twilight lovers! discussion

326 views
Members > Survey for those who have read all 4 Books

Comments Showing 1-50 of 75 (75 new)    post a comment »
« previous 1

message 1: by [deleted user] (new)

1. Which book/s do you think is the best of the series and why? worst and why?
2. If you found out that your true love was a Vampire, but s/he didn't drink human blood, how would you react?
3. Why did you first think that Rosalie didn't like Bella?
4. If you were a Vampire, and you were as rich as the Cullens, what would you spend you're time doing??
5. In the books, they talk about Carlisle as the leader and example to the rest of the family. If you were in his place, what would your reaction be when Edward told you Bella was pregnant??
6. Would you be able to be in Leah's place in a pack full of guys, with all your thoughts out there for every one to here?
7. What would you say made Edward take the chance of changing Bella when he believed that it would condemn her soul to hell?
8. If you were in Bella's position, who would you choose-- Your childhood friend Jacob, or the outrageously gorgeous- but deadly dangerous Vampire- Edward?? Why??


message 2: by I ♥ Luke Castellan *Alexa*, and Twilight! (new)

I ♥ Luke Castellan *Alexa* (i_love_jacob_black_95) | 3164 comments 1. Best... Twilight. That's one of the few I've read, but its the best so far.

2. I would be SOO happy, and love him forever.

3. Because she was an idiot.

4. Traveling!

5. I would probably flip slightly, but try and take care of the situationg.

6. No. Not at all. I'd die.

7. He wanted to be with her forever, and he knew if she died, he'd have to die also.

8. Jacob, because he's more of my type of guy, and has great personality.


message 3: by liz (new)

liz (liza123) | 17 comments 1.twilight because it has a lot of action and romance.

2.i would be scared and happy at the same time.

3.because they sounded like two different people.

4.shopping!

5.i would freak out!

6.no i would also die.

7.he loved her and he wouldn't live without her.

8.Jacob because he has been with me my whole life


message 4: by [deleted user] (new)

1. Eclipse. I'm not a HUGE fan of Jake, but I was glad that she had that friendship with him.
2. Well, assuming I didn't pass out, I'd be fine with it. Well, I'd probably not talk to them for a week, but then I wouldn't shut up. But you can't trust me with a secret like that. I'd run home and tell my mom and best friend.
3. Because Bella was getting all the attention
4. Changing my name and writing many books and becoming a famous author over and over again.
5. Dude, totally not possible, but let's say you're right... THEORIES!!
6. Nope. No can do.
7. I don't understand the question.
8. lol, can I pick a third person??? I'd totally be putting Alice and Edward together and be snatching Jasper.



message 5: by Mindi (new)

Mindi Poelwijk (mindip) 1. Best = Eclipse and Breaking Dawn b/c they had the most action. Worst = New Moon although the book was necessary to introduce the wolves and the relationship between Jacob and Bella, I found the book rather depressing and sad. Even the action at the end wasn't great.
2. I'd be thrilled.
3. Because Bella was a threat to the family.
4. Oh man, what wouldn't I do?
5. Assuming I knew everything Carlisle did, I would be panic.
6. Heck no
7. She would die otherwise.
8. EDWARD b/c he is dangerous.


message 6: by Lorna (new)

Lorna 1. Twilight was the best - the tension between Edward and Bella was exciting. Worst...Breaking Dawn - but I still liked it. It just seemed too far-fetched, like she was trying too hard.
2. I'd check myself (and him) into the nearest mental clinic
3. I thought she was jealous of Edward.
4. Travelling, exploring the world and different cultures.
5. Similar, I think. I'd research like mad to see how I could keep Bella AND the baby alive
6. I would, yes. I dont have much to hide.
7. The fact that she was dead! And he (selfish bastard) couldnt live withoutn her. And she made him promis!
8. Edward - but only because I dont want his blood on my hands. The psyco would probable end up killing himself again.
Oh and Jacob is young and strong, and could heal easier. AND Edward is so much hotter ;)


message 7: by Michelle (new)

Michelle (michellerobins) 3. in twilight when she was being a jerk to bella and didnt keep a secret of it

7. considering her back had just been broken and if he didnt change her, she would have died... that answer's kinda simple...

8. techincally, if you caught that small detail, bella didnt know jacob as a childhood friend, that was part of the movie...


message 8: by Lorna (new)

Lorna I thought they used to go fishing etc..together? When they were like, REALLY little when she went to Forks on the school holidays...


message 9: by I ♥ Luke Castellan *Alexa*, and Twilight! (new)

I ♥ Luke Castellan *Alexa* (i_love_jacob_black_95) | 3164 comments Yep.


message 10: by I ♥ Luke Castellan *Alexa*, and Twilight! (new)

I ♥ Luke Castellan *Alexa* (i_love_jacob_black_95) | 3164 comments Michelle wrote: "3. in twilight when she was being a jerk to bella and didnt keep a secret of it

7. considering her back had just been broken and if he didnt change her, she would have died... that answer's kind..."


In the movie they were childhood friends. Jake says:
"Remeber, we used to make mud pies together?"
then Bella says:
"Yeah, no I remeber."


message 11: by Maryann (new)

Maryann (uorgirl) | 35 comments 1. For me, I really enjoyed Twilight because it was so fresh and kept you wanting more. I honestly don't think any of them are bad at all.
2. It would probably make me want to be perfect looking too...lol.
3. Well, she really didn't. She thought that Edward and Bella were going to end badly and they would all have to move away.
4. I would be more like Edward than anyone else. I mean, I am a nerd at heart, so I would be as well read and educated too.
5. I think it would be the same only because it was something that they never heard of. The worry would be natural.
6. I don't think so. I know it must have been hard on her. And, I think she made up for that with her attitude.
7. I think what did it beside the fact that he loved her so much, was that it was her choice.
8. Edward...DUH!!! I mean, I would have Alice to dress me constantly!!!




message 12: by Michelle (last edited Apr 10, 2009 05:02PM) (new)

Michelle (michellerobins) C-A-M-P-F-I-R-E-S-O-N-G SONG! *Alexa* wrote: "Michelle wrote: "3. in twilight when she was being a jerk to bella and didnt keep a secret of it

7. considering her back had just been broken and if he didnt change her, she would have died... t..."


well, yeah, but that was in the movie. in the book they didnt know each other. she knew jacob's sisters, but he wasnt born then/yet, so she couldnt have known him.

unless we're specifically referring to the movie? in which case, i missed that memo...


message 13: by Sella (new)

Sella Malin Michelle wrote: "C-A-M-P-F-I-R-E-S-O-N-G SONG! *Alexa* wrote: "Michelle wrote: "3. in twilight when she was being a jerk to bella and didnt keep a secret of it

7. considering her back had just been broken and if..."


