Do you think Winnie was right or wrong for giving the immortal water to the toad instead of keeping it for the future?

[[deleted user]]

I think it was her opinion on doing it. It was her choice and her problem to choose what she would do with the water. I mean Jesse can't do that. Oh no he can't. This is a girl we are talking about, not a boy. So jesse back away from the girl or else.

[[deleted user]]

Was it right or wrong of Winnie to switch places with Mae so that the Tuck's could be safe?

[Katie]

I would like it if she had kept the water so that there could be an interesting sequel to the book.

I agree with @Nshera