David Estes Fans and YA Book Lovers Unite! discussion

Monsters (Ashes Trilogy, #3)
This topic is about Monsters
59 views
Buddy Reads! > Monsters Buddy Read

Comments Showing 51-100 of 117 (117 new)    post a comment »

Karen’s Library | 11320 comments Mod
YES, in gruesomeness!! I can't get the images from Chapter 53 out of my head. Hahahah... Erase, erase, erase...!!


Katelyn Broad (katelynb) Yeah, this book is definitely gruesome. I'm only on chapter 47 but it's good to know i have more gruesomeness to look forward to in chapter 53... *looks around nervously* I've been reading this at work and my manager just walked in and asked why I looked so disgusted. Haha!


Karen’s Library | 11320 comments Mod
Conversation I just had with Ilsa on Facebook:

Karen Benson: I'm halfway done with Monsters. Ilsa! I can't get Chapter 53 out of my freaking head!!

Ilsa J. Bick: Heh. Mission accomplished.


Karen’s Library | 11320 comments Mod
Jen wrote: "I'm at Chapter 73. Holy CRAP when are these characters going to catch a break? [spoilers removed]
This book is crazy, just flat crazy. There is no following any kind of what you think is going t..."


Apparently, this just keeps going and going and going per Jen. :-P


Karen’s Library | 11320 comments Mod
Katelyn wrote: "Yeah, this book is definitely gruesome. I'm only on chapter 47 but it's good to know i have more gruesomeness to look forward to in chapter 53... *looks around nervously* I've been reading this at ..."

That made me laugh picturing you trying to sneak a read at work.


Caitlin (caitlinsiem) | 409 comments Karen, that's awesome. She is so awesome. I am at 32% myself. Oh my goodness!


Katelyn Broad (katelynb) Karen wrote: "Conversation I just had with Ilsa on Facebook:

Karen Benson: I'm halfway done with Monsters. Ilsa! I can't get Chapter 53 out of my freaking head!!

Ilsa J. Bick: Heh. Mission accomplished."

That's awesome! Haha!


Karen’s Library | 11320 comments Mod
Whoops. Correction! Chapter 54!!! MY brain apparently got a bit scrambled after reading it.


message 59: by David, Mr. Blue Eyes; He's the Best--Ain't no lie!! ;) (new) - added it

David Estes (davidestesbooks) | 10717 comments Mod
LOL!!! She is a crazy woman!


Karen’s Library | 11320 comments Mod
She enjoys tormenting us!!


Caitlin (caitlinsiem) | 409 comments I think I might be a bit if a masochist then because I'm enjoying the torment lol. It's. Just. So. Good!


message 62: by Karen’s Library (last edited Oct 03, 2013 11:32PM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Karen’s Library | 11320 comments Mod
50% in. I'm in awe! No gore in this chapter. (view spoiler)

Some answers are revealed finally but now more questions! I am thinking the gruesome is finally calming down quite a bit.

Now we're getting somewhere! Hang in there guys! Keep going!


message 63: by Karen’s Library (last edited Oct 03, 2013 11:39PM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Karen’s Library | 11320 comments Mod
Caitlin wrote: "I think I might be a bit if a masochist then because I'm enjoying the torment lol. It's. Just. So. Good!"

Same here, Caitlin! I'm curious to see if anyone else finds Chapter 54 as disturbing as I did. Jenny, for me, it was comparative to how disturbed you were by Michael Grant's (view spoiler).


Katelyn Broad (katelynb) Caitlin wrote: "I think I might be a bit if a masochist then because I'm enjoying the torment lol. It's. Just. So. Good!"

I'm with ya Caitlin! This book is definitely getting better and better as I read on, even though it is becoming more and more gruesome.
P.S. I love your name! :)


message 65: by Karen’s Library (last edited Oct 04, 2013 12:21AM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Karen’s Library | 11320 comments Mod
Eep! It's official! Ilsa J. Bick Ilsa J. Bick is coming to answer our questions from November 11th through the 17th!! David set up the thread, so pop in and say hey and start thinking up questions to ask. I think anything goes with her! She's got a quirky sense of humor!

So excited!

http://www.goodreads.com/topic/show/1...


Caitlin (caitlinsiem) | 409 comments Okay, so... I'm on chapter 50 and (view spoiler)


Karen’s Library | 11320 comments Mod
Caitlin wrote: "Okay, so... I'm on chapter 50 and [spoilers removed]"

Ha Caitlin! I know! That entire section was kind of freaky! (view spoiler)


Karen’s Library | 11320 comments Mod
Jen wrote: "I'm at Chapter 73. Holy CRAP when are these characters going to catch a break? [spoilers removed]
This book is crazy, just flat crazy. There is no following any kind of what you think is going t..."


