A Game of Thrones (A Song of Ice and Fire, #1) A Game of Thrones question


193 views
Game of thrones - Who would win in a fight?
Andytrop79 Andytrop79 (last edited Jul 27, 2013 04:17AM ) Jul 27, 2013 04:04AM
Ok we'll hopefully find in the series who is best placed to win the Game of Thrones, but who would win in a straight up one on one fight.
So the contenders i can think of are the hound, the mountain, jaime lannister, khal drogo, jorah mormont, grey worm, daario naharis, barristan selmy, brienne of tarth, bronn the sellsword, lord of bones, qhorin halfhand, jon snow, ned stark, syrio forel the dancing master or tyrion.



People who I think wouldn't make it to the final round:

Jaime -
fights cheaply

Jorah -
too in love with Khaleesi

Ned's Bastard -
he literally knows nothing

Fully Headless Ned -
Can't see him being a great warrior

The Maiden Fair -
Haven't gotten to her in the books, but in the show she seems wooden.

The Imp -
Needs Poderick too much


People who could possibly make it to the final round:

Bronn -
He`d need a cash incentive.

Clan Clegane -
Both are too wild and unpredictable.

Pretty Boy Daario & Grey Worm -
Don`t know much about these guys yet, but they seem skilled, so maybe.

Ser Barristan -
Getting old, but is goddamn world famous fighter.

My Sun and Stars -
Got a hella long braid for a reason.


The person who I think would win this fight:

Syrio Forel -

Swift as a deer. Quiet as shadow.
Fear cuts deeper than swords.
Quick as a snake. Calm as still water.
Fear cuts deeper than swords.
Strong as a bear. Fierce as a wolverine.
Fear cuts deeper than swords.

20232128
Ammar Syed meryn trant killed him easily...
Jul 26, 2014 04:42AM · flag

Gregor Clegane owns everybody in a melee. Guys like Jaime and Loras are more skilled swordsmen, but the physicals advantages of Clegane are enormous in the ASOIAF context. Only Sandor is a good match for him, but I believe he would ultimately lose as well.

Guys without armor like Drogo, Nahaaris, Grey Worm, Lord of Bones, Bronn or Syrio are easy work for him.

Ned, Jon, Mormont aren't skilled enough.

Barristan and the Half Hand are too old.

Tyrion...LOL.

The only character that could had a chance against Gregor is Arthur Dayne with Dawn. IMO of course.

4436497
Mweene I don't agree about the amour. Guys without it can be just as deadly. remember what Bronn did at the Vale. I think Nahaaris, Bronn and Syrio would be ...more
Nov 02, 2013 04:39PM · flag

Daenerys, but it would not be a fair fight, the dragons would jump in.


It might would be Syrio. Though I think that if you threw in Jaqhen (sp?) or Melisandre, they would win.


I totally agree! Syrio all the way.


Jaime Lannister "We Do Not Sow" or his classic one liner "Summer is here"


The Hound


You all forget the Blackfish, still alive and kicking.
In the north riverlands, could join the Cranogmen. Then north to join John Snow.


Goran (last edited Jul 27, 2013 04:35AM ) Jul 27, 2013 04:30AM   -1 votes
Hodor.

Jokes aside, starting this kind of threads for aSoIaF characters seems a bit pointless. It's not a superhero comic book.


back to top