The One (The Selection, #3) The One discussion


1594 views
Team Maxon or Aspen

Comments Showing 151-200 of 500 (500 new)    post a comment »

message 151: by Meg (new) - added it

Meg Eilish Team aspen
Macon is a douche


message 152: by Meg (new) - added it

Meg Eilish Haha I meant maxon


message 153: by Night (new) - rated it 5 stars

Night Moose wrote: "Team aspen
Macon is a douche"


How is Maxon a douche?


message 154: by Meg (new) - added it

Meg Eilish Night wrote: "Moose wrote: "Team aspen
Macon is a douche"

How is Maxon a douche?"


Cause he claimed to be like eternally in love with her and shit, and then he was hooking up with Celeste


message 155: by Night (new) - rated it 5 stars

Night Moose wrote: "Night wrote: "Moose wrote: "Team aspen
Macon is a douche"

How is Maxon a douche?"

Cause he claimed to be like eternally in love with her and shit, and then he was hooking up with Celeste"


Oh and America wasn't hooking up with Aspen? pot calling kettle black much?


message 156: by yoongi (new) - rated it 5 stars

yoongi Night wrote: "Moose wrote: "Night wrote: "Moose wrote: "Team aspen
Macon is a douche"

How is Maxon a douche?"

Cause he claimed to be like eternally in love with her and shit, and then he was hooking up with Ce..."



I agree. Maxon and America both cheated on each other. (Sorta.) They made the same mistake. It's even now.


message 157: by Night (new) - rated it 5 stars

Night SORTA! HA!


message 158: by yoongi (new) - rated it 5 stars

yoongi Night wrote: "SORTA! HA!"

Well they didn't say they were together at that point.


message 159: by Night (new) - rated it 5 stars

Night GeekReader wrote: "Night wrote: "SORTA! HA!"

Well they didn't say they were together at that point."


But still it was a low point for me. America cheating with Aspen. Aspen putting her in danger then Maxon and Celeste. I could go on for hours about how Maxon and America screwed up.


message 160: by yoongi (new) - rated it 5 stars

yoongi Yes, I do agree with that.


message 161: by Ccl8989 (new)

Ccl8989 Moose wrote: "Team aspen
Macon is a douche"


haha yes


message 162: by Ccl8989 (new)

Ccl8989 Night wrote: "Moose wrote: "Night wrote: "Moose wrote: "Team aspen
Macon is a douche"

How is Maxon a douche?"

Cause he claimed to be like eternally in love with her and shit, and then he was hooking up with Ce..."


haha Aspen and America didn't hook up :)


message 163: by Night (new) - rated it 5 stars

Night Ccl8989 wrote: "Night wrote: "Moose wrote: "Night wrote: "Moose wrote: "Team aspen
Macon is a douche"

How is Maxon a douche?"

Cause he claimed to be like eternally in love with her and shit, and then he was hook..."


The hell they didn't well they got pretty close if they didn't hook up


Stacia Arielle Clair urgh. I feel totally mean saying this but this whole triangle has been a really ugly mess to be honest and I really hope that America actually deserves to end up with Maxon in the end of The One. I AM TEAM MAXON, but I feel like he deserves better than someone who is seeing someone else behind his back ya know. And Aspen. I don't hate the guy I really don't, he just loves America and first loves always stick with you but he just thinks of her the way she was before the selection and I guess doesn't really see that she's changed/changing and starting to have more faith/confidence in herself and Maxon is the best person to bring those traits out in her so if she does choose Aspen she'll just be a three and him a two. If she chooses Maxon and she actually deserves him at that point it'll be better for everyone involved including the united states of china. I hate Celeste with a vengeance and think that Kriss has ulterior motives too and yeah I definitely think the king knows more than he's giving away right now. but ultimately Maxon is by far the best character and America needs to get a grip and make a decision for once.


message 165: by Indy (last edited Jan 04, 2014 04:50PM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Indy I hope America ends up with Maxon because I think he brings out the best of her. I think Aspen holds her back. But I think in The One America won't really talk to Aspen in it because at the end of The Elite she basically said I choose Maxon. so yeah... If you can't tell by now I'm TEAM MAXON!! I can't wait for the book. All of our questions will be answered. Anyone else hope Kiera Cass writes about America being a princess if she get's picked?


message 166: by Meghan (new) - rated it 4 stars

Meghan MAXON!!!! :) Can't wait for The One!!!


