The Serpent's Shadow
discussion
Which series did you like better: Kane, Heroes of Olympus, or Percy Jackson?
date
newest »
newest »
message 1:
by
[deleted user]
(new)
May 28, 2013 08:05AM
I think I liked Kane or Percy Jackson best but the Heroes of Olympus books are really good too (so far)!
reply
|
flag
Percy, or Hero's of olympus. Anything with Annabeth.
Percy Jackson, then Heroes of Olympus, then Kane
I seriously can't choose, I love them all, but I do think the Kane Chronicles should be longer!!! I would really enjoy that!
Hmmmmmm..... Tough one uhhhhhhhh..... I think I have to say PJO and HoO are tied for the best.
I like them all for diffrent resons. Heros of olympus for suspence, Percy jackson for the awsome chapter names and the start of it all and kane chronicals because it gives you a new mothology so much unlike the ones Rick has done in the past.
I like them all for diffrent resons. Heros of olympus for suspence, Percy jackson for the awsome chapter names and the start of it all and kane chronicals because it gives you a new mothology so much unlike the ones Rick has done in the past.
Celestina wrote: "I like them all for diffrent resons. Heros of olympus for suspence, Percy jackson for the awsome chapter names and the start of it all and kane chronicals because it gives you a new mothology so mu..."
Yeah, you get to learn a lot about the mythology in Kane
Yeah, you get to learn a lot about the mythology in Kane
I like Percy Jackson better because I'm not too familiar with Egyptian myth. Also, I think the Kane chronicle is much more confusing than Percy Jackson because of the god possessing human part. In Percy Jackson, if you were the children's of the gods, then you possess their power. in Kane chronicles, there is a god possessing human and that really threw me off.
I LOVED Percy Jackson and I LOVED heroes of Olympus. I didn't like the Kane chronicles. ): I am going to have to say heroes of Olympus is my favorite though. I LOOOOOOOOVE Heroes of Olympus!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
NO! three words: Kane Chronicles= Awesome. And no, the equal sign is not a word. Notice I called it a sign
~The Heroes of Olympus (cuz it still had a bit of Percy Jackson stuff) ~Percy Jackson
~Kane Chronicles
Alyssa wrote: "I seriously can't choose, I love them all, but I do think the Kane Chronicles should be longer!!! I would really enjoy that!"I totally agree. Rick riordan definitely should have added on at least one bk. I think I love the first PJ series just because it was the first, original series that Percy was featured in, and I think the best.
Percy Jackson, of course
Angel wrote: "Percy Jackson, of course"The first or second???
First, the second are alright I guess. Kane seems too dramatic and not real, I mean the way they act its not the way a 13 and 15 yrs old act
Cally wrote: "Alyssa wrote: "I seriously can't choose, I love them all, but I do think the Kane Chronicles should be longer!!! I would really enjoy that!"I totally agree. Rick riordan definitely should have ad..."
I think he should bring the Kane siblings to camp half blood and do a series with all of them together.
Kenneth wrote: "Cally wrote: "Alyssa wrote: "I seriously can't choose, I love them all, but I do think the Kane Chronicles should be longer!!! I would really enjoy that!"
I totally agree. Rick riordan definitely ..."
THAT WOULD BE SO AWESOME!!!!!
I totally agree. Rick riordan definitely ..."
THAT WOULD BE SO AWESOME!!!!!
definitely percy jackson, but the other two i havent read the newest books yet
definitely percy jackson! i have read PJO, HOO, Kane and percy is still my favorite character EVER!!
Percy Jackson is just...
...barely above Heroes of Olympus,while Kane Chronicals...
...is down here
...barely above Heroes of Olympus,while Kane Chronicals...
...is down here
Heroes of OlympusFirst read, first loved. Plus, Rick really improved as a writer by that second series. His scenes are better developed. Like, I just went back and read the Calypso scene in TBotL And I was like, THAT'S ALL!? HE SPENT TWO WEEKS WITH HER AND ALL YOU HAVE TO SAY IS THAT SHE AND HER ISLAND WERE PRETTY!? YE GODS! LEO'S SCENES HAD SO MUCH MORE DETAIL! YOU'RE KILLING ME!
Percy Jackson and Heroes of Olypus equally!Kane Chronicles...not so much, but they are still good books. Rick Riordan just sets his standards too high. XD
The Percy Jackson series started it all. What I would want to see is a Percy Jackson/Kane Chronicles mash up series. Imagine Sadie and Annabeth butting heads. Or Sadie and Clarissa. Reading Percy and Carter fight in Son of Sobek was hilarious.
Either The Percy Jackson series or Heroes of Olympus. The Kane Chronicles is great, but I think because I read the Percy stuff first and Greek/Roman mythology interests me more...
Percy Jackson, but I like The Heroes of Olympus. I really didn't enjoy the Kane Chronicles.
The Kane Chronicles were good, but they weren't the best. I like Percy Jackson and the Olympians best because it was the original and it was more of the action/adventure/mythology and nothing else. There is way too much romance in Heroes of Olympus and everybody is getting paired off. I don't mind a little bit of it, but I feel like that is the main focus of the series and not the actual war of the Giants. How many Giants have we seen in the first three books? Four. Five if Otis and Ephialtes were separate. Over how many chapters? Like two each. Just saying...
I like the Kane Chronicles better because they're Egyptian and I love Egyptian stuff. They are way more exciting than the "Olympus" books. They have way better characters than PJ and the olympians. I would like the Heroes of Olympus second.
(All thoughts, remarks, and comments, are in my own regard and not meant to reflect what everyone else should think about it; it would be fun though).Percy Jackson. The Kane Chronicles are close, The Heroes of Olympus are atrocious, but Percy Jackson was the first and the best. In my opinion!
Percy Jackson, or the Kane Chronicles(they both have Percy). Then the Kane Chronicles
I think first is Percy Jackson, then Kane Chronicles, then Heroes. They are all close though.P.S. You listed the Kane Chronicles twice, and it doesn't actually have Percy. Did you mean Heroes of Olympus?
percy jackson . END OF STORY
Kane Chronicles because they are more interesting and it is Egyptian. The characters in the Kane Chronicles are slot more nice than in the other series. I don't see why you all like Percy so much. He is a jerk! Compared to Carter or any character from the Kane Chronicles (except Sadie) he is too mean and full of himself!
Ooh I love Kane!!! And Heroes got progressively better. But I think I love PJo the best. They are all really close thought.
Hands down- The Heroes of Olympus series. And the reason is NOT just Percy Jackson- but because of EVERY Hero I met in this series!
I like Heroes of Olympus series second. Then the other one. Kane Chronicles are in my opinion the best!
THere aree 2 sereis of just percy jackson and greeks but Kane Chronicles spices it up. plu i really like the way of narrating. thou i will finnish blood of olympus because i want to then there will be a final veridect
The Kane Chronicles are best!Percy Jackson pales in comparison with the Kane Chronicles. Rick Riordan really matured in his writing by having two narrators (from different countries). It really shows off his skill as a writer.
Now you might be wondering why the Heroes of Olympus isn't at the top for this reason. Well, I haven't finished that series yet, so the verdict is still out.
The Kane Chronicles. I enjoyed it much more than Percy Jackson.
Heroes of Olympus because of Leo. then kane chronicles and then Percy Jackson
percy jackson, heroes of olympus, kane chronicles
all discussions on this book
|
post a new topic