Actually, I recall that Jacob and Bella DID know each other in their childhood IN THE BOOK-- but Jacob was so young back then that Bella doesn't remember him, only his sisters.



message 14: by Sella (last edited Apr 13, 2009 10:57PM) (new)

Sella Malin Britty wrote: "1. Which book/s do you think is the best of the series and why? worst and why?
2. If you found out that your true love was a Vampire, but s/he didn't drink human blood, how would you react?
3. Wh..."


1. Best= Breaking Dawn, because it was the most exciting. Worst= Eclipse, because Jacob was being a jerk.

2. At first, I would probably be freaked out. Then I'd get use to it, I guess.

3. I think that Rosalie didn't like Bella at first because she was jealous of Bella- jealous that she was a human, jealous that Edward wanted her and not Rosalie.

4. I would buy the Bookstore and own it. Then read all I wanted :D Plus I would WRITE A LOT!!! And go to as many shows and concerts as I wanted. :D

5. First I would be shocked...then maybe I'd be understanding.

6. Definitely not. I need my privacy, thank you very much.

7. Um, the fact that if he didn't change her she'd DIE!!! I think that was a pretty easy decision, don't you? Death or vampirism?

8. If I was Bella, I would choose Jacob. Just because I think he's so sweet and funny and hot. But Edward is cool too; I don't care, either one, really. :D


message 15: by [deleted user] (last edited Apr 28, 2009 01:40PM) (new)

1. Best=NEW MOON!!!!! JACOB WAS THERE AND NOT EDWARD!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
2. I would go into shock....then I'd start asking questions.
3. I thought she didn't like humans.
4. I would buy all the books I liked...then I'd read them.
5. I'd be like, I thought you said she was too breakable.
6. NEVER!!!!! I'D BE SO UPSET!!!!!!!!!
7. The fact that she was about to die.
8. Jacob. Edward always over reacts to everything. Jacob just finds a way to get over it.


♥{Miranda!®}♥  (bella) 1. Best= Twilight, that's were it all starts!

2. *blankly stare*, lol then ask him to change me into one!

3. First impression was that she was jealous, cuz you know how her and Edward were "ment to be"

4. i would learn a ton of musical instruments, and go to a lot of good concerts!

5. I would be worried, and tell them to come back home so I could take a look at Bella.


6. It would be hard, but i usually ask guys advise, so i'd be fine

7. That's what his true love wished for, he'd do anything for Bella!

8. I HATE THIS QUESTION! I WANT THEM BOTH!!! Probably Edward, for one Jacob didn't imprint on Bella, so there goes that relationship, lol. Edward is very romantic, and understanding. Jacob is a good friend, someone that's dependable that you can rely on keeping your deepest, darkest secrets, you go to him for everything even when Edward and you are going thru tough times, *cough, cough... New Moon*


message 17: by Payge (new)

Payge (wannabeBellaCullen619) | 3 comments 1. Breaking Dawn... because Edward is incredibly romantic in it. New Moon... Edward was no in it and Bella was really strange.
2.I would be a little scared in the beginning but then i would get over it and love them... eventually i would aske to be turned into a vamp.
3.I thought Rosalie just had a stick up her bum and wasn'tused to anyone else getting attention.
4. I would spend time in school and then i would travel the world.\
5.I would try to be calm buti am not like carlisle and would probably be very mad and tell Edward to deal with it himself.. i would eventually cave in and help them though.
6. sort of because the werewolves are all hot but i would miss my privacy because i dont think Quil and Seth would let me live the crush i have on them down.
7.love, i think Edward knew that he wouldn't be able to watch her die and also she was pregnant and would die very young which would ruin edwards point of long life so why not.
8. Edward because he loves Bella with such intensity that no one could ever hurt her when Jacob is hurting her and deosnt give personal space.


message 18: by [deleted user] (new)

1. Breaking dawn was the best book in my opinion, it had more action.

2. I would be slightly wary, but i would get over it and love him, and then be asked to be turned into a vamp, to make us both more comfortable.

3. I thought it was jealousy because Rosalie wanted Edward and couldn't understand why Bella was able to earn a place in his heart so easily. She just had some issues.

4. I would get a proper education, travel the world, anfind the one I truly love and then do everything humans want to do (crazy stuff like jump off mountains and skydive and wooooohoo)

5. I would think abotu how it was possible, and then i would hepl them.

6. I would kind of mind because they are guys, and i am a girl, they wouldn't let me live it down if i had a crush on em.

7. love, mostly becuase he did it because he couldnt see her suffer and die.

8. Edward, because he is so much in love with her he wont let anything hurt her, while jacob acts more human and cant help himself if he hurts her feelings.








message 19: by Faith (new)

Faith | 84 comments 1. Which book/s do you think is the best of the series and why? worst and why?

Best was Eclipse because I loved the whole who will she choose storyline. Especially during the camping scene. Worst: Breaking Dawn as i really didn't like the pregnancy storyline with Edward becoming near enough a forgotten character and the whole fight scene that never happened.

2. If you found out that your true love was a Vampire, but s/he didn't drink human blood, how would you react?

I think I would be fine with it to be honest considering their eating habits

3. Why did you first think that Rosalie didn't like Bella?

Mostly jealousy over Bella, and I thought it was possible that she was worried about her family being exposed.

4. If you were a Vampire, and you were as rich as the Cullens, what would you spend you're time doing??

I would spend my time in a bar all day- i would say Theme Parks but then the sun is a problem with being exposed and all....

