History of Medicine & Diseases discussion
INTRODUCE YOURSELF
date
newest »

message 1:
by
Rebecca
(new)
Feb 09, 2013 05:48PM

reply
|
flag

Trude wrote: "Hi! My name is Trude. I'm a research student Art Studies and bookhistory with a strong interest in medicial history. I am especially interested in nineteenth century infectious diseases like choler..."
Wow, that sounds interesting. Are you looking at tertiary syphilis as a cause for madness with your thesis?
Wow, that sounds interesting. Are you looking at tertiary syphilis as a cause for madness with your thesis?

Glad to get to meet you both! On the group's bookshelf, I posted about 50 books from my collection which narrowly define the scope of this group. Are there any other books that we should look at or read as a group? I know we are all busy, so would a book every two months be too much (I am a moderator for another two groups and a member of four more.)

No, not specifically. For my thesis I will test Michel Foucault's theory on the representation of madness. Foucault claims that at the end of the Middle Ages the text of a book and the illustrations accompanying those words started to drift apart. This means that the images would 'tell' their own story of madness, a story that could be quite different than the book itself. For instance: while Cervantes himself - and more important, the printers and publishers that later on added their own prefaces etc. to the text - showed a keen understanding of the humoral theory that was still very persistent in those days, none of that could be seen in the illustrations. Until 1725 the illustrations of Don Quixote only show a generic knight on a horse accompanied by a squire on a donkey. And if I am right about my assumptions, it means that Foucault is wrong: illustrations will be very much linked to the text until way into the eighteenth century.
@Trude: what do you think happened during the eighteenth century to account for the disconnect in the pictures?

Well, the only possible explanation I can come up with at the moment is Pierre Bourdieu's theory of social Distinction. Starting at the beginning of the eighteenth century, the illustrations were based on tapestries that were clearly meant for more elite audience in comparison to the audience of the illustrations. But I am still trying to come up with a more logical and less obvious solution.
@Trudy: is there any difference between the eighteenth century translations (ie could the artist be influenced by the way the work was translated at the time into English and French)? Also, the political situation in England and France was changing at the time with the revolutionary wars upsetting the status quo. Could the pictures have reflected a more counter-revolutionary idea?

It's nice to meet you all and I look forward to some great discussions.
Welcome, Lori! Anyone have any thoughts on any medicine-related books? I am finishing: Gulp: Adventures on the Alimentary Canal. I am a big Mary Roach fan. Has anyone heard about some new releases or other books of interest?


I have read "Pox" and "The Panic Virus" is on my To Read list. Now that we have a critical mass of people, I will put together a list of books to vote on for our next group read.







Rod, because I live in Utah, Barney Clark comes to mind--he was the first patient to receive a permanent artificial heart, at the University of Utah in 1982. What an interesting project you're working on--I'd love to hear more about it as it develops. Hope the new year is treating you all well!


My name is Philippe. I'm physician biologist. I work also in health économy and anti-âging. I like multidisciplinary approach. I'm interested in microbiological problematics. For exemple the cholera épidémy at XIX° with role of the travelings merchants in the transmission of the disease. Why PR appear in middle âge with urbanisation?
But I like also psychiatry especially the évolution in XIX°


I propose to choose some subjects and to begin to work. I think that quickly we can find one or two who interest us.

Other subject, Plague. Read Daniel Defoe it's incredible. There is the singular personnality of Yersin. I advice you a novel "Peste et cholera" on his life.
So two subject


My name is Anne-Kathleen, I am a historian, and I am doing a PhD on the killing of psychiatric patients in Nazi Germany. I am especially interested in the history of psychiatry 1900-1950.
I hope to find some interesting books dealing with this period in this group and some discussions with other members.


I'm not involved in the health care sector, I'm just very interested in the history of medicine.

_ Asleep: The Forgotten Epidemic that Remains One of Medicine's Greatest Mysteries by Molly Caldwell Crosby
_ Rabid: A Cultural History of the World's Most Diabolical Virus by Bill Walsik.
Looking forward the book recommendations for this group.
Books mentioned in this topic
Letters to Doctors: Patients Educating Medical Professionals through Practical True Life Experiences: The BRCA Mutation and Hereditary Breast and Ovarian Cancer Syndrome Edition (other topics)Gulp: Adventures on the Alimentary Canal (other topics)