Twilight (The Twilight Saga, #1) Twilight discussion


1052 views
Anyone else wanted to punch Kristen Stewart in the face???

Comments Showing 1-50 of 118 (118 new)    post a comment »
« previous 1 3

message 1: by Madeline (last edited May 01, 2013 11:26PM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Madeline I HATED her acting in the movies, so I just stopped watching them. She is extremely UNEMOTIONAL-yeah sure Bella was supposed to be quiet and calm, but gawd Kristen always looked like she was constipated and awkward. (Note-I don't hate HER, just her eye-twitching-strange-random-noise-acting)


Gerd Did you consider talking to a doctor about this urge of yours to beat up constipated and/or awkward people?


Madeline Gerd wrote: "Did you consider talking to a doctor about this urge of yours to beat up constipated and/or awkward people?"

Well of course I didn't literally want to punch her in the face, I just get a tad over emotional/ exaggeration when it comes to commenting -_-


message 4: by [deleted user] (new)

I agree though. Kristen Stewart did make Bella look like a socially akward person and almost ruined the character and attitude that Bella was meant to have.


message 5: by Gabby (last edited May 01, 2013 02:33AM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Gabby Hehe, have you watched New Moon in 2x fast forward. She blinks SO MUCH! But I don't hate her. They could have found a better Bella, but I like her as a person.


Yesenia I wonder what they saw in her to make them cast her...


Casey Yesenia wrote: "I wonder what they saw in her to make them cast her..."

I wonder that every time I watch the movies!!! Surely there was a better choice.


Mirkat Poor girl only has one facial expression. With all her Twilight money, you'd think she could afford to buy a few more. ;)


Madeline Mirkat wrote: "Poor girl only has one facial expression. With all her Twilight money, you'd think she could afford to buy a few more. ;)"

HAHAHAHAHAAH, If only lolol


Isabelle Yeah. I think it was mostly because of jealousy, and the fact that she cheated on Rob with a married guy.


Sylvia (Van Peebles) Fulmer I wanted to punch Bella in the face when I was reading the book. She's just annoying. I think Kristen plays her very well. The movies were really bad.


Siobhan Honest trailers, just the stares:

http://youtu.be/TpU5O_Uur_c

#justsaying


message 13: by Angelique (new)

Angelique fernandez it's true she looks constipated and uncomfortable all the time! hahaha I thought I was the only one.


message 14: by Neon (new) - rated it 4 stars

Neon I want to punch her all the time. Sure she is pretty but her expressions are royally Moronic.


message 15: by [deleted user] (new)

I completely agree. Possibly another actress could have portrayed Bella better


message 16: by Lu (new) - rated it 2 stars

Lu I dont like Bella, but I feel sorry for her, Kirsten was the worst option. Seriosly what is wrong with her?


Rachel  (APCB Reviews) My teacher says that Kristen Stewart looks like "she is always on drugs." I think that she can't act at all. My favorite scenes from the movies are when Bella is freaking out like when Edward says he is leaving Forks; Bella goes hysterical and it's hilarious to watch her sputter and shake her head and widen her eyes and look like she has seizures (caused by her bad acting). She and Bella are alike in that they are both stupid and make incredibly rash decisions.


message 18: by [deleted user] (new)

I think that if a different actress had played Bella then she could have been portrayed as the strong cheeky and loyal woman that many people believe she was in the book.


message 20: by Ree (last edited May 01, 2013 02:07PM) (new) - rated it 3 stars

Ree Yes! And I thought it got even worse as the movies proceeded.

Everything Wrong With Twilight In 6 Minutes Or Less:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ghPsLc...

This is hilarious!


Siobhan Reese wrote: "Yes! And I thought it got even worse as the movies proceeded.

Everything Wrong With Twilight In 6 Minutes Or Less:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ghPsLc...

This is hilarious!"