5. In the books, they talk about Carlisle as the leader and example to the rest of the family. If you were in his place, what would your reaction be when Edward told you Bella was pregnant??

I would be completely freaked out, and would try and find out how it could possibly happen. I don't think I would initially try and help out, i would probably agree more with Edward.

6. Would you be able to be in Leah's place in a pack full of guys, with all your thoughts out there for every one to here?

I wouldn't want to be a warewolf in the first place and i personally think no matter who you are, you wouldn't really want your thoughts out there for all to hear.

7. What would you say made Edward take the chance of changing Bella when he believed that it would condemn her soul to hell?

I think he had no other choice. He was going to lose the girl he loved, had waited for his entire life. If he didn't he would never see her again, at least if he did Bella would still be alive.

8. If you were in Bella's position, who would you choose-- Your childhood friend Jacob, or the outrageously gorgeous- but deadly dangerous Vampire- Edward?? Why??

I really don't like Jacob in that way, he's immature and pushy etc etc so i would choose Edward everytime. But i can understand why people are attracted to the whole "Childhood friend". He was there for her when Edward left...however Edward is SOOOOOO much better looking, mature, appreciative and the list goes on!





Charlotte (Buried in Books) 1) Twilight is the best, such a beautiful love story. Breaking Dawn is my least favourite, the story lacked something although it did tie things up nicely, I wanted more vampire action.

2) If we truely loved each other it wouldn't matter.

3) She didn't want anything to threaten her perfect setup. She'd never seen Edward like that before and she expects everything to stay the way she wants it.

4) Reading, well I wouldn't have to work would I?

5) "I'll support you whatever you want to do (where would you like to bury your wife, because if we don't change her chances are she'll end up six feet under)"

6) No, I'm not enough of a tomboy.

7) Love, he couldn't live without her, he knew it was something she ultimately wanted. I loved that it was Edward that changed her.

8) Edward, when you're in love, you're in love. Vampire love is a strong thing, in more ways than one. Anyway Jacobs imprinted, so he's off the market in any case.


message 21: by Nicole (new)

Nicole (2dogcrazy) 1. Breaking Dawn
2. I would freak out at first, but since he didn't drink human blood I guess I would be okay with it.
3. I think she was jealous because Bella was a human and what Rosalie wanted more than anything was to be a human and then Bella wanted to become a vampire.
4. I would READ!
5. I would freak, and then I would try to help Bella.
6. NO!
7. Because it was what she really wanted to do. And also it was what he really wanted her to do too, but he didn't want her to have to live as a vampire.
8. EDWARD!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!



message 22: by Sherry (new)

Sherry (ninneschong) 1. Which book/s do you think is the best of the series and why? worst and why? Tough call. My favorite might have to be New Moon. My least favorite... a tie between Eclipse and Breaking Dawn. Both had issues for me.
2. If you found out that your true love was a Vampire, but s/he didn't drink human blood, how would you react? If vampires are "real" then I would have to treat it like disease or something. If vampires aren't real and he just "thinks" he is, I am so outta there.
3. Why did you first think that Rosalie didn't like Bella? Because she was human.
4. If you were a Vampire, and you were as rich as the Cullens, what would you spend you're time doing?? Probably not repeating high school over and over. (I love how Edward calls it Purgatory in Midnight Sun.)
5. In the books, they talk about Carlisle as the leader and example to the rest of the family. If you were in his place, what would your reaction be when Edward told you Bella was pregnant?? I don't know. In my head, Carlisle was the head of the family because he was best equipped to deal with the decisions and be the voice of reason. I could never be the head of the family... I am so ill equipped for the job. I would probably wait for someone else to make a decision.
6. Would you be able to be in Leah's place in a pack full of guys, with all your thoughts out there for every one to here? Eeeek! No. My head is a scary place to be.
7. What would you say made Edward take the chance of changing Bella when he believed that it would condemn her soul to hell? Losing the love of his life. I think that Bella also helped him see that vampirism was not his choice and that it didn't change his goodness.
8. If you were in Bella's position, who would you choose-- Your childhood friend Jacob, or the outrageously gorgeous- but deadly dangerous Vampire- Edward?? Why?? When you love someone there is never a choice. In the end it all worked out.


message 23: by Barbara (new)

Barbara | 5 comments . Which book/s do you think is the best of the series and why? worst and why? I THOUGHT TWILIGHT WAS THE BEST. THIS IS WHERE I FELL IN LOVE WITH THE CHARACTERS...ESPECIALLY EDWARD. I THOUGHT NEW MOON WAS MY LEAST FAV JUST BECAUSE EDWARD WASN'T IN IT AS MUCH. AFTER READING THE BOOK I UNDERSTAND THE REASONING BUT STILL...
2. If you found out that your true love was a Vampire, but s/he didn't drink human blood, how would you react? IF HE LOOKED LIKE EDWARD, WOULDN'T BOTHER ME
3. Why did you first think that Rosalie didn't like Bella? AT FIRST I THOUGHT IT WAS BECAUSE ROSALIE WAS JEALOUS OF HER FOR HAVING EDWARD FALL IN LOVE WITH HER BUT I THINK SHE WAS JEALOUS THAT BELLA WAS WHAT ROSALIE WASN'T...HUMAN.
4. If you were a Vampire, and you were as rich as the Cullens, what would you spend you're time doing?? I'D SAY TRAVELLING AND READING. I NEVER HAVE ENOUGH TIME TO READ.
5. In the books, they talk about Carlisle as the leader and example to the rest of the family. If you were in his place, what would your reaction be when Edward told you Bella was pregnant?? I'M NOT SURE.
6. Would you be able to be in Leah's place in a pack full of guys, with all your thoughts out there for every one to here? THAT WOULD BE TOUGH, ESPECIALLY IF YOU LOVED ONE OF THEM. I CAN'T IMAGINE SOMEBODY HAVING ACCESS TO MY THOUGHTS
7. What would you say made Edward take the chance of changing Bella when he believed that it would condemn her soul to hell? SHE WOULD STILL BE WITH HIM AND EDWARD WOULDN'T LIVE WITHOUT HER.
8. If you were in Bella's position, who would you choose-- Your childhood friend Jacob, or the outrageously gorgeous- but deadly dangerous Vampire- Edward?? Why?? LOVE IS LOVE AND IT'S WHERE YOUR HEART LEADS YOU. I'LL ALWAYS BE AN EDWARD FAN; EVEN IF HE'S A VAMPIRE. WE ALL HAVE OUR QUIRKS.