Daelynleopard After I read all those comments I'm prepared that America will end up with Maxon... Hm. I have to think about it.
Well, probably it has to be Maxon 'cause he's the reason for the Selection. But I'd be really sorry for Aspen. I like him a lot. At least he's authentic. But that America can't find a solution confuses me, too. That's why I'm not sure which Team I'm in.


message 168: by Night (new) - rated it 5 stars

Night Daelynleopard wrote: "After I read all those comments I'm prepared that America will end up with Maxon... Hm. I have to think about it.
Well, probably it has to be Maxon 'cause he's the reason for the Selection. But I'd..."


I feel sorry for him I'm a maxon fan. But I like that he is willing to keep fighting, I hope he and America remain close friends by the end of it.


Almost Famous Author I swear to god, if America chooses Maxon I will die, come back to life, burn all the books and then die again!!! TEAM APSEN ALL THE WAY!!!


message 170: by Night (new) - rated it 5 stars

Night Almost Famous Author wrote: "I swear to god, if America chooses Maxon I will die, come back to life, burn all the books and then die again!!! TEAM APSEN ALL THE WAY!!!"

There is no possible way for them to happen. UNLESS Maxon acts the same way in book three. But America is to blame also.


message 171: by nessa (new) - rated it 5 stars

nessa cs Team Maxon I mean he understands America and wants to give her time for everything :D


message 172: by Night (new) - rated it 5 stars

Night Vanessa wrote: "Team Maxon I mean he understands America and wants to give her time for everything :D"

isn't America kind of selfish without knowing it?


message 173: by Ayesha (new) - added it

Ayesha There is a new book coming out about Aspen, maybe after reading it everyone's views will change about the ship. Maybe because we haven't really got to know Aspen that well. I'm still Maxon all the way!


message 174: by yoongi (last edited Jan 10, 2014 05:47PM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

yoongi Hard to believe all this started from one little comment.


message 175: by Night (new) - rated it 5 stars

Night one long thread it is!


message 176: by Katie (new) - added it

Katie I think it will almost certainly be Maxon. Think about it. Why would she spend three books to end up right back where she started? I mean, the government will change (come on now, it's dystopian, no one really thinks we'll end up with the castes at the end, right?) But there's no reason for her to spend three books thinking over everything, only to end up in the same relationship at the end. I personally don't like Aspen, but I can see both sides of the argument.


message 177: by Night (new) - rated it 5 stars

Night Katie wrote: "I think it will almost certainly be Maxon. Think about it. Why would she spend three books to end up right back where she started? I mean, the government will change (come on now, it's dystopian, n..."

Same here


message 178: by Riya (new) - added it

Riya I can't wait for the next book to come out.


message 179: by yoongi (new) - rated it 5 stars

yoongi Riya wrote: "I can't wait for the next book to come out."

Uhg, When will it come?!?! I need it now! Team Maxon!


message 180: by Night (new) - rated it 5 stars

Night GeekReader wrote: "Riya wrote: "I can't wait for the next book to come out."

Uhg, When will it come?!?! I need it now! Team Maxon!"


Maxon may not win or if it goes the same way as sever by Lauren de stefano. one of the main cast may die.


message 181: by Amy (new) - added it

Amy Lee I need more Maxon, now. A-s-a-p.
I like Aspens character, he's a sweet guy but fortunately, I'm supporting Maxon and I hope they get together officially and this cover is seriously leading me on because there better be a good ass wedding within that wonderful book.


message 182: by Night (new) - rated it 5 stars

Night Amy wrote: "I need more Maxon, now. A-s-a-p.
I like Aspens character, he's a sweet guy but fortunately, I'm supporting Maxon and I hope they get together officially and this cover is seriously leading me on b..."