I love that, and bad lip reading, but everything wrong is great ... You think it's over, but then you get three minutes of stupid noises Kristen Stewart makes.


message 22: by Neha (new) - rated it 5 stars

Neha This is the best twilight discussion that I have answered on. And it is exciting to know that so many people just loathe her because I hated her from the moment I saw her face on the first twilight book. So yes, I do feel like punching her face and then cutting it off and then burning it on fire so that she never rebrands again. UGH! How much Ijust hate her!!!


Carolynne I don't completly hate her. But i just think she could've put A LOT more emotion into her acting because it was extremly dull and i got so bored!


message 24: by QR (new) - rated it 4 stars

QR Haha I wrote an article about this ages ago, I think it's still pretty relevant.

Here's why I don't think Kristen is a bad Bella:
http://puffcritique.blogspot.ca/2012/...


Hayley Completely. Constantly. Does not do Bella justice at all.


Noodles .... I feel sorry for Kristen.

I have absolutely no love for her acting and really disliked them choosing her for the Snow White movie, but saying you loathe and hate her? The over the top insults? Saying you want to hurt her? And saying you're joking doesn't make it any better. I mean think about this for a second. You're suggesting physical violence against another human being because you don't like the way they act. Not because they said or did something horrible, but because they didn't portray a character in a way that you saw fitting. Does that sound stable to any of you? Esp you Neha get therapy nothing about your post suggests a healthy state of mind joking or not.

It's perfectly fine to have criticisms about an actress, but keep in mind that is a person you're talking about. She's a human being. She does have feelings and while she may not see some small thread on a random book review site it doesn't give anyone the right to act so petty and barbaric. It doesn't give you the green light to stop acting like a decent human being.


message 27: by Nirodha (new) - added it

Nirodha I despise the Twilight Saga book & film version XD


Madeline Neha wrote: "This is the best twilight discussion that I have answered on. And it is exciting to know that so many people just loathe her because I hated her from the moment I saw her face on the first twilight..."

wooaahh there buddy boy kinda crossing over the line into scary


Siobhan Olivia wrote: "Madeline wrote: "Neha wrote: "This is the best twilight discussion that I have answered on. And it is exciting to know that so many people just loathe her because I hated her from the moment I saw ..."

I don't think cheating is cool ...


Lyserg You should watch snow white and the huntsman....for a second I was confused because I swear, I felt like I was watching Bella Swan all over again! **groan**


Noodles No cheating isn't cool. However again she is a person. She does make mistakes and her entire worth shouldn't hinge on that one just because her dirty laundry is more out there then a normal persons is. Not saying she's a great person, I don't know enough about her, but if cheating once is the worst thing she's ever done she's already doing better then 50% of the human race.


message 32: by QR (new) - rated it 4 stars

QR I think the married guy who cheated on his wife with a girl much younger than himself is more of a scumbag than Kristen... Just my opinion though.


message 33: by Rai (new) - rated it 5 stars

Rai Yep Yep!!!!!


message 34: by [deleted user] (new)

I didn't care.

Bad characters portrayed by bad actors never upset me. Only when good characters are portrayed by bad actors do I become annoyed.


message 35: by R. (last edited May 02, 2013 06:46PM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

R. Madeline wrote: "I HATED her acting in the movies, so I just stopped watching them. She is extremely UNEMOTIONAL-yeah sure Bella was supposed to be quiet and calm, but gawd Kristen always looked like she was consti..."

I agree with you :/ I don't hate her... just her acting in those movies... Another thing that really annoyed me that she'd do was that little stutter... "Edward y- you can't leave me." "N-n-no!" -.-


Keiley Kirsten Stewart was terrible in the Twilight movies--because she was told that was how she was meant to act. Trust me when I say that she isn't a terrible person, and she's acted beautifully in other movies.


Jessica I love this conversation. Btw, you are not the only one who wanted to pucn Kristen Stewert in the face!!


Noodles Keiley wrote: "Kirsten Stewart was terrible in the Twilight movies--because she was told that was how she was meant to act. Trust me when I say that she isn't a terrible person, and she's acted beautifully in oth..."