message 24: by Savannah (new)

Savannah (namesavannah-catcherinsoftball) 1.My Favorite book in the series is Breaking Dawn. I like Breaking Dawn the best because...The Romance increases and the way they interact becomes more intent. I love the suspense when the Volturi comes. I love Renesmee... And in Breaking Dawn I start to like Jacob. The one I like the least is New Moon...because it is so depressing!
2.If I found out my true love was a vamp... He would be my true love...so it wouldn't matter!
3.What i thought was the reason that Rosalie didn't like Bella was That rosalie just had a bad attitude and she wasn't into liking anyone but family!
4.If I was a vampire and as rich as the Cullens... I would spend my time doing the hobbies that I LOVE to do... I love sports... I love to read.... I hang with friends...that might be a little bit difficult though!
5.I have No idea what i would do it I were In Carlisles Position with that!
6. I would not be able to be in Leah's Position... I don't know what i would do...but at the same time, i think it would be cool!
7. I think Edward gave up and he just wanted for Bella to have what she wanted... though to him it was the worst thing for her... He didn't really have a choice though when the baby came so he acted out of love when he changed her. I also think that he wanted to be with Bella Forever!!!!!!
8. If I were in Bella's Position, I would choose Edward. The love of her life. I wouldn't choose Jacob because he is a stupid, bullhead *******!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!


message 25: by [deleted user] (new)

1.Breaking Dawn b/c it has the happy ending and secrets are.....not secrets no more and lots of action. I just can't choose a worse one.
2. I would freak. But not be afraid. And I would say "Dang. This is exactly like Twilight."
3. Because Edward didn't like Rosalie and everyone LOVES her. When Edward was in LOVE with Bella, Rosalie is like "Ugh! I'm way prettier. How can Edward like HER?" LOL
4.Idling, daydreaming,spending, traveling
Awesome things.
5.Be shocked but would find a way to handle the problem.
6.AHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH! I would NOT live through that. Boys hearing my every thought even only for a while.........AHHHHHHHHHHHH! Panic...AHHH!
7. He wanted to be with Bella forever and she did too.
8. IDK..they both are really sweet and cute.


message 26: by Mikayla (new)

Mikayla | 76 comments 1. Which book/s do you think is the best of the series and why? worst and why?
Probably Twilight, because the story was so new and pure then, and the plot was the best of the 4.

2. If you found out that your true love was a Vampire, but s/he didn't drink human blood, how would you react?
So basically, like if he was Edward? I don't know how I would react because I can't even imagine a situation were that would be true. lol

3. Why did you first think that Rosalie didn't like Bella?
because she was self-centered and thought they were wayy above humans
4. If you were a Vampire, and you were as rich as the Cullens, what would you spend you're time doing??
hmmm
5. In the books, they talk about Carlisle as the leader and example to the rest of the family. If you were in his place, what would your reaction be when Edward told you Bella was pregnant??
I would be surprised and stunned, and tell him to come home immediately

6. Would you be able to be in Leah's place in a pack full of guys, with all your thoughts out there for every one to here?
Yeah, that wouldn't be fun, but I could hear theirs too, and we'd all be in the same position, so whatever.

7. What would you say made Edward take the chance of changing Bella when he believed that it would condemn her soul to hell?
Because he couldn't lose her. Even if he would just die afterwards anyway, he couldn't bear to see her die.

8. If you were in Bella's position, who would you choose-- Your childhood friend Jacob, or the outrageously gorgeous- but deadly dangerous Vampire- Edward?? Why??
Ummm, haha, can you tell that this is worded by an Edward lover? I would choose Jacob. He is a good friend and a loving guy, and HUMAN ;]
lol and completely awesome!


message 27: by none (new)

none (asdlfkgjh) 1. Twilight because I love meeting Edward at first.
2. I would be frightened at first, but stay wit him.
3. Rosalie didn’t like Bella because she was vain, so it bothered her that Edward thought a human was so beautiful when Edward wasn’t remotely interested in her.
4. It depends whether I had a partner or not. If not, I would spend it learning, traveling, playing sports, hunting, and running.
5. I would wish I could get her to have an abortion, but know that it was really her choice.
6. Definitely not, it would be so embarrassing, and sad too, with Sam.
7. If he didn’t change her, the only other option was let her die.
8. Edward. He’s more romantic and quiet. Also, he cares about Bella, and he’s not pushy or arrogant. Jake would be a great best friend, though.



message 28: by Heidi (new)

Heidi | 5 comments 1. Best: It's hard to say but I would say twilight because it bit from the very begining. That's what got me hooked. I had to find out what would happen next.
Worst: This is really hard to say because I really enjoyed all the books. But I would say Eclispe only because Bella and her refusal to say away from Jaocob and let him move on and be happy with Edward really annoyed me for a good part of the book.

2. I would probably be a little weirded out. But true love would conquer.

3. I think Rosalie was jealous of Bella. She was like her friend and Edward was like her freinds husband. That was waht Rosalie always wanted and never could have.

4.I wouldnt go to highscool! LOL. I don't know really alot of traveling. I woauld want to find a remote island to buy. Like Esme's island.