Oh there will be but will it be America?
Maxon may be in danger in the last book and is left fighting for his life. please forbid it to be Aspen who is fighting for his life and America AGAIN strings Maxon along.


message 183: by Amy (new) - added it

Amy Lee Night wrote: "Amy wrote: "I need more Maxon, now. A-s-a-p.
I like Aspens character, he's a sweet guy but fortunately, I'm supporting Maxon and I hope they get together officially and this cover is seriously lea..."


That's true, inside im desperately hoping its America. I mean, I like Aspen and such but she shouldn't be going behind Maxon's back.


message 184: by Night (new) - rated it 5 stars

Night But can America say no to Aspen?


message 185: by yoongi (new) - rated it 5 stars

yoongi Night wrote: "But can America say no to Aspen?"
Maybe she'll say no to both of them! Team America! ( But in all seriousness, maybe she says no to both)?


message 186: by Night (new) - rated it 5 stars

Night GeekReader wrote: "Night wrote: "But can America say no to Aspen?"
Maybe she'll say no to both of them! Team America! ( But in all seriousness, maybe she says no to both)?"


it said in the that it'll almost be too late before she realizes something I wonder what it is?


message 187: by yoongi (new) - rated it 5 stars

yoongi Night wrote: "GeekReader wrote: "Night wrote: "But can America say no to Aspen?"
Maybe she'll say no to both of them! Team America! ( But in all seriousness, maybe she says no to both)?"

it said in the that it'..."


That she loves Maxon? Aspen? Something that has to do with the resistance?


message 188: by Night (new) - rated it 5 stars

Night GeekReader wrote: "Night wrote: "GeekReader wrote: "Night wrote: "But can America say no to Aspen?"
Maybe she'll say no to both of them! Team America! ( But in all seriousness, maybe she says no to both)?"

it said i..."


I'm hoping that it will be explained better. I also hope the Selection has NOT LASTED THREE BOOKS!


message 189: by Maria (new) - rated it 1 star

Maria I'm all for Team Maxon. Screw Aspen he's just there to screw up America + Maxon. I seriously think Aspen will go with that Celeste bitch cuz they're both so alike.


message 190: by Maria (new) - rated it 1 star

Maria Night wrote: "But can America say no to Aspen?"

Easy, she kinda already did


message 191: by Night (new) - rated it 5 stars

Night Mariah wrote: "Night wrote: "But can America say no to Aspen?"

Easy, she kinda already did"


When? I don't remember her making a decision throughout the Elite I love Aspen, I can't trust Maxon It drove me insane. Book two I feel made a disservice to America to me she came of kind of selfish. And I think who ever posted that this was Americas Selection was right on the mark. I hope the the Selection ends at the end of Chapter 1 in the next book. I'm a loyal fan to ms Cass. I know there is also fan-fiction but what was the point of the three books if all she does is go back to Aspen. I wonder will Maxon get wounded or something and that it will force her to see Maxon is the right guy for her.


message 192: by Maria (last edited Jan 17, 2014 09:14PM) (new) - rated it 1 star

Maria Night wrote: "Mariah wrote: "Night wrote: "But can America say no to Aspen?"

Easy, she kinda already did"

When? I don't remember her making a decision throughout the Elite I love Aspen, I can't trust Maxon It ..."


when she kind of snaps @ Aspen when he's talking to her after she was supposed to leave the Selection
you know: "Do you really want to get me by default?"~America
that fight
besides if you say you want to fight for someone, would you still secretly date the other guy?
Don't get me wrong- Aspen was a gr8 guy in the Selection, but in the Elite: he's just putting her in danger (Marlee nd woodwork scenario all over again but this time Maxon will be broken hearted
I know what ur talkin about the whole America's Selection thing- I think that something big has to happen~ wat im trying to say is that either Maxon/Aspen will die or will go with someone else
Not likely for Kiera cass to leave them single
To me rebel attack at the end of the book made her realize Maxon is the right guy for her...I dunno
America is bipolar: one second she's all for Aspen the next she goes with Maxon *this keeps repeating OVER and OVER again its kind girl make up ur mind all really NOPE she needs time, time, time ,time*
WOW- this a long re-reply
Plz Kiera Cass end the Selection in ch.1 of the One so we can see how America will change Illea

