The Throne of Fire question

My first thought is that Sadie might get a kinda superior attitude ( completely natural) and mess up then Annebeth would take the advantage and win. But it was super hard to decide because I love both of them

ANNABETH CHASE IS SO AMAZING!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! SHE WILL WIN

You HAD to make me decide... I am a hardcore percy jackson fan and I wish I could say Annabeth, but the hard truth is that Sadie is a magician with a goddess in her. So I reluctantly say Sadie. "I've betrayed camp half-blood! 'shoots himself'

hmmm.. well sadies the better fighter but annabeth may be able to outsmart her

SADIE!!!! With out a SINGLE doubt!

hard choice but I'm gonna have to go with annabeth cause i enjoyed PJO better and i love reading percabeth scenes... and i rally like athena and she's her daughter

I personally like Sadie over Annabeth.

Me, being a PJO fan would say Annabeth. But, then I considered the fact that Sadie does have her Egyptian whatnot and and I've decided...idk

Sadoe could beat Annabeth, but Annabeth would definitely outsmart Sade, and whatever Sadie did, Annabeth could use her brains.

They are both awesome in their own way, but have such different personalities that it's hard to compare them.

Sadie has a fun and witty sense of humor. She has a stubborn streak and likes poking fun at others... though she does know when to stop (usually. :D) Her strengths are helping her friends and channeling - and sometimes being able to resist - a goddess' power. However, Sadie really isn't a leader, and she's eager to support her brother's leadership.

Annabeth on the other hand is much more of a natural leader, and she's more serious and makes wiser decisions than Sadie. Unlike Sadie, she has trouble resisting power and often uses her wits more than anything else. She depends on Percy to give her hope and a much-needed smile when she gets too serious or a bit depressed, and helps her friends not too make impulsive decisions. However, Sadie is more like Percy in her sense of humor, decision making, and the fact that she relies on raw power (from Isis) to combat her enemies.

In other words, I love both of them, though for very different reasons! :D

Annabeth, definitely!

I think it would be quite close for the win, and I doubt they would ever find themselves in a fight, but I think Annabeth Chase would win.

annabeth all th e way i mean shes smarter shes better and shes got a hellhound on her side

Annabeth, because she is smarted, and is more experienced.
although sadie is great, she's very new, and she acts without thinking.

true dat

Annabeth all the way.
I was not thrilled with the Kane Chronicles, I even found some of it insulting. Not Riordan's strongest writing point. But when you right a masterpiece like the PJATO series, it would be rather hard to beat.
Not saying I hate the Sadie or anything. I just have read better books.

I'd have to say Annabeth. Sadie does have a goddess inside her but Annabeth is a child of Athena. Children of Athena our known for their battle plans and witty-ness(sp?) so I could totally see Annabeth during a fight trick Sadie and defeat her.

That would be a hilarious scene in a book but even though I like annabeth better Sadie would win

Gosh, this is a hard one. i like both girls' style. Both are definitely awesome. In an actual fight, i feel that Sadie would win with the firepower, but Annabeth would definitely win with sneakiness, cleverness, and just general being-more-smart. Don't get me wrong, Sadie's "bloody brilliant", but come on. this is ANNABETH we're talking about.

I think Sadie

My first reaction would be Annabeth, but Sadie does have a goddess inside her. That would give Annabeth a major disadvatige.

Annabeth!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Annabeth...duh

Annabeth!

Oh my goodness, this is an insanely hard choice. In a fight or overall awesomeness?

Annabeth, of course, I hate Saddie I don't know how people can stand her. And yes, maybe she is a powerfull Eye of Isis but Annabeth is the Daugher of Athena, the follower of the Mark what else do you want?

I like both of them.
Sadie definitely has more powers (maybe because she has a goddess inside her too)....but Annabeth too is equally capable. It is a hard choice.

Sadie definitely wins in a fight. Whichever girl is the more awesome depends on your definition of "awesome".

I like Annabeth but she has barely any powers whereas Sadie has magic on her side and can control the elements, blow up opponents, and even summon a concept such as "order". The other problem is that her best weapon, knowledge, is useless since she knows nothing about Egyptian magic and how it works.