5. Fear this is completly unkown and could kill his whole family.

6. No way! Poor Leah.

7. His love for her and wanting to be with her forever.

8.Edward! The love between them was a love that would last forever. She would have never been truly over him even if she found a sort of happinies with Jacob. She would always longe for Edward.

reply | flag *




message 29: by Meaghan (new)

Meaghan | 8 comments 1a) Personally, my favorite book of the saga was Eclipse. I just loved all the Team Edward/Team Jacob sides, and I loved that Edward was back from the long barren time without him in New Moon.
1b)I know that I'll more than likely get a lot of frowns for this, but my least favorite book was Breaking Dawn. I'm not saying that it was horrible, but I had waited 6 months waiting for this perfect ending to the Twilight saga that I had created in my head, but I've got to say, the real thing was a disappointment. All the characters seemed very OOC, and I really didn't like the Renesmee plot twist.
2) If my true love were a vampire, I really wouldn't care. I know that probably sounds bad, but if I really loved him and he were an umm...vampire...in real life *cough, cough* I don't think that I would care.
3) Rosalie is such a complex character, I'm not really sure what to say. I'd have to say she was probably jealous like it said in the book because Edward wanted Bella and he had never actually wanted her, but I'm not sure....
4) If I were rich and had all the time in the world...hmm....I'd probably spend a good amount of my time traveling and learning and such.
5) I have to admit, if I were in Carlisle's positions I would have FREAKED OUT!!! I mean, they have never heard of anything like it happening before, and, wow, it would have been weird!
6) In all honesty, no, I don't think that I could do it. Having everyone knowing what I was thinking would be near impossible even if the people were my best friends, but to have that with a bunch of guys? I don't think so.
7) I think it was partially because he wanted her for longer than just a human life time, that seemed pretty evident to me. However, I think it also had to do with the fact that Bella wanted it so badly. I know that in the beginning he was completly admant about changing her, but the fact the being changed was what she really wanted...well, I think that that also had a pretty big effect on the situation.
8) Edward or Jacob....choosing one between that other is really a hard choice. Throughout the whole Team Edward/Team Jacob I am strictly Team Edward. However, that was what I wanted for Bella to choose because I always felt that her love for Edward was so much stronger. Picking one for my own life would be so much harder though. But.......my decision would be Edward. Edward is so sweet and kind, and he is kind of overprotective, but that would only be because he would want what's best for me. Jacob is sweet, but he's not match for Edward. I mean, come on, Edward SPARKLES!!! (lolz) :)


The Insane Psychopath Jane Volturi (janewhitlockhale) 1. For the best, I choose New Moon. It adds more than just love to the story, and you really get to see how deep Bella had fallen for Edward in Twilight. You don't just learn about the vampires, but you get to see past the Cullens and more at La Push. You learn the rivalry, which helps set up the plots for the next two books.
For the worst, it's hard to decide, but I think I'm going with the original, Twilight. There were so many good things in this book, but they just fell in love a little too fast, I think. There were just some things in there I didn't like.
2. Well, I can think of many things, but this one is the most likely. I'd probably freeze up, scream, then act like nothing had happened. Then I'd start drawing bloody/depressing things, and then become happy again. I'd talk to him about, and hopefully convince him to change me.
3. Rosalie, dear dear Rosalie. At first, I thought she was just a jerk. Then after thinking it through, I realized what could have happened. Then, and now, I feel sorry for her.
4. All of that money. I'd probably spend quite a bit of money shopping, like Alice. I would also travel the world quite a bit, that would be very fun.
5. To be in Carlisle position, I would have frozen up in shock, then probably passed out. After a while though, I would have come around and been all calm.
6. This is a tough question. I probably would have been able to though, as some of my best friends are guys. Plus, I have a brother who is annoying and always seems to know what I'm thinking.
7. I think he wanted her forever. He knew that if they both died, that she would go to Heaven and that he wouldn't. He changed her to stay together, I believe. He didn't want to be apart, ever. I think it also had to do with making her happy.
8. Oh my gosh, the impossible question. Now, I would absolutely love to be a vampire, but I have to say I'm Team Jacob. I wouldn't want to be with someone I had necessarily 'just' met, then someone I had known and loved for years. Edward is kind and overprotective, but I don't think he'd be fun. Jacob is lovable, and a freaking wolf, which I have always loved, and he would let me have more fun with dangerous stuff.


message 31: by Samantha (new)

Samantha (samanthan) 1. Best=Twilight and Breaking Dawn Worst=New Moon. No Edward!!!!!!!!!!! *sob*
2. Well, since I've read Twilight I'd be cool with it. Not staying with them forever, since I want to have a normal life, but it could work for awhile while we're still the same age and I don't want to have kids. And I'd ask them to get me out of town if any nomads were coming around, lol.
3. I first thought Rosalie just didn't like Bella cause she was a haughty bitch.
4. Not going to high school! I would buy myself a private island and chill there with the one I loved for all eternity. That's what I'm talking about.
5. I would want Bella to have an abortion, for her and Edward's sake.
6. NO!!! Are you kidding?! It's hard to be around guys when they can't read your thoughts. And since most of the werewolves are hot, there's no telling what I'd be thinking about them...
7. He took the chance because he had no other choice. It was his last resort. It was either change her, or let her die and have to raise the thing that had killed her on his on. I don't think Edward would have changed her if it weren't for the baby and her impending death.
8. Edward all the way! Jacob is just immature. Edward is so many wonderful things: understanding, intelligent, protective, romantic, musical. Jacob is just so teen angsty and he violates Bella's personal space by kissing her when she doesn't want him too. Edward has respect for women, and he listens to what Bella really wants.


message 32: by [deleted user] (last edited Jun 12, 2009 03:56PM) (new)

1.I think Twilight is the best because it shows their relationship starting out and how it all began. NewMoon and Eclipse are tied for worst. I don't like the Jacob-ness of them.

2.I'd be happy to have found them and them being a vampire would make me thrilled. Being with my true love forever would be one of the best things that could happen to me. Never having to risk them dying everday, never being scared that when I wake up they won't be alive. Although if they changed me I would get to spend every second with them, seeing as though vampires don't have the need to sleep.

3. I thought that at first it was because she was a danger to their family, but also a threat to her.

4.I'd most likely get books, so many books that I'd never run out of things to read. I'd also get music, any type that I love.

5.I'd ask if he was truley the father, not that Bella would cheat, but there is rape. It almost happened to her once. After being told nothing like that had happened I would be shocked, but than start asking quesitons that would most likely end up embarressing Bella.

