The Sword and Laser discussion
This topic is about
Wool Omnibus
2013 Reads
>
Wool: Casting
date
newest »
newest »
message 1:
by
Dara
(last edited May 01, 2013 08:24AM)
(new)
-
rated it 3 stars
May 01, 2013 08:23AM
I normally don't cast too much when I read but I keep picturing Lucy Liu as Juliette. What about you guys?
reply
|
flag
Deputy Marnes = Sam Elliot
I totally agree with the Sam Elliot choice - every line I read by Marnes I saw him delivering it.
Don't know if you guys are aware of this but Ridley Scott has optioned the rights to Wool for a movie. Now that doesn't mean it will be made as many books get optioned and never see film but it does make me happy that if it does see the big screen that a big time director like Scott will be behind it.
I kept picturing Rashida Jones for Juliette.
Gregory wrote: "I kept picturing Rashida Jones for Juliette."From Parks and Rec? Lol. Juliette is a strong, action hero type. Jones is the romantic comedy type.
I like the general look of Sam Elliot for Marnes. But Elliot has a very tough presence, and Marnes is ultimately a weak character (maybe). Here are my picks:
Holston - Viggo Mortensen
Marnes - Jon Voight
Jahns - Helen Mirren
Juliette - Diane Kruger
Bernard - Phillip Seymour Hoffman
Lukas - James Mcavoy
Knox - Ron Perlman
Walker - Ian McKellan
Solo - Leo Dicaprio
Shirly - Amy Acker
It's maybe a bit too star-studded to be realistic, but hey, it's a fantasy casting.
Dara wrote: "I normally don't cast too much when I read but I keep picturing Lucy Liu as Juliette. What about you guys?"She's exactly who I pictured when I read Wool.
The book doesn't really offer a detailed description of Juliette, but it does say she has "bright eyes". Lucy has what I would call dark eyes. Not that that matters much; I mean, book descriptions have very little to do with actual movie casting.But I'm always amazed at how people ignore descriptions of characters in books when they imagine them. I was surprised at how much backlash there was from the casting of Rue in The Hunger Games. The actress perfectly fit the description in the book, but some people thought she was supposed to look different.
Stuart wrote: "The book doesn't really offer a detailed description of Juliette, but it does say she has "bright eyes". Lucy has what I would call dark eyes. Not that that matters much; I mean, book descriptions ..."I didn't take bright eyes to mean light in color but more of a sparkle/personality/look in the eye.
So, because I was curious, I asked Hugh Howey about his preferred Juliette casting on Twitter:
I would be totally psyched about the first two choices. I absolutely love Evangeline Lily. Can't wait to see her in The Hobbit.
Kathryn wrote: "Stuart wrote: "The book doesn't really offer a detailed description of Juliette, but it does say she has "bright eyes". Lucy has what I would call dark eyes. Not that that matters much; I mean, boo..."That's what I took it for as well. The other descriptor I remember is brown hair in a braid.
I really don't know why I pictured Liu. It just stuck.
Noomi Rapace would be awesome :)
Dara wrote: "I really don't know why I pictured Liu. It just stuck."Well, I think the skin color would be correct maybe. The book does say that she has a dark complexion, but that Jahns thought it might be as much from grease and grime as anything else.
Mod
Tim wrote: "Sean Bean should play Holsten - [spoilers removed]"That's mean. :-P But so true... :'( I love Sean Bean... but I'd love to for once see him LIVE through an entire movie...
If Sean Bean survived a film it's probably mean the end of the world as we know it.
Kathryn wrote: "Tim wrote: "Sean Bean should play Holsten - [spoilers removed]"That's mean. :-P But so true... :'( I love Sean Bean... but I'd love to for once see him LIVE through an entire movie..."
Stuart wrote: "Kathryn wrote: "Tim wrote: "Sean Bean should play Holsten - [spoilers removed]"That's mean. :-P But so true... :'( I love Sean Bean... but I'd love to for once see him LIVE through an entire movi..."
You are cruel. :'(
My most brillant pick was Maggie Smith (on Downton Abby - the dowager countess of Downton, Prof. McGonagall in the Harry potter films) for McLain, the Head of Supply. As a party game, I think you could cast all of Wool from the Downton Abby cast.On another note:
I imagained Zach Galifianakis as Solo.
Perhaps it was the Man-boy with the beard thing.
Charlise Theron was who I pictured for Julie.
Kathryn wrote: "Stuart wrote: "Kathryn wrote: "Tim wrote: "Sean Bean should play Holsten - [spoilers removed]"That's mean. :-P But so true... :'( I love Sean Bean... but I'd love to for once see him LIVE through..."