I finally made it to your spoiler, Jen! I'm at Chapter 76, 58% in. I took a day off from this book because everyone's right. It's so intense! You literally don't get a chance to come up for air, chapter after chapter!


Caitlin (caitlinsiem) | 409 comments Just hit part for (chapter 55) and I'm gonna say chapters 52-54 were all quite chilling. I'll admit, I felt more empathy for different characters then I felt grossed out. It was so well written though. And I think what Ilsa does well is that she doesn't add gore for gores sake. Does that make sense? Like, it all has a purpose, albeit a twisted one but still


Caitlin (caitlinsiem) | 409 comments So the end of chapter 56...

(view spoiler)

Am I the only one who freaked here from excitement?! I was waiting for that moment since forever!!!!


message 71: by Karen’s Library (last edited Oct 06, 2013 02:29PM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Karen’s Library | 11320 comments Mod
Caitlin wrote: "So the end of chapter 56......"

Oh absolutely not! See my spoiler in my message 62 from when I was at 50%!!! I sat up in my bed with a big WTH????!! But don't read it until you're at 50%!!!


Caitlin (caitlinsiem) | 409 comments I will :) I get so tempted to read spoilers ahead but I'm restraining myself! lol


Katelyn Broad (katelynb) Caitlin wrote: "Just hit part for (chapter 55) and I'm gonna say chapters 52-54 were all quite chilling. I'll admit, I felt more empathy for different characters then I felt grossed out. It was so well written tho..."

I agree with you. I just finished 54 and while it was gross, I liked that it wasn't just disgusting just to be disgusting. I'm loving that this book is getting somewhere now! I want answers!


message 74: by David, Mr. Blue Eyes; He's the Best--Ain't no lie!! ;) (new) - added it

David Estes (davidestesbooks) | 10717 comments Mod
OK OK, you all are killing me, but I'm finally jumping back into this book, starting from 19% :) Can't wait!!


Caitlin (caitlinsiem) | 409 comments 52% in. Phew! My goodness! Karen... I totally understand and agree with all of your message 62!!! So much stuff!

And welcome back David! It's nice to have a head start on you for once. Even if it's only for a day! Lol.


message 76: by David, Mr. Blue Eyes; He's the Best--Ain't no lie!! ;) (new) - added it

David Estes (davidestesbooks) | 10717 comments Mod
Lol thanks!


Caitlin (caitlinsiem) | 409 comments Just reached chapter 103. 75% and

(view spoiler)

I'm so addicted to this book!


message 78: by David, Mr. Blue Eyes; He's the Best--Ain't no lie!! ;) (new) - added it

David Estes (davidestesbooks) | 10717 comments Mod
Um 38% I think :) Oh gosh, the whole thing with (view spoiler) was awful!


Caitlin (caitlinsiem) | 409 comments Agreed David! It was quite shocking. It caught me so off guard!


message 80: by Jenny, Always smiling! :-D (new) - added it

Jenny (juliababyjen) | 12932 comments Mod
I'm in the same place, and yes, it was horrible!


Karen’s Library | 11320 comments Mod
Chapter 100. 76% in. Seriously? (view spoiler)


Karen’s Library | 11320 comments Mod
David wrote: "Um 38% I think :) Oh gosh, the whole thing with [spoilers removed] was awful!"

Yea, was not expecting that at all!!


Karen’s Library | 11320 comments Mod
Caitlin wrote: "Just reached chapter 103. 75% and

I almost started crying just now! When Tom realized the little girl was Ellie and then she noticed him!!! So sweet. So touching. It was perfect. But I hope Chris..."


Just hit Chapter 103 so I can finally read your spoiler.

(view spoiler)

This is so good, how am I going to put it down tonight to sleep?


message 84: by David, Mr. Blue Eyes; He's the Best--Ain't no lie!! ;) (new) - added it

David Estes (davidestesbooks) | 10717 comments Mod
52% Gosh, I'm getting really confused with a lot of the names and backstory, but now I really want to know what the heck (view spoiler) have to do with anything!


Caitlin (caitlinsiem) | 409 comments You'll find out David. Don't you worry ;) just keep reading!!!


Karen’s Library | 11320 comments Mod
David wrote: "52% Gosh, I'm getting really confused with a lot of the names and backstory, but now I really want to know what the heck [spoilers removed] have to do with anything!"