6.It would be hard to say the least, but with my thoughts it wouldn't matter really, even if they are personal. They're just thoughts that would most likely annoy them all to death.

7.He loved her so much and not to mention the fact that there was no possibility of her living and he caused that for her, at least in his mind he would think,seeing as though he is the one who made her pregnet.

8.I would choose Edward without any doubt. Jacob loved me enough to fight for me, Edward loved me enough to let me go. While Jacob spent his time convincing Bella of the danger Edward put her through, Edward spent his time convincing her that everything Jacob said was true. But while he did this he still loved her unconditionally, doing anything in the world just to keep her safe, to keep her happy.The person who loves me enough to do that has my heart completely.





message 33: by Mary (new)

Mary Honeycutt (magnoliahoney) | 41 comments 1. Best was Eclipse because of the love triangle and there was absolutely no "worse" book. I'd read them all over and over again.

2. I'd be a little freaked out but I truly love him so I'd accept who he was. Nothing matters when you are in love.

3. I just thought she didn't want anyone added into the Cullen clan. I thought she was being overprotective, overbearing and selfish.

4. Absolutely the same thing...staying in one place long enough to feel comfortable there and then move somewhere else and do the same thing.

5. As a doctor, I would have been extremely worried for her health. And the fact that I love my son, Edward, and was so happy that he had finally found his soulmate, this would worry me even more. I would be concerned about how my son would hurt if his soulmate were to pass away.

6. Absolutely not!

7. He had to have understood her position too...that she wanted to be with him forever. He wanted her for forever too. I don't believe he ever really, truly committed to taking her life from her. I think he always had this hope in the back of his mind that she would change her mind and live a little longer. I think it was always a helpless thought in his mind. It wasn't until he had no choice but to revive her as a vampire or she would die forever that he prepared to make her immortal. He had no choice left.

8. Deadly dangerous Edward....fun, adventure, always being protected by him....to be loved so indefinitely and unconditionally would be wonderful!


message 34: by Elena (new)

Elena Hubner | 64 comments 1. Twilight and eclipse were the best because they had a good amount of action and they were page turners, twilight introduced the characters and eclipse brought them out well. New Moon was the worst. nothing happened, bella just complained about the hole in her hert and there was zero action.

2. A tiny bit freaked out but also like COOL! and if i really loved it wouldn't matter.

3. i thought rosalie was just a big fat jerk, not that she really isn't in BD. and she was just a B-R-A-T!

4. shopping! and i think it would be fun to play baseball, i'd hang out with emmett and alice. oh yeah!

5. crazy son! she's only 18! what was he thinking!

6. no, especially since they are all so obnoxious. but go seth!

7. what? i don't remember the whole condemning soul to hell thing.

8. i the book- edward 100%. he is so gorgeously put in the book. in the movie- jacob cause edward is just a meanie butt in the movie and he's not even that cute. but jacob is nice and funny. I'd want emmett though.


message 35: by Mary (new)

Mary Honeycutt (magnoliahoney) | 41 comments Elena wrote: "1. Twilight and eclipse were the best because they had a good amount of action and they were page turners, twilight introduced the characters and eclipse brought them out well. New Moon was the wor..."

LAMO. #5: "What in the world are you thinking, son?"


message 36: by [deleted user] (new)

1.) Which books do you think are the best of the series? Why? Worst and why?

I can't pick out a worst, because a few of them are a tie with each other. I have mixed feelings. I think Twilight and Breaking Dawn are on the same level, and I enjoyed them both. Eclipse and New Moon, could never be included on the worst, however. It's like apples and oranges for me.

2.) If you found out that your true love was a Vampire, but he didn't drink human blood, how would you react?

I would probably freak out, and reevaluate my entire existence. Google "insanity" and see if I fit the bill. Then after freaking out, I would refer to vampire novels. And then maintain my composure, before smiling like a maniac that something that cool actually existed. Then I would act all cool about it, as he told me. If he was my true love I don't think I would hold it against him. Although, unlike Bella, I would take it under consideration at least.

3.) Why did you first think that Rosalie didn't like Bella?

I thought it was because Bella had no regard for her own life, and she wasn't thinking enough about how her life would change.
Turns out, I wasn't too far off in my thinking.

4.) If you were a Vampire, and you were as rich as the Cullens, what would you spend your time doing?

I would probably spend my time honing my skills, like Edward and his music. I would practice drawing and writing, and playing an instrument, until I was good at it. When you have eternity you can do a lot of things. With their money I would buy the things I needed to practice such skills. An easel, oil paints, books, literature, instruments, lessons. If you have forever, why not spend your time learning?

5.) In the books, they talk about Carlisle as the leader and example to the rest of the family. If you were in his place, what would your reaction be when Edward told you Bella was pregnant?

I'd probably spring into action just as he had, there would be no time to get used to the idea before making plans. I would ask Edward to return home immediately to figure out more. But as a whole I would be thinking; Oh. My. God.

6.) Would you be able to be in Leah's place in a pack full of guys, with all your thoughts out there for everyone to hear?

Me being me? Sure. I always have trouble articulating exactly how I'm thinking and feeling, it would be a relief to know someone who didn't have to get my idea from my words, but rather straight from the source. It would be nice to have some input from the guys as well, as to whether or not I'm damaged. And to be the only female werewolf? Heck yeah! Days and nights hanging out with the hot quileute boys doesn't sound so bad to me.

7.) What would you say made Edward take the chance of changing Bella when he believed that it would condemn her soul to hell?

He changed his mind. With marriage and her lack of sins, and if she did the lifestyle the right way, he probably believed she wouldn't go to hell. Regardless of her species.

8.) If you were in Bella's position, who would you choose, Jacob or Edward? Why?

