Mockingjay
discussion
edit:
date
newest »
newest »
message 1:
by
Makayla
(new)
-
rated it 5 stars
Feb 16, 2013 10:23PM
I don't know but i'd rather be in the Hunger Games than the Holocaust
reply
|
flag
i would rather be in the hunger games
Kaylee wrote: "This is rather disrespectful to the Fixed that for you.
em wrote: "What's the Holocaust?"Faith is right in that a history book would be best, but until then, Wikipedia will suffice:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_holo...
Also, there are lots of good fiction books about it- you should search around and read some.
Faith wrote: "Delete this disgusting question."Once other people have commented on a discussion, it can not be deleted.
This is a horrible comparison........ And they shouldn't be compared; nor the holocaust trivialized.
Oh, I know what you mean, sorry . I thought u meant there was another dystopian sci fi series about it out there and the question was about surviving the HG or that....
em wrote: "Oh, I know what you mean, sorry . I thought u meant there was another dystopian sci fi series about it out there and the question was about surviving the HG or that...."oh- ha ha! okay, that makes sense...sorry!
OMG, I KNOW WHAT IT IS. EVERYBODY JUST CALM THE FUCK DOWN.
I would rather be in the Hunger Games. At least somebody won and I don't know, it sounds a bit more, fun, if you can use that word to describe either.Anyway I have a great strategy for the HG.
No really? Did you just compare a real life genocide to a young adult fiction? Hundreds of people at a time placed into gas chambers based on their religion, sexuality, outward appearance, genetic traits (among other things) and slaughtered. First of all, apples and oranges and secondly it feels like your comparison is bordering on being flippant and hugely downgrading the horror of the holocaust.
yeah, i'm kinda confused... there isn't really a comparison and who the FUCK would want to be apart of either?
Faith wrote: "em wrote: "What's the Holocaust?"Really? No offense but you need to read more history books.
Plus this is an extremely offensive question original poster. The holocaust wasn't a game , people w..."
^^ hahha! She told you
Hush now child, no one wants your opinion.
^^ are you kidding me! The Hunger Games was not worst. Plus why are we comparing something tragic that did happen and something that did not nor will ever happen.
Nicole di Angelo wrote: "Holocaust kills women, men, children, old people, everyone, after suffering of course. Hunger Games kills 24 in one sitting, and more here and there in the districts.In the end, I'd rather it be t..."
your SICK. the HG killed fake characters. the holocaust killed millions of REAL people.
Nicole di Angelo wrote: "Holocaust kills women, men, children, old people, everyone, after suffering of course. Hunger Games kills 24 in one sitting, and more here and there in the districts.In the end, I'd rather it be t..."
You disgust me.
Nicole di Angelo wrote: "Dude chill out!!! OF course the Holocaust was terrible I'm not saying it was ok! What I am saying is that if BOTH had actually happened not just the Holocaust, Hunger Games would be worse because o..."You. Disgust. Me.
it would not be worse... what do you think is worse? 11 million people dying or 23 stupid teenagers?! huh?! NO I WILL NOT CHILL OUT.
Nicole di Angelo wrote: "Both are absolutely awful, but can you even imagine having to sit there and watch while your child was hunted and killed for the amusement of the rich? During the Holocaust terrible things happened..."You disgust me.
can you imagine watching your children be tortured and killed... and then being tortured and killed yourself after that? Because thats what happened in the Holocaust!!! which is wayyyyyy worse than HG (even if HG were a real thing) oh and another thing is: you get to train for the HG... the holocuast people didn't know when the hell they would be taken away. they were forced to live secret lives in annexes (can you imagine hiding out your entire life)????? yeah, didn't think so
Kaylee wrote: "Lostshadows wrote: "Kaylee wrote: "This is rather disrespectful to the thousands millions of real people who died in the Holocaust."Fixed that for you."
11 million, yes."
really true. this isn't an appropriate conversation, especially because the Holocaust was a real-life nightmare. I find this very disrespectful guys :(
Nicole di Angelo wrote: "Yeah I got that, and saying it so many times doesn't change that. But please enlighten me on how you could possibly believe that having to live through the hunger games would be any betrer"i can't explain the un-explanatory. you can't even begin to explain which one is better. because they are both terrible. but the Holocaust is a real thing, and it should never be compared to a fictional game. that is just SO WRONG.
Caraline wrote: "Kaylee wrote: "Lostshadows wrote: "Kaylee wrote: "This is rather disrespectful to the thousands millions of real people who died in the Holocaust."Fixed that for you."
11 million, yes."
really..."
thank you for agreeing.
Nicole di Angelo wrote: "Dude chill out!!! OF course the Holocaust was terrible I'm not saying it was ok! What I am saying is that if BOTH had actually happened not just the Holocaust, Hunger Games would be worse because o..."I think you should stop posting things because you are VERY wrong and being very disrespectful.
Vee wrote: "Caraline wrote: "Kaylee wrote: "Lostshadows wrote: "Kaylee wrote: "This is rather disrespectful to the thousands millions of real people who died in the Holocaust."Fixed that for you."
11 milli..."
of course. you are very right
Got asked an opinion, gave it, sorry it bothered so many people, I deleted the posts
Wow even your ashamed of your cruel words you deleted you post. You disgust me
I would say, the hunger games because the people who die there are only a tiny fraction of the people who died in the Holocaust. I hate wars, useless and pointless.
This really is a disgusting topic.You want to compare the Hunger Games and the Program from Battle Royale? Go for it.
You want to compare 24 dead teenagers to another work of fiction? Fine.
I don't see how you can discuss a popular YA trilogy in the same breath as one of the worst periods in the entire human history.
Thank you^^^ I agree this is sooo beyond wrong.
I'm just going to settle this and say I'd rather be in the Glade.
YES!!! Go Gladers! Or I could be in New Pretty Town... or in the Dauntless faction, or in Everlost... (I could go on.) What about you guys?
^^^^ I could go into any of those too!
all discussions on this book
|
post a new topic