So, Maggie Smith, who is nearly 80, as the gun-totting, hard-as-nails, McLain, who (view spoiler). That's what you envision for DAME Maggie? Disgraceful! ;)
Lots of good suggestions here. Some I really like and some not so much. I'm not going to cast the whole thing, but here are a few of my picks. I think Charlize Theron could play Juliette in her sleep. She's played that type of character many times before. I'd probably go a little more outside the box and cast either Morena Baccarin or Moon Bloodgood there.
I love the idea of Ron Perlman as Knox. Perlman just makes almost everything he's in better.
For Bernard I'd pick Gary Oldman or Robert Carlyle. Both would be good there.
Lastly, I think for McLain, I might go with Pam Grier. I think she'd bring something interesting to the mix.
I like the idea of Pam Grier as McLain.
Galifiniakis is a good pick for Solo. I pictured Bernard as the guy who played Bernard on Lost. I wonder where that came from!
Man-boy Solo could be Jon K from the office. He always looked like a man child to me. For Bernard I'd want Kevin Spacey, he's so great at being heartless.
Something in the delivery given by the reader of the audio book version just automatically placed Jewel Staite as Jules for me.
David(LA,CA) wrote: "Something in the delivery given by the reader of the audio book version just automatically placed Jewel Staite as Jules for me."Even just reading the book I pictured Jewel Staite as Jules.
Had to google Jewel Staite (hey, it's been a long time since Firefly!), but yes that would work for me :)
hah! I was already picturing Evangeline Lily as Jules.
When reading I always pictured Erica Cerra from Eureka as Juliette. I think this has to do with the character she played in that show as much as anything.
Mod
Yup me too. In fact if anyone else ever plays her I will be disappointed that's how ingrained it got in my mind. It was the only casting my brain did to me actually.
Although Erica Cerra might do in a pinch.
I kept seeing Juliette as Bitsie Tulloch, probably because she plays a character called Juliette in Grimm. I can just so easily picture her tinkering with machines, somehow.
I don't know why, but listening to the latest podcast where they mentioned this thread triggered another casting choice for me:Paul Giamatti as Bernard.
Ooh, Paul Giamatti would be good as Bernard. He can be good at evil too.
for a second during the audio book the Juliette voice the narrator did sounded a little like Sarah Michelle Gellar to me, so for the rest of the book I kept picturing Buffy. I think it especially worked when she would threaten people.Although now that I see Erica Cerra mentioned she seems like she would be really good.
For me Juliette looked mostly like Meryl Streep. When she was in her 30s. Although I think Evangeline Lilly or Bitsy Tulloch would work for me too. I didn't like her on Lost, but that was mostly that I didn't really like her character. I find the concept of casting very interesting, because I never thought of books that way. I mainly tend to have a general idea and it's more about the way the person is than what he/she looks like. I notice a bias here that I didn't even think of anyone non-caucasian... But I think Lucy Liu for example would be a great choice, even if I wasn't imagining it when I was reading :)
From the moment it appeared I always pictured Robbie Coltrane as Knox. Maybe tinted from the physical similarities of the character to Harry Potter's Hagrid
Eve Miles (Welsh woman from torchwood) would be my choice for Juliette. A strong woman that you could picture getting dirty fixing machines and getting the job done.
Holston - Michael Fassbender (edit: actually Kevin Spacey... I read him as older in Book 1 then in Book 2 he seemed a lot younger because of Jahns & Marnes's perspective)
Jahns - Sally Field
Marnes - Kurt Russell
Jules - Mila Kunis
Bernard - Timothy Spall
Walker - John Hurt
Knox - Mickey Rourke
Lukas - Anton Yelchin
Scottie - Andrew Garfield
Jahns - Sally Field
Marnes - Kurt Russell
Jules - Mila Kunis
Bernard - Timothy Spall
Walker - John Hurt
Knox - Mickey Rourke
Lukas - Anton Yelchin
Scottie - Andrew Garfield
Nathan Fillion (another Firefly alum) would make a great Holsten.
Lena Headey for Juliette.
Stuart wrote: "So, because I was curious, I asked Hugh Howey about his preferred Juliette casting on Twitter"Here's the link if anyone wants to follow Howey, or retweet his response :)
https://twitter.com/hughhowey/status/...
The guy who plays Hagrid in Harry Potter as Knox.
Kat wrote: "Lena Headey for Juliette."Nooooo! (Runs away very quickly. ;-) )
I actually pictured Elizabeth Mitchell as Juliette (although that's probably due to Lost lol). Or maybe Jewel Staite (yeah it's the mechanic thing lol) Sam Elliot would be a good Marnes.
Galifinakis is a good Jimmy/Solo but he'd have to slim down in my opinion
Robbie Coltrane (Hagrid from HP) would be a good Knox
Not really an actor but I pictured Lukas as Goemon from Lupin the Third http://moe.animecharactersdatabase.co... with maybe more unkempt/spiky hair