Jacob. He was there for her through the tough times. He was there when she crumbled by the mention of Edward's name. He gave his life for her time and time again, and always put her before his selfish needs. I would never have to mask my emotion for fear of making Jake uncomfortable, he had thick skin. He could eat with me. Make a the choice to watch me sleep, even though it would leave him deprived. When I was cold, which I often am, he could wrap me up in his arms and warm me and my heart. He would know everything about me, cause he would take notice. He would be honest, and tell me when somethings wrong, not fearing that I would take it badly. Jacob doesn't turn into a statue when he's upset, he doesn't hide behind any facadé. He let's you know exactly how he's feeling. He would bring spontaneity to my life. He wouldn't be an eclipse. Jacob Black would be my Sun.



message 37: by [deleted user] (new)

As you can see, I kind of love Jacob, more than anyone should love a fictional character. I'm not a fangirl. They wouldn't be able to say it like me.


message 38: by Christina (last edited Jul 09, 2009 08:56PM) (new)

Christina Russ (WEIRDteensAreNORMALteens) | 34 comments 1.Best: Breaking Dawn; it had a nice conclusion, and part of it was told from Jake's point of view, which was a nice switch. Worst: Eclipse; it was entirely too long and drawn-out to have just a fight at the end, which everyone knew the protagonists would win anyway.
2.I'd be totally happy and amazed that i can say that i know a vamp.
3.I actually couldn't make sense of it. I just thought she was a mean girl.
4.I'd probably spend my time reading books, like i do now.
5.I'd react in a calm way. What would be the sense in panic? I'd be worried for Bella, though.
6.Heck no. I'm a private person.
7.I think that he just didn't want to see her hurt anymore, after what he did to her in New Moon. After that book, Bella sure got a lot more than she usually got out of Edward; if she said jump, he double jumped.
8.Jacob and Edward are tight, but i'd choose Edward. His personality is more my style. Jacob's personality reminds me too much of my own. There would be nothing hew there for me to play around with. But Jake is awesome. And as a bonus, Edward's pretty hot.

And Melzz, you're insanely right about Jacob. All of those things are true.


message 39: by Amanda (new)

Amanda Kay (littlebee81) 1. Which book/s do you think is the best of the series and why? worst and why?
BEST.....Twilight b/c it's the 1st and you start to learn about Edwards family
WORST.....New Moon...b/c edward leaves lol



2. If you found out that your true love was a Vampire, but s/he didn't drink human blood, how would you react?
BE STUNNED AT FIRST BUT I WOULD STILL LOVE THEM...AND TRY TO UNDERSTAND WHY THEY CHOSE TO NOT DRINK HUMAN BLOOD



3. Why did you first think that Rosalie didn't like Bella?
I THOUGHT MAYBE IT WAS BECAUSE SHE WASN'T GOOD ENOUGH FOR EDWARD



4. If you were a Vampire, and you were as rich as the Cullens, what would you spend you're time doing??
WELL BECAUSE I AM SO INTO SCRAPBOOKING...I THINK THAT'S WHAT I WOULD SPEND MY TIME DOING...EITHER THAT OR PHOTOGRAPHY LOL



5. In the books, they talk about Carlisle as the leader and example to the rest of the family. If you were in his place, what would your reaction be when Edward told you Bella was pregnant??
HMMM...I WOULD PROBABLY HAVE THE SAME REACTION AS HIM.



6. Would you be able to be in Leah's place in a pack full of guys, with all your thoughts out there for every one to here?
NO WAY!!! I LIKE HAVING MY THOUGHTS TO MYSELF. SO I FEEL BAD FOR LEAH A LITTLE BIT FOR THAT.



7. What would you say made Edward take the chance of changing Bella when he believed that it would condemn her soul to hell?
HE WANTED TO SAVE THE LOVE OF HIS LIFE AND THEIR BABY I THINK.


8. If you were in Bella's position, who would you choose-- Your childhood friend Jacob, or the outrageously gorgeous- but deadly dangerous Vampire- Edward?? Why??
MMMMM....HMM....THIS IS A TOUGH ONE....I AM ALL FOR EDWARD....BUT I THINK WHEN IT COMES DOWN TO IT...I'D PICK JACOB B/C HE IS THE 'UNDERDOG'...NO PUN INTENDED...HE'S JUST SUPER SWEET AND WAS THERE FOR BELLA WHEN SHE NEEDED A SHOULDER TO CRY ON.


message 40: by [deleted user] (new)

1. Twilight and for the most part Breaking Dawn. Twilight because..just because..and Breaking Dawn because the connection with Bella and Edward intensifies.

New Moon was my least favorite because Edward isn't in it as much. :)

2. I would probably freak out...but then again if he looked like edward then i guess i could handle it.

3. I thought it was because rosalie was jealous of bella

4. Exactly what Edward spends his money on...cars.. :)

5. umm...freak out a little because she's human with a vampire/human child growing in her.

6. I would most likely die if everyone of my guy friends knew what i was thinking.

7. The love of his existence was going to die. not only would she have left him, but she would leave nesse as well...and so...he loved her too much to let her go. (plus its what she wanted.)

8. Well, i hated the fact that there was a love triangle, even though it made it more interesting..but still i hated it. But i would choose EDWARD! Because even though Jacob is sweet in his own way..edward was mature and understanding, and ultimately never pressured Bella. He loved her enough to change her into a vampire..the one thing he vowed not to do...why wouldn't you choose the vampire?



message 41: by [deleted user] (new)

Eleina wrote: "1.I think Twilight is the best because it shows their relationship starting out and how it all began. NewMoon and Eclipse are tied for worst. I don't like the Jacob-ness of them.

2.I'd be happy ..."


Too true..i loved your explanation for choosing Edward.




message 42: by [deleted user] (new)

1. Which book/s do you think is the best of the series and why? worst and why?

Well I think that twilight was the best book cause it really intruduced the story. and i think eclispse was the worst cause it was long and nothing really happend.

2. If you found out that your true love was a Vampire, but he didn't drink human blood, how would you react?

I would say "yes!" i would be safe!!

3. Why did you first think that Rosalie didn't like Bella?
I thought she was kind of jealous cause she wanted edward.

4. If you were a Vampire, and you were as rich as the Cullens, what would you spend you're time doing??

prob watching tv, reading, computer, shopping, etc.

5. In the books, they talk about Carlisle as the leader and example to the rest of the family. If you were in his place, what would your reaction be when Edward told you Bella was pregnant??

I would start freaking out especially since she was a human.

