The Flashman Club discussion

41 views
Main > FLASHMAN UNDER FIRE!

Comments Showing 1-11 of 11 (11 new)    post a comment »
dateUp arrow    newest »

message 1: by Jasper (new)

Jasper Speedicut | 1 comments Flashman fans should be aware that a book published today (The Speedicut Papers: Book 1 - Flashman's Secret) debunks the entire Flashman legend. Apparently he was a remittance man in Paris and did none of the the things he claimed in The Flashman Papers. It's pretty compelling stuff...


message 2: by Robert (new)

Robert Jr. (robpeecher) | 1 comments Looked for it. Can't find it.


Adrian (magicrat) (magicrat) | 35 comments Thanks for the info - £8 for the Kindle is a bit steep for my tastes though :)

Robert - Speedicut Papers


message 4: by Djb (new)

Djb | 286 comments All these pale imitations are coming out and they won't countenance my homage to the 'real' thing !


message 5: by Djb (new)

Djb | 286 comments Hmm, 'The Speedicut Papers' . Just seen a review from The Times of this from Monday (April 1st). Written by 'Thomas Arnold', with quotes from Prof Elspeth Morrison and Prof Thomas Hughes it's an April Fool's joke. My only excuse is that it wasn't April 1st when I saw it !


Adrian (magicrat) (magicrat) | 35 comments :)

Is there a online link to the review??
I'd like to read it.


message 7: by Djb (new)

Djb | 286 comments Adrian (magicrat) wrote: ":)

Is there a online link to the review??
I'd like to read it."


Probably behind the papers paywall. I've got the hard copy - I will scan it and upload it sometime. It isn't really all that good, tbh.


Adrian (magicrat) (magicrat) | 35 comments Djb wrote: "Adrian (magicrat) wrote: ":)

Is there a online link to the review??
I'd like to read it."

Probably behind the papers paywall. I've got the hard copy - I will scan it and upload it sometime. It i..."


That'd be good if it's not too much hassle.

Reminds me of the reports when the original Flashman was published.


message 9: by Djb (new)

Djb | 286 comments Adrian (magicrat) wrote: "Djb wrote: "Adrian (magicrat) wrote: ":)

Is there a online link to the review??
I'd like to read it."

Probably behind the papers paywall. I've got the hard copy - I will scan it and upload it so..."


Oh, you will see the similarity !


message 10: by Djb (new)

Djb | 286 comments Djb wrote: "Adrian (magicrat) wrote: ":)

Is there a online link to the review??
I'd like to read it."

Probably behind the papers paywall. I've got the hard copy - I will scan it and upload it sometime. It i..."


I'll mail it to you. Not able to scan it for the moment.


Adrian (magicrat) (magicrat) | 35 comments Thanks - got it.

Quite fancy a read of this now. If anyone reads it can they let us know what their thoughts are.


back to top