Imagine America doesn't win the Selection--*fkjakfjjakdjfal;djsf* the whole book would be useless


message 193: by Night (new) - rated it 5 stars

Night Mariah wrote: "Night wrote: "Mariah wrote: "Night wrote: "But can America say no to Aspen?"

Easy, she kinda already did"

When? I don't remember her making a decision throughout the Elite I love Aspen, I can't t..."


America continuously doubted herself in the Elite. If ASPEN is end game? ONE BOOK WOULD HAVE DONE! AND AS A WRITER I'd be disappointed in Ms Cass. Maxon has been hurt too many times because America needed more TIME TIME TIME! I think I screamed at the book. MAKE UP YOUR DAMNED MIND! I love the books though.


message 194: by Riya (new) - added it

Riya GeekReader wrote: "Team Maxon. [I do know, he was a dirtbag when he was with Celeste, and Aspen was her first, but Maxon, even though its not okay, she belongs with him.] Americas hold choose already. Maxon is sweet,..." I agree with you on this. Aspen broke it off just because he was embarrassed of America providing him with food. I thought that was ridiculous. I am glad that America found someone like Maxon that will treat her better than Aspen can ever do.


message 195: by Nat (new) - added it

Nat Team MAXON PLEASE


message 196: by Night (new) - rated it 5 stars

Night Aspen is her first love she needed TIME to get over him. I understand that but WHY A WHOLE BOOK? If the selection continues in the third book beyond chapter one. My review will NOT BE flattering.


message 197: by Leah (new) - rated it 5 stars

Leah Rhodes Casey wrote: "@lifeofred true I have a general rule with these triangles to always pick the second guy.. Because if you really loved the first one completely you never would've fallen for the second one in the f..."

That is sort of true with the Vampire Diaries because even after Elena has gone from Stefan and Damon MULTIPLE times, you still have no freaking idea who she will end up with at the end of the series. That love triangle was difficult to keep up with at times, and this one with America and Maxon and Aspen is so easy. Why would we have this whole Selection if she doesn't end up with the prince? It is a great plot device to get insight into this dystopian world, but it would feel like a HUGE WASTE to make a beautiful series and have America choose the obviously wrong guy. The Selection is pretty much built around America and Maxon's relationship. Aspen's presence at the castle still confuses me to no end. He is so frustrating. Team Maxon forever.


message 198: by Night (new) - rated it 5 stars

Night Leah wrote: "Casey wrote: "@lifeofred true I have a general rule with these triangles to always pick the second guy.. Because if you really loved the first one completely you never would've fallen for the secon..."

It truly is a GREAT IDEA for a dystopian society. America deserves to be queen. I like the idea of the monarchy. interesting. But I hope Maxon is not killed or hurt. But someone may be hurt. I have this feeling.


message 199: by Leah (new) - rated it 5 stars

Leah Rhodes Night wrote: "Leah wrote: "Casey wrote: "@lifeofred true I have a general rule with these triangles to always pick the second guy.. Because if you really loved the first one completely you never would've fallen ..."

Hopefully it is, like, Celeste or Kriss or Aspen. I heard something from Christine (polandbananasbooks) that maybe America's dad is in on the rebellion because after she told him about that book he just took off and she didn't see him (and the rebellion really likes dem books)


message 200: by Night (new) - rated it 5 stars

Night Leah wrote: "Night wrote: "Leah wrote: "Casey wrote: "@lifeofred true I have a general rule with these triangles to always pick the second guy.. Because if you really loved the first one completely you never wo..."

Only one part of the rebels. I think that her father is a former rebel and that he married her mother but when he saw how maxon was like America did in the selection I think he wants America and Maxon together as they can fix the country


back to top