The Orion Team. discussion

THE SEVENTH FLOOR > What are the worst films based on books?

Comments Showing 1-10 of 10 (10 new)    post a comment »
dateDown arrow    newest »

message 1: by Samuel , Director (new)

Samuel  | 4692 comments Mod
Sometimes, when Hollywood gets its hands on a best-selling spy thriller, all goes well. But other times, it screws up royally and creates rubbish which does not remain faithful to the essence of the book its based on.

What are movies which you have seen, based on books which have made you shake your heads in anger at how far they depart from the quality of the source material?

message 2: by Samuel , Director (new)

Samuel  | 4692 comments Mod
To kick things off, White House Down and Olympus Has Fallen. Take the late Vince Flynn's Transfer Of Power, dump the entire cast of Flynn's characters, give the films ridiculous titles and go away from the original topic the book focused on (Islamist terrorists) The action was ok...I suppose. But both films were like fake Rolex watches compared to the source material.

message 3: by Unknown (new)

Unknown Auther | 1 comments The Hitman film was based on a game series but there were also novels. The film was terrible! It was just a action film shoot-em-up when Hitman is supposed to be a ghost

message 4: by Samuel , Director (new)

Samuel  | 4692 comments Mod
So true. At the end, he was just Rambo in an Hugo Boss suit, not the "silent assasin" from the games.

message 5: by Samuel , Director (new)

Samuel  | 4692 comments Mod
Patriot Games....Dear god it would have been a lot better if they had stuck with his Highness Prince Charles. And the major changes in the take down of the ULA....the book was in a different league.

message 6: by Barry (new)

Barry Sierer | 15 comments "Sum of All Fears". My favorite Clancy book, destroyed as a film. There is nothing quite so tragic as a good story told poorly.

message 7: by Samuel , Director (last edited Feb 18, 2014 10:19PM) (new)

Samuel  | 4692 comments Mod
Rewatched "Tinker Tailor Soldier Spy" and was aghast. For all the brilliant actors, it started with a bang and ended with a proverbial whimper and a boring climax.

message 8: by Samuel , Director (new)

Samuel  | 4692 comments Mod
The Dogs Of War Film. One of my favorite Frederick Forsyth books was demolished by so many unnecessary changes.

message 9: by Emily (new)

Emily | 3 comments The Bourne Trilogy. It hurt so much watching those films.

message 10: by Samuel , Director (last edited May 24, 2014 03:43PM) (new)

Samuel  | 4692 comments Mod
Taking Of Pelham 123 (2009) in which a group of gunmen stage a terrorist attack on the NY subway system ( Not the 1974 version which was brilliant) It's the ultimate case study on how a attempt to do a pragmatic adaption can blow up in the film makers face.

back to top