but the sneeze I just had seemed to flush it out of my brain!


Karen’s Library | 11320 comments Mod
Caitlin wrote: "Finely, I can speak! Lol. Karen I'm glad you see what I mean now but I do understand where the others were coming from about the gore ruining it a bit. None of that really bothered me but growing u..."

It was extremely intense!! I get it that it's just not everyone's cup of tea. Even I had to take a break from the intense and gore a couple of times. And I loved the story! I decided to wait to finish on the weekend when I would have time and the luxury to have the time to savor the end and take it all in slowly instead of trying to rush to read it late at night after a long work day.

And glad I wasn't the only weepy one. ;-)

Can't wait to read your review, Caitlin!


message 104: by David, Mr. Blue Eyes; He's the Best--Ain't no lie!! ;) (new) - added it

David Estes (davidestesbooks) | 10717 comments Mod
Karen wrote: "Just finished. I get it now, Caitlin!! I get the ugh and the SPECTACULAR!

Am I the only one that wept when Chris and Ellie did the ashes? Especially Ellie! In fact, I'm still weepy. I loved Mina..."


Yes! I absolutely do that! If I'm not crying as I write a scene where one of my favorite characters dies, then I usually re-write it because it must not have been emotional enough. And if I'm not laughing at my own jokes then I certainly can't expect anyone else to!


Karen’s Library | 11320 comments Mod
David wrote: "Karen wrote: "Just finished. I get it now, Caitlin!! I get the ugh and the SPECTACULAR!

Am I the only one that wept when Chris and Ellie did the ashes? Especially Ellie! In fact, I'm still weepy..."


That makes me feel better, David! At least I know you were as heartbroken as I am when I'm reading it. ;-P


Caitlin (caitlinsiem) | 409 comments My book review is up! Hope you enjoy it Karen ;)

http://wp.me/p3SYar-x


Karen’s Library | 11320 comments Mod
Caitlin wrote: "My book review is up! Hope you enjoy it Karen ;)

http://wp.me/p3SYar-x"


As usual, INCREDIBLE review, Caitlin!! I tweeted! :-D


Caitlin (caitlinsiem) | 409 comments Thanks Karen! It means the world to have your support! And as always, it's so fun to buddy read with you :D


Karen’s Library | 11320 comments Mod
Ditto! Buddy reads make the experience of the book so much better!


message 110: by David, Mr. Blue Eyes; He's the Best--Ain't no lie!! ;) (new) - added it

David Estes (davidestesbooks) | 10717 comments Mod
Karen wrote: "David wrote: "Karen wrote: "Just finished. I get it now, Caitlin!! I get the ugh and the SPECTACULAR!

Am I the only one that wept when Chris and Ellie did the ashes? Especially Ellie! In fact, I..."


Hahaha! I love my characters, and though I kill them indiscriminately when it's their time, it still saddens me :(


message 111: by David, Mr. Blue Eyes; He's the Best--Ain't no lie!! ;) (new) - added it

David Estes (davidestesbooks) | 10717 comments Mod
Wow, that really is an amazing review Caitlin! I wish I could write reviews like that!


message 112: by Jen (new) - rated it 1 star

Jen (jenwesner) | 1222 comments Caitlin wrote: "My book review is up! Hope you enjoy it Karen ;)

http://wp.me/p3SYar-x"


Wow, great review! I think you hit every point possible!


Caitlin (caitlinsiem) | 409 comments Thank you Jen and David! That means a lot :D


message 114: by Jenny, Always smiling! :-D (new) - added it

Jenny (juliababyjen) | 12932 comments Mod
David wrote: "Karen wrote: "Just finished. I get it now, Caitlin!! I get the ugh and the SPECTACULAR!

Am I the only one that wept when Chris and Ellie did the ashes? Especially Ellie! In fact, I'm still weepy..."


Good to know! Yeah, I laugh and cry while reading your books. Demon Evolution had me cracking up a LOT! lol


message 115: by Jenny, Always smiling! :-D (new) - added it

Jenny (juliababyjen) | 12932 comments Mod
Caitlin wrote: "My book review is up! Hope you enjoy it Karen ;)

http://wp.me/p3SYar-x"


Loved your review, great job!


message 116: by Jenny, Always smiling! :-D (new) - added it

Jenny (juliababyjen) | 12932 comments Mod
Okay, so I was the turtle this go round...I FINALLY FINISHED IT!!! It was a solid 4 star read for me. I didn't love it as much as Caitlin and Karen, but I did really like it. The ending was FANTASTIC, I loved every part of the last 20% or so. It took us awhile to get there, but when we did...everything suddenly made sense. Ilsa is a brilliant writer! Amazing how she pulled all that together!


message 117: by David, Mr. Blue Eyes; He's the Best--Ain't no lie!! ;) (new) - added it

David Estes (davidestesbooks) | 10717 comments Mod
Jenny wrote: "David wrote: "Karen wrote: "Just finished. I get it now, Caitlin!! I get the ugh and the SPECTACULAR!

Am I the only one that wept when Chris and Ellie did the ashes? Especially Ellie! In fact, I..."


LOL! I aim for laughter :)


1 3 next »
back to top

70863

David Estes Fans and YA Book Lovers Unite!

unread topics | mark unread


Authors mentioned in this topic

Ilsa J. Bick (other topics)