It's actually relevant! The last half of the book, for me, seems to be the best.


Caitlin (caitlinsiem) | 409 comments I'm at 92%... And I'm LOSING MY MIND!!!


Caitlin (caitlinsiem) | 409 comments I just finished... I don't know what to do...

I feel like this was a prank. How can that be the end?! Ugh... I will actually respond once my brain stops spinning...


Katelyn Broad (katelynb) Caitlin wrote: "I just finished... I don't know what to do...

I feel like this was a prank. How can that be the end?! Ugh... I will actually respond once my brain stops spinning..."


Uh oh, now I'm nervous.


Caitlin (caitlinsiem) | 409 comments It was SPECTACULAR!!!

Katelyn, I seriously can't wait for you to finish :D


Katelyn Broad (katelynb) Caitlin wrote: "It was SPECTACULAR!!!

Katelyn, I seriously can't wait for you to finish :D"


Me either! I'm only on page 454 unfortunately. It's taking me forever.


Karen’s Library | 11320 comments Mod
Katelyn wrote: "Caitlin wrote: "I just finished... I don't know what to do...

I feel like this was a prank. How can that be the end?! Ugh... I will actually respond once my brain stops spinning..."

Uh oh, now I..."


Me too!! Ugh and SPECTACULAR are both words that don't go together. Hehehheheh... I'm at 79%. Will finish up tonight after yet ANOTHER Board meeting. 3 back to back... Put a fork in me, I am DONE. :-P I just want to get home and READ already.


Caitlin (caitlinsiem) | 409 comments Yay! Karen I hope you understand my contradiction better when you finish ;) I am so massively addicted to Bick's writing now!


message 94: by Jen (new) - rated it 1 star

Jen (jenwesner) | 1222 comments Done. Done, done, done, and I am so glad. My thoughts:

(view spoiler)


message 95: by David, Mr. Blue Eyes; He's the Best--Ain't no lie!! ;) (new) - added it

David Estes (davidestesbooks) | 10717 comments Mod
I'm freaking out now, what with Jen's two star review and all your excited comments and spoilers that (Wah! I can't read!). I'm at 55% and going rather slow.

One thing about the gore, I have to be honest, I think it's losing its impact as there's so much of it I don't really notice anymore. Another eyeball scooped out, more intestines spilling, yada yada, I'm tending to skim those parts...

But I'm still very much interested in how everything will fit together, and gosh, I really want these poor characters to catch a break already!


message 96: by Jen (new) - rated it 1 star

Jen (jenwesner) | 1222 comments David wrote: "I'm freaking out now, what with Jen's two star review and all your excited comments and spoilers that (Wah! I can't read!). I'm at 55% and going rather slow.

One thing about the gore, I have to b..."


Those 2 stars are just a reflection of my initial reaction - and honestly, this book just wasn't something I really liked. I don't want to bring the rating down on the book - but I just had such a problem getting through it that if I'm honest, it's just a 2-star book for me. All that nonstop action was great for someone who likes that sort of thing. But I visualize everything, and it just got to be too much. I did like the science of the changed and Finn and Alex's monster.

Not sure what I thought of the ending, really.


message 97: by David, Mr. Blue Eyes; He's the Best--Ain't no lie!! ;) (new) - added it

David Estes (davidestesbooks) | 10717 comments Mod
I hear you about the action, I became so ready for the "slower" parts that I found myself enjoying them more than the action :) I finished by the way, still trying to get my thoughts together! She is a very talented writer though, the way she describes things is impressive!


message 98: by Jenny, Always smiling! :-D (new) - added it

Jenny (juliababyjen) | 12932 comments Mod
Finally up to 52% and its getting good now! (view spoiler)


Katelyn Broad (katelynb) I finally finished it and all I can think is: wow. I don't even know what to say. I was surprised that I actually really loved the ending. That series was like a crazy roller coaster.


message 100: by Jenny, Always smiling! :-D (new) - added it

Jenny (juliababyjen) | 12932 comments Mod
I'm now up to 70% and its going much faster now! I was hoping to finish it today, but I had to take a nap before work...wasn't feeling well. And then I proceeded to have daymares involving ghosts. *shivers* It actually gave me goosebumps IN MY DREAM!!! I've never had that happen before! Off the topic, sorry!

Anyways, really liking this a lot better after the halfway point, and things are starting to make more sense now.


back to top

70863

David Estes Fans and YA Book Lovers Unite!

unread topics | mark unread


Authors mentioned in this topic

Ilsa J. Bick (other topics)