A Dance with Dragons
discussion
Will Aegon Targaryen be the one who eventually gets the Iron Throne?
date
newest »

message 1:
by
Edgar
(new)
-
rated it 5 stars
Sep 19, 2013 12:17AM

reply
|
flag

I'm also 99% sure that Aegon won't make it to the end of the series alive, and probably not even to the end of Winds of Winter. He might die in battle. Or possibly, someone (a Lannister - or maybe even a Tyrell) might hire a faceless man (or maybe a faceless woman/girl) to get rid of this yet another contender for the Iron Throne before he gets too far. Or, most interestingly, he might be bumped off by Varys if he starts getting too uppity and forgets who his benefactors are.

I think it's a bit early to tell what he'll do and I'm looking forward to seeing what happens with him no matter how long he lasts.
One correction though, Robb Stark never wanted the Iron Throne. He was King in the North and intended to rule the North and let the rest of the six kingdoms squabble amongst themselves. He just wanted vengeance for Ned and, to some extent, the right to live free from the rule of Joffrey Baratheon.

Even if he is for real, why do Varys and Illyrio and whoever else is involved with hi..."
The same way it was 'proved' that Cersei's children were not Robert's. No DNA test involved there either. Even in the real world, DNA technology has been around only 20-30 years. In all the thousands of years prior to that, human societies have found numerous ways to cross-check people's identities that didn't involve DNA tests. Of course, such methods are not exactly fool-proof, and none of them can be as objective as DNA testing (which is why Cersei's children are still officially considered Baratheons, and are still on the Iron Throne). But that doesn't change the fact that anyone who cares enough to dig into Aegon's past and/or what actually happened to Elia's baby could probably find evidence that Aegon is not who he claims to be.
Varys and Illyrio know perfectly well that most other great houses of Westeros don't want a Targaryen on the throne (they each want themselves on the throne). But there are some exceptions: the Martells support the Targaryens, so Aegon has the automatic support of one of the seven kingdoms (Dorne). The Targaryens were the 'official' royal family for centuries, and in a feudal system, many people believe in the divine right of kings. So even if the great houses don't want a Targaryen back on the throne, there may be a number of other important lords who are willing to support Aegon's claim. Not to mention, the common people are also likely to support it (not that anyone cares about the poor smallfolk). And last, but not least, Aegon isn't planning on just strolling into King's Landing and asking for his throne back. He has landed in Westeros at the head of a conquering army. Whether or not the other houses 'want' him there is kind of immaterial.


So he has at least 5000 men with him who are ready to fight and win him the throne. Not as big as what Dany has, but fairly large really and these men are probably better warriors than most Westerosi considering they've been fighting more often for a longer period of time and have absolutely no qualms relating to honor or rules of engagement.





Tragically for you, one of GRRM's themes seems to be "blood means nothing wrt leadership".

At the end of #5 Varys sings the praises of Aegon as some sort of 'humble emperor' it seems likely this means either Aegon will die early, turn out to be worse than Joffrey or as above not be a Targ.
I'm starting to think that GRRM isn't going to put anyone on the throne, mayhap it will destroyed by dragon-fire, Westeros itself will be decimated or maybe by the end no-one will want the throne anyway.


Just don't want to see Dany vs Aegon, that'd just be sad IMO.

Second, I hope that Aegon gains the Iron Throne, I really do. He has more rights to it than Dany, being Rhaegar's heir. Yeah, he was just introduced, but that doesn't mean he is an ignorant character. As Varys said, he has been shaped for ruling his whole life, and he, having lived a harder life, would NOT end up being a Joffrey. He comes for his birthright, and he has my full support.
Third, I don't think Martin is going to kill him off quickly (if he dies at all). I say this because he's not going to do what he did with Quentyn, introducing a character and then eliminating him right away. Aegon has a large role to play.
Fourth, Martin, in a Game of Thrones panel actually said that there will be a few others who sit the Iron Throne before the end. SO, with that being said, let's say that Aegon does eventually die (though I hope not), I believe at one point he will, actually, sit the Iron Throne. How long his reign will last is questionable, but I truly think he will be king for at least a small period of time.
Fifth, it's obvious that Aegon is one of the heads of the three-headed dragon, so this convinces me of his larger role. He's not going to die so early, he will be important. The Targaryens WILL rule again, whether it be Aegon, Dany, OR Jon (yes, I believe Jon to be the son of Rhaegar).
Long live Aegon Taragryen! True king of Westeros. [:


I've had enough of the Lannisters, especially Cersei. But they had it coming though with all of the deaths that happened.

I've had enough of the Lannisters, especially Cersei. But they had it coming though with all of the deaths that happened."
Pretty sure they will be. Watch the Emmy Game of Thrones Panel and you can see what Martin had to say. Unless he was lying, which I doubt lol. But yeah, pretty sure the Lannisters will be kicked off at one point. I mean, their power is crumbling anyways.

That being said, I have no objection against him claiming the throne. Jon Connington, again is right that he is fit to rule, all that we've read about him makes it clear that he is going to be a character not unlike Rhaegar himself which means perceptive, smart, strong, fair etc.
If the throne HAS to be taken by a Targaryen I really, really, really hope it's NOT Daenerys for many reasons (I can elaborate on that, but this poll's intent isn't that). If however Jon ends up being Rhaegar's and Lyanna's son, I wouldn't mind him taking the throne either, but from the looks of it he's very much like Ned, doesn't want anything to do with IT and is committed to night's watch. In case he survives and becomes Azor Ahai reborn, he would probably kick some white-walker ass and stay in night's watch. But in that case I wonder what's Bran's story going to unfold like, I mean he seems to be with the old god type of creatures now, and it doesn't seem like they're as ad as Melisandre makes them to be. If he dies, eh so be it, I've had time to come in terms with that.
So basically yeah, Aegon for king. Yaaay.
all discussions on this book
|
post a new topic