6. Would you be able to be in Leah's place in a pack full of guys, with all your thoughts out there for every one to here?

oh heck no! that would be really hard!

7. What would you say made Edward take the chance of changing Bella when he believed that it would condemn her soul to hell?

wait what???

8. If you were in Bella's position, who would you choose-- Your childhood friend Jacob, or the outrageously gorgeous- but deadly dangerous Vampire- Edward?? Why??

I would choose edward. i think i like him more becuse he is kinda more risky (i like taking risks) and he is really cute, but i would be really good friends with jacob if he keeps his hair short! :P


message 43: by [deleted user] (new)

1. Eclipse is the best because it is the most balanced out of the four. The worst for me is Breaking Dawn...I don't like Renesme

2. I would want to be a vampire with him.

3. I don't know but you kinda get that vibe that someone doesn't like someone else but you don't realy know why.

4. Trying to live a normal life and turn my loved ones into vampires so I wouldn't have to spend the rest of eternety (idk how to spell it) alone.

5. Let's get her some help so she won't die.

6. I don't think it was a matter of wether she was able to, but she kinda had to so if I ABSOLUTELY had to then ofcourse I would, if I didn't have to then I would choose not to.

7. He wants to make her happy in any way he can and if she wants to be a vampire then thats what he will do.

8. If I was Bella I would choose Edward because he would be my true love...if I was Bella and Jacob was my true love then I would choose him.


message 44: by Callie (new)

Callie | 10 comments 1. My favorite book in the series would either be New Moon or Eclipse. It's always hard for me to pick between the two. New Moon because we truly see the intensity of their relationship. (And for the epic scene in Volterra) Eclipse because of the greater amount of action and because I think it's the best written out of the saga.

The worst? I'm going to say the first book, Twilight. I still got hooked, but Twilight took me the longest to read and it felt like I was waiting forever for something to happen. I don't have much against Breaking Dawn, but I am noticing that some people on here agree with me and don't really like Renesmee. Sorry kid. But to clarify, I love them all!

2. I'd want to be with them forever like Bella wants to be with Edward. They don't kill humans, so why should I be afraid? They've been able to maintain control thus far, and I'd have a great amount of faith in them.

3. I'm not sure. At first I thought it might be jealousy, but I figured that Rosalie was too confident for it to be that. I knew that there had to be a truly deeper reason for her animosity.

4. I'd definitely take a lot of language classes. I'd also like to travel for a while. Then when I settle down, I like the idea of restoring older homes like Esme does. I enjoy renovating and seeing the transformation.

5. Wow, this is a very thought provoking question. On the inside I'd be extremely shocked and possibly speechless, but on the outside, I would do my best to keep my face calm. Even if I was currently unaware of what to do, I would tell Edward that it would be all right and that we'd handle this and that I'd be there for them.

6. I wouldn't want so many people to know, but if that's the situation, I can deal with it. It doesn't even matter that it's a group full of guys; any group of people that can hear your thoughts is bound to be a little uncomfortable. You'd just have to manage. On the bright side, it'd be hard for people to lie to me.

7. Hmm. Let's see....She was dying! *smacks forehead* Besides, after reading New Moon and hearing Edward say "Carlisle was right" without thinking he might still be alive, convinced me that he didn't fully believe that he was damned. (Yes, I figured it out before Bella! XD) Plus, Bella really wanted to be with him forever and Edward knew that she wouldn't just be leaving HIM behind, but Nessie, the Cullens, Charlie, Renee, etc. She still had so many people that loved her.

8. I'd pick whoever I was in love with. Being close to both of them would mean that I wouldn't be able to completely give either of them up. But if I have to, I need to pick my love. Since I don't personally know Edward OR Jacob I can't rightfully choose. However, based on what I do know, I do like Jacob's sense of humor, but I've got to pick Edward on this one.


Tiffany (Dawkins) Dawkins (tiffanydawkins) | 44 comments Which book/s do you think is the best of the series and why? worst and why?
Well Breaking Dawn has to be my best... I am a sucker for Happily ever afters!! I don't have a worst really, I guess if made to choose like now I would say New Moon just because it took me the longest to read!
2. If you found out that your true love was a Vampire, but s/he didn't drink human blood, how would you react? Well I don't know I'd like to think it wouldn't matter but really being a sane individual I would definitely think he was crazy!
3. Why did you first think that Rosalie didn't like Bella? I thought that she was just scared, Bella being a totally new concept to their lifestyle!
4. If you were a Vampire, and you were as rich as the Cullens, what would you spend you're time doing??
Everything!! Traveling, and making sure my husband and I did the good dead on every continent, in every country, in every city!!
5. In the books, they talk about Carlisle as the leader and example to the rest of the family. If you were in his place, what would your reaction be when Edward told you Bella was pregnant?? Same as his, I would help them in what ever way they needed me to, its not like their dating and marriage were a secret, he knew that they were in love and he did the right thing!
6. Would you be able to be in Leah's place in a pack full of guys, with all your thoughts out there for every one to here? I am a very open person so I could do it!
7. What would you say made Edward take the chance of changing Bella when he believed that it would condemn her soul to hell? Love conquers all, even rational thinking!
8. If you were in Bella's position, who would you choose-- Your childhood friend Jacob, or the outrageously gorgeous- but deadly dangerous Vampire- Edward?? Why?? Aren't we always attracted to the bad guys! lol Either one would be good!


message 46: by [deleted user] (new)

*hated all of em....
* *slap* LOUIS WANNA BE!!!!!
* cuz no one likes her
* 1st of all, y would i b a vampire? 2nd of all, y would i b rich? 3rd of all, WHERES LOUIS???!!!
* id have killed both of them long ago...
* to be, ir not to be, that is the question...
* so i could kill em.... (:
* neither... LOUIS!!!!!!!!!!!


message 47: by [deleted user] (new)

Lol, Louis fan girl. :D


message 48: by [deleted user] (new)

teehee!louis is awesome, but he scares me and annoys the heck out of me in the movie 4 interview... but i like him in the book XD


message 49: by [deleted user] (new)

XD


message 50: by [deleted user] (new)

O.o


« previous 1
back to top