Has she been in anything really other then Twilight and Huntsman? I really hate judging her acting on only two films that probably would have been weak with or without her.


Jonida Noodles wrote: "Keiley wrote: "Kirsten Stewart was terrible in the Twilight movies--because she was told that was how she was meant to act. Trust me when I say that she isn't a terrible person, and she's acted bea..."

I have seen some Indies with her in it and she has exactly the same expression on the whole time. It is sooooooo annoying. The girl needs some classes badly.


On the other hand Robert has been great in all the other roles he has played, so it is totally Kristen.


So disappointing that both Meyers' books have turned into very lame movies.If I was an author I would learn the lesson from the first and be hands on in the second.


iamjenai Madeline wrote: "I HATED her acting in the movies, so I just stopped watching them. She is extremely UNEMOTIONAL-yeah sure Bella was supposed to be quiet and calm, but gawd Kristen always looked like she was consti..."

lol yeah that was I thought too. she only has 1 expression in all of her movies... like you said looking constipated LOL hahaha


iamjenai Lord wrote: "You should watch snow white and the huntsman....for a second I was confused because I swear, I felt like I was watching Bella Swan all over again! **groan**"

and you have to watch that alien something movie of hers and her first movie I've seen was the Panic room... same emotions... same loook..


iamjenai Noodles wrote: "Keiley wrote: "Kirsten Stewart was terrible in the Twilight movies--because she was told that was how she was meant to act. Trust me when I say that she isn't a terrible person, and she's acted bea..."

and you have to watch that alien something movie of hers and her first movie I've seen was the Panic room... same emotions... same loook.. that's four movies now for me..


message 43: by Sindy (last edited May 03, 2013 01:53AM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Sindy I can totally see why poeple didnt like Kristen in twilight but what I DIDNT like most was her inability to use a kechup bottle....seriously you should watch the twilight bloopers. She tries and tries till the director just decided to take the scene without her having done it. Another was how they apparently said her voice would sound like an angel....hers sounded like a suffocated bird...JUST KIDDING BUT REALLY IT WAS BAD.


oh and I absolutely LOVE Kristen


Siobhan Noodles wrote: "Keiley wrote: "Kirsten Stewart was terrible in the Twilight movies--because she was told that was how she was meant to act. Trust me when I say that she isn't a terrible person, and she's acted bea..."

Panic room when she was twelve, adventureland ... There must be more but they're the only ones I know of. Check her profile on imdb.

I bought adventureland, because of Jesse eisenberg, but it is horrible, really freaking terrible. It went to the local trade in shop pretty fast ... And I'm the girl who has every dodgy film Jake Gyllenhaal ever made.


Elena They should have chosen a better actress. Kristen Stewart just doesn't seem like the Bella in the books.


message 46: by [deleted user] (new)

YOU ARE MY SISTER!!!!!!!!!!!!!
I was wondering who agreed with me. But no, every1 was like, Kristin this and Kristin that!


message 47: by Amber (last edited May 03, 2013 12:14PM) (new) - rated it 3 stars

Amber iamjenai wrote: "Lord wrote: "You should watch snow white and the huntsman....for a second I was confused because I swear, I felt like I was watching Bella Swan all over again! **groan**"

and you have to watch tha..."


I sooooo agree with you. Makes me grimace every time I see her! Why does she have to act like that in every movie that I see her in?


message 48: by Bee (new) - rated it 1 star

Bee Personally, I think Kristen Stewert is a good actor. Stephanie Meyer just doesn't know how to properly develop characters. All of her characters have the same constipated look on their faces. The only one with any emotion really showing is Alice. Think of they way that she depicted the characters in the book and all they did was made them act the same way in the movie.


Yesenia I personally liked Billy Burke, he plays Charlie Swan. Out of all of them his acting felt natural


message 50: by Bee (new) - rated it 1 star

Bee Most of them are good actors, it's the author and how they portray them is what makes the characters so awkward.


« previous 1 3
back to top